News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by kragen on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:11PM (#20813369)
Do you think MOStek would have been able to survive in today's legal environment? I don't think so, and that's what worries me.

The SCO-Linux litigation wasn't complicated. It was just fraud on SCO's part, under copyright law that was well-established at the time. With the Google/Oracle precedent in place, SCO would probably win.

I agree that Levandowski, like weev, is profoundly unsympathetic, but we can't let that blind us to the precedents he is being used to set. If Levandowski wins his case, ordinary (and extraordinary) senior engineers will be safer from getting strangled by non-compete agreements; if he loses, they will be in more danger.

Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by rayiner on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @10:51PM (#20816445)
> Do you think MOStek would have been able to survive in today's legal environment? I don't think so, and that's what worries me.

What’s different about “today’s environment?” If anything patent rights are weaker today—back in 1976, there were no ex parte or inter partes reexams to challenge patents in the PTO. You had to challenge patent validity in district court, where the patent was accorded a presumption of validity and a high “clear and convincing” standard was necessary to overcome that presumption.

Looking briefly at the case history, it seems like the litigation with Motorola would have played out the same way today. Motorola had patents in the 6800 chip bus. As a result of the litigation, MOStek had to drop the 6501, which was socket compatible with the 6800. But the 6502 was a substantially different architecture internally, and was not socket compatible. (Moreover, that lawsuit settled when Motorola got the upper hand when it discovered that one of the MOStek’s engineers had taken confidential documents with him from Motorola. Taking confidential documents with you, which is what happened here, wasn’t okay back then either.)

Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by dllthomas on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:23AM (#20816763)
As someone who grew up in Santa Cruz with parents and friends working in tech, I feel the need to point out that the "SCO" involved in the lawsuit wasn't the same people as the "SCO" that developed the tech - the rights to the name and the software were purchased by Caldera after (it seems, although I'm less confident about this part) all that was left was at Caldera were the lawyers and MBAs.
Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by kragen on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @02:32AM (#20817402)
Yeah, I have several friends who were at the real SCO. They had nothing to do with this.
Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by jamespo on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @06:36PM (#20815148)
If he wins, why bother investing in research, just steal someone else's.
Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by erikpukinskis on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @09:23PM (#20816065)
No one else has done the research I’m doing. My goal isn’t to get rich, it’s to solve the problems my community is having.

If someone else wanted to solve those problems using my work, I would be very glad and would do something else with my time.

Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by azinman2 on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @09:43PM (#20816138)
That’s great for you — I don’t feel that way for me. Stealing ideas is one thing, but stealing a complex implementation is another.
Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @05:32PM (#20814594)
The Google-Oracle precedent is not actually relevant to SCO v IBM, because IBM didn't re-implement an interface copyrighted by SCO.
Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by kragen on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @06:45PM (#20815205)
You're right, of course, because it turned out SCO wasn't the owner of the relevant copyright.
Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by deelowe on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @10:00PM (#20816209)
True, but the bit about interfaces is also not comparable between the two. There wasn't a lot of commonality between openserver and IBM (RedHat) Linux. It's not like the libraries on one system would run on the other. SCO's seminal allegation was that code was copied between the two, but they never produced evidence. Likely, because there was none. The case was eventually dropped when it was determined SCO couldn't even make a claim to begin with and the rightful copyright holder, Novell, stated they didn't believe SCOs claims. Then SCO went bankrupt and the whole situation just kind of quietly went away.
Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by kragen on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:08AM (#20816705)
They did eventually show some “code”, namely signal.h and a couple of other similar files.

However, thanks to iBCS, it is actually possible to run SCO Unix binaries on Linux, and has been since last millennium. That's why interfaces like signal.h shouldn't be copyrightable: the goal of copyright Law is not to give SCO control over code their customers write.

Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @11:27AM (#20820727)
Not quite. The case is still active (!) in the Federal court in Salt Lake City. The judge lifted the stay on the case on May 14, 2018. Since then, absolutely nothing has happened. But the case has not "gone away" so far as I can tell.
Re:Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets by prirun on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @10:34PM (#20816386)
There are cases saying you can't copyright an interface:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotus_Dev._Corp._v._Borland_In....