News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by kranner on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:18AM (#2082536)
Will someone please summarize? The link makes only a vague statement about incompatibility between GPL code and the App Store...
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by tzs on Saturday January 08, 2011 @04:36AM (#2082733)
People have posted links to the original thread and the FSF's long analysis, but a short summary might be possible. I shall attempt one.

One of GPL's requirements is that when you distribute GPLed code, you can not impose any additional terms on the recipient.

When a user obtains an app from the App Store, Apple makes a copy of the app and that is downloaded to the user. This means that Apple needs permission of the copyright owner to do this. For most apps, there is no problem, because the developer owns the copyright, and grants Apple permission to make and distribute copies.

When the developer has included GPL code that he does not own, and whose owner has not granted an exception for Apple, Apple has to obey GPL. That means imposing no terms beyond GPL on the recipient.

Unfortunately, Apple does impose terms on the user--you aren't allowed to use the App Store unless you agree to Apple's terms, which include limits on what you can do with the downloaded software.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by rahoulb on Saturday January 08, 2011 @09:33AM (#2083087)
So if the original authors of VLC (not the authors of the iOS app) granted that permission to Apple then this wouldn't be an issue?
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by tzs on Saturday January 08, 2011 @05:18PM (#2084120)
It would take all people who own copyrights of code in VLC. That would include the VLC authors, but might also include authors of other GPL code that the VLC authors used.

If a GPL project hasn't planned from the start to allow for the possibility of granting license exemptions, it is fairly easy to let outside GPL code get into the project without its authorship being carefully tracked and documented.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by abrahamsen on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:50AM (#2083223)
Yes. That might be quite a lot of people though.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by kurtsiegfried on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:30AM (#2082563)
http://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/vlc-devel/2010-October...

This is the original post by Rémi Denis-Courmont, on the VLC developers mailing list pertaining to the takedown notice filed at the end of October. In it he links to another FSF post about incompatibilities between the App Store licensing terms, and the GPL, as well as his rational for filing the takedown notice

EDIT: Sorry Callahad for the dupe, you typed faster than I did.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by huhtenberg on Saturday January 08, 2011 @03:08AM (#2082634)
So it was the FSF who pushed for the removal, and not Apple doing it on their own accord?

Also reading that older HN discussion from two months ago it appears that Apple had addressed the compatibility of the AppStore T&C with the GPL (by adding an "unless" clause covering any prior licensing between the user and the software vendor) - has this changed since then?

Can anyone care to comment without bashing either side? Thanks.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by sanxiyn on Saturday January 08, 2011 @03:15AM (#2082645)
Well, FSF and Remi notified Apple of the situation, and Apple removed them (GNU Go, Battle for Wesnoth, VLC).

As I understand, FSF and Remi did not request Apple for removal, they requested either Apple modify their terms of use to be compatible with GPL, or failing that, remove the app. It was Apple's choice.

EDIT: the parent added question about App Store terms change after I replied. I am working on that.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by masklinn on Saturday January 08, 2011 @05:14AM (#2082782)
> It was Apple's choice.

Apple's only choice was to remove it, they were never going to create a special set of ToS just for these applications, and they were even less likely to alter their overall ToS to be compatible with the GPL.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by DougBTX on Saturday January 08, 2011 @06:33AM (#2082874)
Even if they were willing to change their ToS as soon as possible, that would probably take a good few weeks of back and forth with their legal department. But a notification of breach of licence probably comes with an "immediate action required" stick, so the only thing they could do immediately would be to remove the app from the store.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @07:28AM (#2082937)
Apple's choice was to clarify the ToS, notably to explain if you are able or not to use iOS applications for professional use.

http://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/vlc-devel/2010-Decembe...

They preferred to plainly remove it.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by Schmidt on Saturday January 08, 2011 @06:03AM (#2082842)
Or they could use their approval process to figure out that the licence was incompatible with their ToS.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jonhendry on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:32AM (#2083015)
Why should they pay to evaluate the license someone else chose?
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by Schmidt on Tuesday January 11, 2011 @08:05AM (#2091769)
Because they are using their software? And the the entity that built the app for the "App Store" was not the sole copyright holder of the software.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by sanxiyn on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:25AM (#2082547)
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by biot on Saturday January 08, 2011 @04:50AM (#2082757)
So if someone wanted to be an asshole, they could send takedown notices for Pixie Scheme III (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2059242) as well as all other apps that are under GPL and Apple would no doubt follow the same approach and take them away?

Seems like a good way for closed source apps to remove their open source competition.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by rimantas on Saturday January 08, 2011 @05:31AM (#2082804)
Seems like a good way for closed source apps to remove their open source competition.

Not all open source uses GPL, thankfully.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by abrahamsen on Saturday January 08, 2011 @05:42AM (#2082812)
"Someone" needs to be the legal owner of the GPL'ed code in question for the takedown notice to have any legal meaning.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jonhendry on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:29AM (#2083011)
But that could be a tiny portion of the code overall.

One developer with a grudge can cause a problem, even if that developer has a tenuous connection to the project.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:03AM (#2082983)
If it has some code there, yes.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @07:26AM (#2082935)
FSF is wrong and totally biased. Not to mention outdated analysis...

http://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/vlc-devel/2010-Decembe...

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by ugh on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:31AM (#2082565)
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by callahad on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:28AM (#2082556)