I go through 1-2 cases per iPhone and have a mint-condition device when I'm ready to get a new one. What works for $30 throwaway Nokia bricks doesn't work for $800 smartphones.
I don't think I'm in the minority.
I've never had a case not outlast a phone, they keep up well, rubber cases I mean.
Purchased a brand new LG G6 plus which I put in one of those bulky rubber/hard plastic rugged cases. I dropped it a few feet one day and the vibrator never worked again.
I tried replacing the old workhorse with a Nokia 8 Sirocco earlier this year. The first time I dropped that thing the screen broke into a million pieces. I replaced it but dropped it again a few days later. Again it broke into a million pieces. I'm not fixing it again and now it sits on the shelf waiting to be recycled.
Most of the cell phone makers other than Nokia do not get this.