I can see personally defending both types of theft, and I agree that they are probably morally equivalent (all else being equal); but I'm not sure that one can make a blanket declaration that people generally do defend Indian patent theft. Do you have references?
Of course, the rice here was not patented -- according to the article, it was just a trade secret.
> Of course, the rice here was not patented -- according to the article, it was just a trade secret.
This seems to have little to do with my question, which was:
> > I can see personally defending both types of theft, and I agree that they are probably morally equivalent (all else being equal); but I'm not sure that one can make a blanket declaration that people generally do defend Indian patent theft. Do you have references?
Did you perhaps intend to reply to my parent (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20788203)?
:)
How? Want explain how that works?
Elaborate your viewpoint
Company invests $75 million. Gross revenues of $150 million. Net profit $75 million. Companies exist in perpetuity, so that net profit gets reinvested in new research to develop more advances.
Alternate scenario: Company invests $75 million. IP stolen and company recoups $0. Company goes out of business and a successful research organization that took years to build is destroyed.
You can equally well blame competitors for "criminally" driving you out of business.
Is driving a company out of business be now a crime for anybody else?
Innovation should always reap rewards, it's all dependant on how the owner wants it rewarded.
Some could share it as "open-source" if it was code, but at the end of the day. It's their choice, not from the thief.