News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by breck on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:23PM (#20823116)
It is simple.

Not easy, but simple.

This is the solution. It works for all other industries. If I loan you money to buy a house or buy a car, without doing due diligence to that loan, the courts tell me "tough luck" if you file for bankruptcy. But if I lend you $250,000 for an arts degree, the power of the state will force you to pay me.

That's insane!!!

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by harryh on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:31PM (#20823195)
Yes, and home and car loans still exist because if people don't pay it back there is an asset to repossess.

That's not the case with college loans.

Which is why they are fundamentally different.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by breck on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:36PM (#20823253)
> they are fundamentally different.

Perhaps it's good there are some things that are different. Some things are property. Some are not.

In history there always seems to be a trend for those in power to try and enslave those not in power, by putting property laws on people.

This student loan bankruptcy exception is one example. Intellectual slavery laws like copyright and patents are another.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by tptacek on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:41PM (#20823317)
This is a non-sequitur response to the point 'harryh made. Regardless of the underlying moral dimension of college financing, you can't rationally extend dischargeable loans to students, because they can default and discharge the loan with minimal impact on their life. If dischargeability became the norm, most students would simply not be able to obtain loans at all.

That may be a good thing, as 'harryh said. But that's not the point: the point is, at the point where you make student loans dischargeable, you might as well just concede that you're eliminating them altogether.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by breck on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:46PM (#20823362)
In reply to tptacek:

"at the point where you make student loans dischargeable, you might as well just concede that you're eliminating them altogether."

Have you ever gone through bankruptcy? Luckily I have not, but from what I've read it's a horrible thing to go through with serious consequences to your finances that takes a minimum of 7 years to overcome.

I think the cost of college would drop 10x. I went to Duke, and the gardens and pools were lovely, really, but perhaps some tables and books would have been the more appropriate use of my tuition money.

I do agree the IS bit was somehwhat a non sequitor, but there is a common thread here I think when people try to put property and ownership rights on things that nature doesn't make that easy.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by tptacek on Friday September 06, 2019 @05:35PM (#20900127)
I have administered and underwritten bankruptcies for others and feel like I have some direct personal experience with the process. I do not feel like the consequences of bankruptcy are sufficient to make it irrational to discharge 6 figures of college debt through the process.
Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by kasey_junk on Friday September 06, 2019 @08:45PM (#20901081)
I would have declared bankruptcy in a heartbeat for my wife’s loans & it would have been rational. I a) make good money b) have good credit and c) don’t have financial hardships.
Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by imtringued on Friday August 30, 2019 @08:28AM (#20837858)
The asset is a person who will have to undergo a repayment plan for 7 years.
Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by vonmoltke on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:36PM (#20823249)
> But if I lend you $250,000 for an arts degree, the power of the state will force you to pay me.

Why would the state not use the power of the state to make sure you pay back money it lent you?

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by breck on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:38PM (#20823278)
Because it's a dumb predatory loan that should never have been made in the first place. There is a type of business for making dumb loans and using force to ensure they are paid back: the mafia.

The mafias of old are nothing in size when compared to the student loan industry.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by bumby on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @04:13PM (#20823566)
Discharging loans and the predatory nature of them are two different arguments.

If they loans are predatory, make the loans harder to qualify for. It won't fix the predatory nature if they are easy to get rid of; if anything it will make them more predatory by likely increasing the interest rate to compensate for the increased risk to the lender.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by breck on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @05:30PM (#20824180)
This is completely wrong. The answer is simplicity, not more complexity that would come from "make the loans harder to qualify for".

> It won't fix the predatory nature if they are easy to get rid of

Yes, it will. People will stop hunting for more students to go to their schools with expensive landscaping if there were no government guarantees to ensure they get paid.

This is a very simple issue. Any attempts to complexify the issue I suspect are merely attempts to divert attention from the question of human rights and equality. I paid all my student loans and personally have only to lose if they change the laws, but it's the right thing to do.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by breck on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @05:58PM (#20824458)
> You undermine your own point with your assertion that that government guarantees are the issue, not the inability to discharge debt that provide the abundance of students.

I'm failing to see the difference. The government should not guarantee the debt and people should be allowed to discharge the debt in bankruptcy. The responsibility should shift to the lenders, not the government. The price of colleges should tumble. Some should have to close their doors. There should be a great reshuffling in the education space.

> "For every complex problem, there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong."

This is a great quote, thanks for sharing. I would say a more accurate quote would be: For every complex problem, there are infinite answers that are clear, simple, and wrong, but also a few that are right.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by bumby on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @07:19PM (#20825054)
The difference is that one presupposes the other. In other words, there fact that the government started guaranteeing and subsidizing loans created conditions that led to excess debt, which set the table for a need to remove the ability to discharge that debt in order to make the risk of lending acceptable. I believe much of this can be traced back to The Great Society program.

I don't think you're wrong, I think you're just focusing on the wrong aspect. Its the supply of easily incurred debt that is incentivizing high tuition. The laws regarding discharging of that debt are predictable blowback.

It sounds like what you're advocating is a return to the way higher education was treated prior to the 1980s, a time when many less people had degrees. The problem is that return is no longer a simple solution, especially when we live in a society that now requires 4 year and even graduate degrees to be competitive, regardless of whether the position necessitates it

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by breck on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @07:26PM (#20825110)
I'd point you to this paper pasted above: "https://repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article....

It's an unjust law enacted in the 1970's at the behest of dishonest people. It needs to be fixed. Pretending it's a more complicated issue is just a tactic to delay doing the right thing.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by bumby on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @08:13PM (#20825435)
Unfortunately the link is throwing an error me. If it's related to the bankruptcy law, I'm not advocating that it is moral. I'm saying it's part of a complex system that a simple repeal may have unintended consequences.

From my experience in an organization specially tasked to help redesign problem processes, I can only say that every single time someone thought a simple solution would cure a complex issue, they were wrong. I'm sure there's an occasional case that could be the exception to prove the rule, but it became such an inside joke that my boss had a desk placard that read (tongue-in-cheek), "All you've got to do..."

Unfortunately, for those adamant about their idealized simple fix, they could only be convinced by seeing it fail.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by breck on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @08:42PM (#20825590)
Oh, I imagine there would be a number of 2nd order effects. Another commenter mentioned that we might then see bankruptcy records preserved for 20 years, not 7. You are right about that for sure. It's like a big refactor. Often hugely worth it in the end, but lots of problems crop up along the journey.

I still think simplicity is the thing to fight for. Corruption hides in complexity.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by bumby on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @05:48PM (#20824364)
HL Mencken has a famous quote: "For every complex problem, there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong."

You undermine your own point with your assertion that that government guarantees are the issue, not the inability to discharge debt that provide the abundance of students.

Allowing the discharge of debt will not impact schools if the government still guarantees loans. If anything, it will exacerbate the problem by incentivizing more debt by reducing the risk to the borrower. It seems like you are conflating multiple issues in a complex problem in an effort to provide a simple solution.

Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by imtringued on Friday August 30, 2019 @08:33AM (#20837891)
Generally higher interest rates result in smaller loans because people can only afford a fixed monthly payment. A smaller loan generally outweighs the downsides of higher interest rates compared to a huge loan with almost zero interest because that huge loan will be used to bid up prices higher and higher far beyond the original value of whatever you are buying.
Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by vonmoltke on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:42PM (#20823328)
So you are calling the Department of Education a mafia? The Department of Education is the "student loan industry".
Re:Rich Families Are Legally Separating from Their Kids to P... by breck on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @03:48PM (#20823389)
I think mafia is a poor word choice. At least the mafioso didn't pretend to be saints.