[dead]
Re:Deconstructing Google’s excuses on tracking protection
by clairity on Friday August 23, 2019 @03:18PM
(#20781501)
it's useful to know alliances that can cause insider bias, but the parent comment was adding relevant, mostly unbiased, and industry-knowledgeable information that should be encouraged rather than discouraged here.
and such a tool would ironically be a tracker (as others have noted).
Re:Deconstructing Google’s excuses on tracking protection
by Crosseye_Jack on Friday August 23, 2019 @03:05PM
(#20781335)
How would you monitor anon’s?
I know let’s build a tracking network (or join one, let’s say google as they are pretty large) and use that info to work out of their is a conflict of interest or not.
If said comment came from anyone else would it of been dismissed as quickly? Ok it’s Google so prob yes :-p
Re:Deconstructing Google’s excuses on tracking protection
by manigandham on Friday August 23, 2019 @03:42PM
(#20781780)
A better way is let the content speak for itself instead of relying on the person's identity.
Re:Deconstructing Google’s excuses on tracking protection
by Liquix on Friday August 23, 2019 @02:53PM
(#20781181)
Great catch + novel idea. But how would the tool distinguish between those sharing their legitimate controversial opinions (everyone has a right to free speech, no matter how 'brainwashed') vs. malicious active derailing?
Re:Deconstructing Google’s excuses on tracking protection
by acollins1331 on Friday August 23, 2019 @02:59PM
(#20781263)
Just knowing that the person is the CTO of adroll is enough. Let them speak their piece but it's basically a "this comment was paid for by" disclaimer.
Re:Deconstructing Google’s excuses on tracking protection
by pvg on Friday August 23, 2019 @03:01PM
(#20781297)
It would be against the rules of the site which disallow this kind of insinuation whether it's automated or not.
Re:Deconstructing Google’s excuses on tracking protection
by dredmorbius on Friday August 23, 2019 @03:34PM
(#20781691)
Evidence-based demonstration is not insinuation.
How HN decides to address that is a separate matter.
Re:Deconstructing Google’s excuses on tracking protection
by pvg on Friday August 23, 2019 @03:38PM
(#20781724)
There is nothing 'evidence based' here. There is nothing wrong with the comment, no evidence it is an attempt to 'discredit valid arguments or derail conversation'. That's just a completely baseless accusation and, again, the site guidelines ask people not to do that. The user's affiliation is listed right in their profile, to boot.
[Edit: mistook you for the original commenter and fixed that up]