News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by Tichy on Thursday January 06, 2011 @10:21AM (#2075584)
You can't close apps on the Mac either (you can, but it is only for experts). I guess no uninstalling is just the logical extension of that concept.
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by generalk on Thursday January 06, 2011 @10:25AM (#2075597)
I don't follow. Command+Q and AppNameMenu->Quit both disagree with you.
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by statictype on Thursday January 06, 2011 @11:11AM (#2075804)
You're right. But at the same time I wonder how many users understand the distinction. You can get 'rid' of a window by either hitting the red x (which I presume is the same as Ctrl-W), Alt-Clicking the dock icon (which I presume is the same as Ctrl-H) or going to Menu->Quit (Ctrl-Q).

It's easy to understand this, once you realize that window management is app-centric and is organized by Application rather than individual windows but that's a subtle distinction most normal users will not understand on their own.

To compound things, for some apps,closing the window will actually quit the app. And for some, closing the window leaves the app still running in the dock but clicking the dock icon doesn't bring up.

Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by steveklabnik on Thursday January 06, 2011 @01:34PM (#2076511)
I know that an appeal to tradition isn't exactly the most persuasive of arguments, but the core Mac fanbase has been doing things this way for decades. I happen to like it a lot more.

Those few inconsistencies suck, though. Bad apps, what are you going to do? Well, you could reject them from a store...

Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by Tichy on Thursday January 06, 2011 @11:53AM (#2076044)
Have you tried to explain that to your mum?
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by philwelch on Thursday January 06, 2011 @01:20PM (#2076437)
My mother grasped the idea pretty easily, actually, but then again she always used Macs.

If it wasn't for Windows confusing people by conflating windows with applications, I suspect most people's mothers wouldn't have a problem with it.

Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by chc on Thursday January 06, 2011 @07:43PM (#2078024)
As a lab instructor at a community college, I explained this to hundreds of people. None had much trouble with it.
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by count on Thursday January 06, 2011 @01:18PM (#2076431)
Does it make a difference?
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by Tichy on Thursday January 06, 2011 @03:31PM (#2077017)
Yes, because my claim was that closing apps is for experts only, just as uninstalling apps.
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by Tycho on Thursday January 06, 2011 @05:05PM (#2077467)
But users can still see that an app is open because of its dock icon indicator, and also when they close the window, the application's menu is still visible in the menubar until they enter another app. So that helps.
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by stcredzero on Thursday January 06, 2011 @10:26AM (#2075604)
Actually, that's a pretty clever optimization for caching, IMO. The user tends to leave apps in memory, leading to much snappier performance on machines with sufficient RAM.

EDIT: And if you're savvy, you can always manage memory manually and quit from the top menu or from the Dock.

Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by jncraton on Thursday January 06, 2011 @10:38AM (#2075650)
If the OS is intelligent, the memory doesn't get overwritten until it is needed. Even if an app is completely closed and its process is killed, doesn't it's image still hang around in memory for the next time it is run?
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by thwarted on Thursday January 06, 2011 @11:14AM (#2075821)
The binary and libraries and accessed (and perhaps saved) files should still be in whatever buffers/cache the operating system maintains in the unused portion of RAM, but the state of the application is gone (unless the application saved its state and will restore it upon starting up again, of course).
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by glhaynes on Thursday January 06, 2011 @02:10PM (#2076681)
And it appears Lion is going to bring some help to devs on doing just that (saving/restoring state).
Re:Mac App Store: Open for Business by Tichy on Thursday January 06, 2011 @11:52AM (#2076038)
And the local disk is just a cache for the cloud. So installed apps are just cached files from the cloud. Hence my analogy holds.