> In the late ’50s, a Cornell scientist named Frank Rosenblatt had proposed the world’s first neural network machine. It was called the Perceptron, and it had a simple objective—to recognize images.
This is right in the article. They don't attribute neural networks to Hinton—they just note that he worked with them.
Re:A profile of Geoffrey Hinton (2018)
by TheGrassyKnoll on Saturday August 24, 2019 @03:41PM
(#20789257)
It describes how he had the idea as a teenager, inspired by a friend's description of holograms. In the next paragraph, the idea had already been tried as the perceptron, and had been disproven. It's ambiguous because that's how ideas are; the same idea will come to more than one person quite frequently.
> the same idea will come to more than one person quite frequently
This seems to happen as often as not. And sometimes the ones in the not category are that way for a reason!
Re:A profile of Geoffrey Hinton (2018)
by coziestSoup on Saturday August 24, 2019 @03:17PM
(#20789101)
A lot of such articles exaggerate many of the specifics in favor of a dramatic storyline. I find that I enjoy them most when I treat them like based-on-real-events documentaries - Not taking them too seriously, but picking up interesting little facts and ideas along the way.
Except you won't know which are facts and which are dramatized factoids.
Re:A profile of Geoffrey Hinton (2018)
by layoutIfNeeded on Saturday August 24, 2019 @03:16PM
(#20789100)
And yet we merrily accept stuff they write outside our expertise :)
Re:A profile of Geoffrey Hinton (2018)
by anonytrary on Saturday August 24, 2019 @03:33PM
(#20789209)
This is called the Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect[0]. People
believe things about stuff they don't know, even if the source is wrong about stuff they do know.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Crichton#GellMannAmnes...
I was reading somewhere that there are evolutionary drivers behind our cognitive biases. I wonder if this is because to cooperate in social settings you have to rely on other people's expertise.
It's amazing how often people mention Gell-Mann Amnesia on Hacker News. Seems like Crichton's strategy of trying to make the term more popular by attaching a famous scientist's name to it paid off.
Re:A profile of Geoffrey Hinton (2018)
by anonytrary on Saturday August 24, 2019 @10:08PM
(#20790908)
To be honest, I first learned about it on HackerNews a couple of years ago. Someone apparently reposted a link a few hours ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20789446
Edit: I turns out I misread the article, it merely suggests his chosen approach was neural networks, rather than that neural networks are his idea. I think honestly it’s written ambiguously by intent.