As per the article, one of the author Macnamara claims that a complex combination of environmental factors, genetic factors and their interactions explains the performance differences across people. I couldn't access the original paper, however it would be interesting to see how they establish this claim. Also, based on the guardian article, the refutation seems to be targeted at a strawman since the original 1993 paper never claimed that mere repetition was not sufficient.
"Nonetheless, Bryan and Harter (1897, 1899) had clearly shown that with mere repetition, improvement of performance was often arrested at less than maximal levels, and further improvement required effortful reorganization of the skill"[1]
Even if the authors had considered only deliberate practice, it would be quite difficult to measure the nature of a practice.
1. http://projects.ict.usc.edu/itw/gel/EricssonDeliberatePracti...
Read more carefully next time.
It's just feel good science.
[0] https://www.tes.com/news/exclusive-growth-mindset-lessons-ha...
It might be sad for someone but I'm convinced that not everyone has the right talent to be a musician or to play a certain instrument. Some people are geniuses, others are mediocre at best. Everyone has his strengths and talents and it's only normal that we excel at very different things.
My belief in growth mindset has help me improve my communication skills both oral and written. However I also recognise that I have certain limitations based on natural talent. For instance, I’m likely to never to be as good at word games (i.e. scrabble) as many friends and family members. This is at odds with my growth mindset to a certain extent.
Maybe any skill can be improved upon but natural talent gives us an inherit advantage over the rest of the field.
In defence of nurture, 28% of Nobel Prize winning physicists come from families where the father was an academic professional. From the same book (The Cambridge Handbook of Creativity) we learn that this number falls to 6% for Nobel Prize winning writers. However, a whopping 30% of these writers lost at least one parent through death, abandonment or desertion. In contrast, physicists lead fairly normal lives.
Some people pick things up faster than others, but if you put more effort you can still catch up.
It also explains why even talented people still need to practice/learn/etc. to be at the top of their fields.
It also sets a ceiling. Beyond a certain level, no amount of work will make you any better, because you fundamentally don't have the cognitive skill or physical ability to improve further.
I've spent a fair amount of time with musicians, and talent can be very obvious.
You can have a room full of people who have spent years practicing and been through a degree program. They're all outstanding compared to most of the population.
But sometimes one person in that room will still stand out, because their playing will be insightful, compelling, and musical in a way the others can't match. It's an instant thing - it only takes a few bars to hear it.
They won't necessarily have done the most work, or put the most hours in. But they will, in some absolutely fundamental way, "get it" - usually from birth.
The hours and the work refine that ability and make it more obvious. But they can't create it.
The reason she explained to me once is that people see her perform and play and think that's just how easy it is for her.
She said to me once: "Noone sees the thousands of hours I practiced by myself in a dark rehearsal room without even a window at school". That was quite enlightening to me.
So, if someone says it's just "talent", its quite offensive to her. It's hard and dedicated work.
Both are necessary.
She gets upset because she bought into the culture that tells us we control everything about ourselves. Which is somewhat of a lie in many ways.
Also, any random person can learn to play violin sufficient enough to play in an orchestra (besides a physical or mental disability maybe). Maybe not professionally because that needs addition passion and dedication and there is a lot of competition. But playing good enough for a community orchestra that requires audition, pretty much anyone can achieve.
If you imagine every skill is a dimension, you'll be able to traverse to "proficient/adept" quite easily with some dedicated practice
I find the more interesting reflection is how much people overestimate their abilities in the more day to day/mundane skills that everyone has some proficiency in - think "conversation" or separately "running". Both things most humans can do but also most people don't get too much further past novice in them despite being things that we have been doing all our lives.
Turns out that without dedicated practice and good feedback loops, it's possible to stay a novice at something your entire life. So for me at least, talent is about your ability to improve at something with little to no direction.
When I think of the greatest salespeople I know, they have been honing the skill all life, but they also never had anyone teach them what they needed to know or what was important to learn. And yet when I analyze their lives and realize that from young they were constructing feedback loops for things like "how to be funny" or "how to wow a crowd" or "how to negotiate" with virtually zero guidance, I can only infer that this is what genius looks like...
The article should highlight more what kind of practice they refer to and what they think is the main contributing factor.
I think to become an expert in something like playing a musical instrument focused practice and repetition is necessary, so having the right coach is extremely important.
However, the most crucial piece might actually be the passion or willingness to learn in my opinion.