Re:A Chunk of Trinitite Reminds Us of the Power of the Atomi...
by secabeen on Thursday August 22, 2019 @01:00PM
(#20770164)
There has also been some debate about the factors that contributed to the Japanese surrender:
https://www.atomicheritage.org/history/debate-over-japanese-...
Re:A Chunk of Trinitite Reminds Us of the Power of the Atomi...
by cryptonector on Thursday August 22, 2019 @08:52PM
(#20773734)
I've read enough of that to reach this conclusion:
- the motives for dropping the bombs were various, and it depends on whom you asked, but also dropping the bombs was not that significant a thing to the Japanese (for reasons given above),
- wanting an unconditional surrender seems like a legitimate or plausibly legitimate motive,
- and the Soviet entrance in the war definitely sharpened minds all around.
There were no medium or large cities left to flatten in August 1946.
I've read before, and I believe, that the Japanese military leaders and emperor were not that impressed with the A-bomb. And why should they have been? They already were ready for a one-condition surrender, and the U.S. did accept it (calling it unconditional, but the U.S. adhered to the one condition).