News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by agluszak on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @07:44AM (#20745770)
Yeah, so basically modals, banners, reminders to use the app etc. (vide https://www.webdesignerdepot.com/cdn-origin/uploads/2019/06/...) are new toolbars of the late 2010s (http://i.imgur.com/X7ipc.png).

I don't like the direction where the Web is currently heading. Shutting down open APIs, forcing users to use the one and only official app (Facebook Messenger, Instagram, Reddit's starting to do so more and more), ubiquitous tracking, aggressive ad targeting and so on.

How can we - users, programmers, hackers - fight this?

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by javajosh on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:08AM (#20745944)
Well, the fundamental problem is that Capital comes in and builds a really great Thing, a Thing that may not have been built without Capital, but then Capital wants a Return, which causes the Thing to decay. The thing Hackers can do, as in the OPs article, is to salvage the good ideas that the initial efforts of Capital managed to prove, and leave out the rest.

This won't work for individuals, in general, because writing good software is hard. Even if you rely heavily on 3rd party libraries like Jekyll, you still have to know how to pick those libraries, and how to use them, how to deploy them.

Personally, I think it's cool that Capital is willing to get into the fray, even though it so often ends badly. Often it does contribute something, even if it dies. People get mad at Google for axing projects, like Reader, but why? Consider all the market validation they did, for you, for me, for free. Consider all the product design work they did, for all of us, for free.

I don't even think it's bad that devs at Medium are, almost by definition, currently working on nothing but anti-features. It's just part of the Capital-driven software lifecycle, and they are feeding their families, and learning a lot. I can't even hate the managers who made unethical product decisions, because it was always going to be that way, and better to participate in the Capital driven software lifecycle and contribute something then to never have participated at all.

There are amazing, sustainable, ethical, Capital-driven software ideas still waiting to be done, and that couldn't be done without Capital's involvement, but clearly that's not Medium and its ilk. But as Medium declines and eventually dies, remember that this is the fate that waits for every project, no matter how successful, and they leave behind valuable information for us.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by 013a on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:45AM (#20746942)
I like to look at it this way: bad ideas, or bad executions of good ideas, or bad fits for VC, that somehow get funding and die before going public, or even better, get purchased by some bloated old company with too much money; the end result is a wealth transfer from the ultra-wealthy to the middle class. Paychecks get paid out. Stock options liquidate for something usually. Services get purchased to support the business even though they may not be worth supporting.

Right now, the VCs behind Medium are doing the world an amazing service. They're going to see almost no return on investment, but why would any of us "normal people" care about that? Its their money they're wasting. They're paying employees, probably a great wage. Probably providing a ton of benefits to attract talent, including lots of options, great insurance, snacks in the office, unlimited PTO. They're producing a product that is actively teaching competitors like write.as and ghost what Not To Do. I'd bet even most of their employees hate the direction they're going, which means they're learning as well.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by ohithereyou on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:20AM (#20746054)
>Consider all the market validation they did, for you, for me, for free. Consider all the product design work they did, for all of us, for free.

I have a feeling that their intent wasn't to do it for free. What happened is that they couldn't gather enough information about their users to turn a profit. Yes, that's what capital does, but the end result was not free for any of its users - they gave up personal data to use it.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by drinchev on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @04:07PM (#20751474)
> and they leave behind valuable information for us

Leaving information so far :

1. https://svbtle.com

2. https://posthaven.com

3. https://www.blogger.com

...

Not sure, but self-hosting was ( is ) the only way for me to sleep safe.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by tonystubblebine on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:00AM (#20747717)
> But as Medium declines and eventually dies, remember that this is the fate that waits for every project, no matter how successful, and they leave behind valuable information for us.

This statement makes me so angry with Medium's corporate communications. It makes total sense to me that you'd think this, but I also think it's dead wrong.

The problem is that Medium is not clear that they've just straight up changed. So it's not that they are the big free open platform they used to be with an annoying "upgrade to pro" ad model on top of that.

Rather, Medium is primarily a subscription service. Even though they aren't saying this, it's best to think of them as an open-platform version of Netflix where anyone could post an episode or show and get paid for it.

That switch came with a switch in their incentive structure. The incentives for posting on Medium used to be that Medium will bring in a lot of traffic from their network. But they now limit that to articles that are published inside their subscription service. So there's not really any reason to post outside of their subscription service.

This is what I think you're experiencing: the free, non-paywalled portions of Medium are dying because the incentives for publishing went away and the aggressiveness at advertising their actual product (subscribe for, they hope, great content) has become more aggressive.

Meanwhile, while the experience that ElementaryOS was using Medium for is dying, there's a new experience that's quite good and I think plays a nice balancing role in the overall Internet ecosystem. Medium is making a place that rewards quality writing, tries to eliminate writing for the purpose of marketing, and is pouring money into authors and editors so that they can invest more quality into their articles.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by javajosh on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:32AM (#20748082)
* > Medium is making a place that rewards quality writing, tries to eliminate writing for the purpose of marketing, and is pouring money into authors and editors so that they can invest more quality into their articles.*

Can you explain this a little? I don't see much evidence that Medium rewards quality - unless you consider popularity to be a proxy for quality, which we've all learned, painfully, is false. Certainly Medium doesn't offer traditional publisher-style quality improvement services like copy-editing, editing, etc. So I'm curious what you mean.

It's also not clear to me how they dissuade "writing for the purpose of marketing" - plenty of people seem to use Medium as a straight-up content marketing platform, e.g. consultants with newsletters driving people into their funnel, and they want a URL to park their content, for bookmarks, and a place for shared responses.

If Medium actually did these two things, I'd say that they were indeed doing valuable service. But it feels a little like the difference between ideal and real value proposition that the Google Play Store and Apples App Store have: theoretically those walled gardens can enforce higher quality, safer software for end users, and lower friction to revenue for devs, but in reality, devs pay a straight 30% of revenue for that low purchase friction, and whatever illusion of value the platform can plant in users minds with good marketing and PR.

Maybe you are saying that Medium can, rather than improve actual quality, build a reputation for focusing on quality. Then writers can enjoy a similar halo effect as devs on the App Store? It's probably worth trying, from Capital's perspective, but not from mine, because I care more about innovative product design (which Medium has, in abundance) than rehashing a well-worn, slightly devious, business strategy.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by tonystubblebine on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @12:16PM (#20748669)
I think you're proving my point that Medium needs to clarify their brand. They are actually doing all the things you mentioned.

Here's what I can see them doing.

1. You can't get distributed by their algorithm if your article has blatant sales or a call to action.

This removes the incentives for a lot of content marketers. Medium literally has a human read and filter every article behind their paywall. That's thousands of articles every day. It's not very sophisticated, but it's good enough to push back on most of the marketing pieces.

2. Medium's promotion algorithm relies heavily on their Topic feature and topics are all manually curated by editors.

Topics, i.e. Programming, Data Science, etc, trigger most of Medium's distribution paths. They get an article promoted to people in the app and they get the article in the mix to be promoted over email.

3. Medium's Owned & Operated pubs (their term for their internally run ones) do very heavy story edits.

A copy edit is when you do light grammar and spelling and occasionally wording changes. But a story edit goes much deeper often taking several hours. Many of these articles are original commissioned pieces, but I know Medium often "elevates" (their term) an article from the general platform. Here's an example of how deeply an elevated article gets edited: https://twitter.com/tonystubblebine/status/11533445070871633...

4. Medium is increasingly paying for copy editing

I run two publications that do copy edits. They are my copy editors, but are paid for by Medium. These pubs are community aggregators, i.e. they publish a lot. I think there's some value in this even though I know the highest quality articles require a lot more time and editing. Anyway, we copy edit about 500 articles a month.

5. Medium is experimenting with paying for external story editors.

I think my original pub, Better Humans, is the only partner publication they have that gets paid to do a story editor. We have someone with subject matter expertise spend 4-5 hours on each piece reading each sentence for "is this true?" and "could someone follow this advice?" And we do all the normal editing things like sending a piece back for revisions.

---

In sum, I think Medium is trying to have it both ways.

One way is a high volume of "better than the rest of the internet" content. That's how my two new pubs operate. We just want to clean them up and filter out the worst ulterior marketing motives. But we are definitely volume first.

And then in a different dimension, they want to have prestige publications that feel must-read. I think this dimension is much harder, but it looks like they'll get there. (And I know they want to).

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by agustif on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:05AM (#20747771)
> Medium is making a place that rewards quality writing, tries to eliminate writing for the purpose of marketing, and is pouring money into authors and editors so that they can invest more quality into their articles.

As someone who by principle wont ever pay that subscription, my experience is quite the contrary having all those metrics you say, going to the shit, starting from quality content...

Maybe some great articles get hidden behind the paywall but mostly to me it seems all low-quality click-bait shit now, and on top of it they put the modals and stuff...

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by tonystubblebine on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:15AM (#20747881)
We made the transition from just publishing anything that got submitted to doing much deeper editing. Maybe not the topic you care about but here's an example of what we were able to do with an editorial budget: https://link.medium.com/uMM1k1cgjZ
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by CathedralBorrow on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:27AM (#20748006)
Just curious, which principle is that?
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by SahAssar on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @02:43PM (#20760206)
> Well, the fundamental problem is that Capital comes in and builds a really great Thing, a Thing that may not have been built without Capital, but then Capital wants a Return, which causes the Thing to decay.

I feel like most of the examples of this are the other way around: Great Thing is built without a lot of capital (other than a bit to get started, if even that), then gets a bit of traction, and then Captial comes in and the demands for increased ever revenue starts, even if it might not lead to profits.

We really need to have a concept of a sustainable startup, not just "hyper-scale or bust". That is what normal people call a "business".

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by michaelbrave on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:14AM (#20757349)
I have to politely disagree about Reader, it was already proven and working well, what they did was a bit of a scorched earth tactic, other companies couldn't compete with free and died. Then they pulled out and left a vacuum which has lead to a significant decline in in the usage of RSS in the modern web.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by SahAssar on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:06AM (#20745935)
> How can we - users, programmers, hackers - fight this?

By doing exactly what ElementaryOS did here: stop using these platforms. And if you have to use them (as a user), try to use them in the most open way possible: Never via a dedicated app, preferably via RSS or similar for the platforms where it is suitable and where it is supported (like youtube).

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by chris_wot on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:36AM (#20746196)
This is correct. The readers should not be the ones paying for this, it should be the publishers who use the platform.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by giancarlostoro on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:21AM (#20746057)
Improve existing platforms: Wordpress, Ghost, etc.

There's none of that nonsense on those open source platforms.

An aside: Tumblr isn't hostile like Medium is. At least not last I used it. I prefer seeing Tumblr to medium you can really just do any kind of blog you want whether it's a meme feed, or some serious blogging.

Edit: Forgot to add, also Tumblr lets you optionally advertise to non-logged in users to join Tumblr, and it's not a modal, just a button on the top right hand corner where the "Follow" button shows up to logged in users, or you can hide it entirely.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by ymolodtsov on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:23AM (#20746695)
Haven’t you noticed a glaring difference between these platforms, namely the fact that Wordpress and Ghost have a completely different business model and basically no social layer to distribute the content?

That’s why they don’t have such problems – but this is also they reason most people don’t care about them.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by giancarlostoro on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:40AM (#20748199)
My point somewhat still stands though. You've got Tumblr which has a social layer through likes, reblogging, and even "Ask'ing" and messaging other users.

Then you've got projects like Mastodon, and specs like ActivityStreams that have not been adopted by Ghost or WordPress yet, but there's no reason plugins can't be made, these would add a social element to these blogging platforms and turn them into federated blogging platforms. This is just a side thought, but it's not impossible for WordPress and Ghost to get there. WordPress is used more than most realize.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by claudiulodro on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @10:01AM (#20747123)
WordPress powers 1/3 of all sites on the internet . . .
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by martin_a on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @10:05AM (#20747168)
And it's getting worse by setting the wrong priorities.

OPs point stands though, as there is no platform like YouTube where you can easily discover similar content. wordpress.com is not really the place for that, either.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by SahAssar on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @03:03PM (#20760444)
Since the whole oath & GDPR thing happened Tumblr is actively hostile to EU visitors. That might not be you, but basically to see any tumblr content I have to agree to a kitchen-sink of data collectors, trackers and other stuff.

Medium still works like a charm, especially with JS turned off.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by Nextgrid on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @07:52AM (#20745829)
As users, a step in the right direction would be to vote with your wallet, not use nasty services and prefer respectful services wherever possible.

As engineers & designers, we need to stop being complicit and building this shit nor working for such awful companies. If the majority of engineers become ethical then companies like Facebook, Google, etc will have a hard time hiring people to do their dirty work.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by thelittleone on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:05AM (#20745926)
> As users, a step in the right direction would be to vote with your wallet, not use nasty services and prefer respectful services wherever possible.

I'd love an app where I could define companies, people and perhaps countries I don't want to pay so that I'm notified when browsing to a site, or scanning a product to buy so that my time and money could be invested elsewhere.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by pjc50 on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:10AM (#20745961)
Adblocking is a good start. For physical products .. it's a lot harder. I don't want to go full "no ethical consumption under capitalisim", since that's useless, but basically everything that isn't specifically marketed as ethical probably is doing something wrong in the supply chain somewhere, and half of the "ethical" claims are dubious too.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by thelittleone on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:21AM (#20746063)
> I don't want to go full "no ethical consumption under capitalism"

True but one step at a time in the right direction is all it takes for change. Say if I got shafted by Expedia. I would like to add them to my "do not buy" list and have their other brands (e.g. orbitz, travelocity etc) added to the do not buy list. Could make it social so that if my sister got shafted by some company I could see that too and opt for an alternative. There are often stories about unethical companies (Monsanto for example which is now owned by Bayer). I'd like to avoid them, but the burden of doing so prevents it. Lower that burden, provide alternatives and maybe over time we'd see improved ethics and accountability.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by tobr on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:08AM (#20746516)
Is there a way to restrict your card so you can’t buy things from certain vendors? Then you could subscribe to a list of boycotts based on which ethical questions are important to you.

I’m not sure how else to keep track of everything you want to vote-with-your-wallet against.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by chrismatheson on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:20AM (#20746655)
Monzo API might make this possible....
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by artsyca on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:12AM (#20745983)
Groupthink, impostor syndrome and 'fitting-in-ism' rule the day Nextgrid, there's no chance you're going to get a fresh grad out of university fighting for 'ethics' when they're too busy jumping hoops for their management overlords
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by dylan604 on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:51AM (#20746338)
Or more simply just trying to make rent, school loan payments, etc. When you're broke, ethics are hard to keep when someone is promising lots of money.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by artsyca on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:10AM (#20745965)
agluszak, I've been around modern technology since the very beginning, before the Apple ][ days when the web wasn't much more than a gleam in Tim Berners-Lee's eyes and 'Money for nothing' by Dire Straits was the cutting edge of computer graphics and MTV was the closest thing anyone had to streaming media

I've witnessed the rise of the machines from a unique vantage point just across the y2k horizon which makes me uniquely qualified to describe the evolution of the so-called 'technology professional' born of the nexus of home-brew computing, video gaming, sci-fi and old corporatism -- the modern 'tech bro' if you will

I tell you for sure it's the attitude of the casually invested subtly egotistical tech pro intermingling with the traditional corporate stereotype that has brought us here and the only way out is to bootstrap ourselves out of the shadows and take over the system from the inside out by becoming sentient adults rather than code weaving pithicathropus. Our black monolith moment is way overdue

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by DaveWalk on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @12:44PM (#20749022)
Upvoted for being pithy and beautiful. Where's our manifesto? Can I suggest you write it?
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by chasing on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:32AM (#20748074)
> How can we - users, programmers, hackers - fight this?

my_article.html

Uploaded into a public directory on a web server.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by justaguyhere on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:01AM (#20746442)
As users, I guess we can start with paying for good content, tools, apps etc. Most of us don't even pay for something as important as email, and then complain about Google's non existent support for GMail etc.

The other thing we could do is intentionally support good, honest indie makers over mega corps (but there is no guarantee they won't sell to mega corps).

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by ben_jones on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @07:59AM (#20745882)
Disincentivize company founders from cashing out to the detriment of their users by moving the cradle of these technologies to a place where you can respectably buy a house and raise kids without millions of dollars.

We did this to ourselves through decades of equating personal wealth to community and social value.

Which is ironic given the economic purpose of hacker news.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by Santosh83 on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @07:51AM (#20745822)
By use a diverse set of browsers and minimally using apps, we can slow down the silo'ing of the Internet. If users don't blindly buy into every app out there, big corps will have little choice but to interoperate on the open web.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by agluszak on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:13AM (#20745991)
But the big companies do everything that's possible to stop us from using browsers and plain, old websites. Users are not blind, but choosing not to conform to corps' will requires knowledge (why and how, because dark design patterns are called dark for a reason)
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by batat on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @05:54AM (#20755839)
I quit using Imgur because of agressive promotion of their app. Actually you can't even upload an image, neither view a full-size image on mobile version now.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by sjamaan on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @07:57AM (#20745865)
Also by setting good examples and not using this shit ourselves, even if it's the expedient option.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by drinchev on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @04:14PM (#20751564)
There needs to be an app that has the ability to connect ( via oAuth, whatever ) with DigitalOcean / AWS and that can generate a static website out of a WordPress(-like) editor, keeping the state in the cloud - again DO or whatever in a managed database.

The app should cost <20$ ( or be open sourced ) and it should have a huge eco-system of themes / plugins, including paid ones.

Sadly this app will never have an IPO or growth rate worth investing, but it will fix the problem ( for a while ).

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by hawski on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:26AM (#20746723)
I think we should code around them, instead of writing comments on HN.

Me included. I previously wanted to write an elaborate comment, but I should really focus more on productive endeavors.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by agluszak on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:48AM (#20746988)
To be honest, I find writing comments and discussing on this topic very important. Maybe on HN people are aware of such practices and know how to mitigate them, but the general public need to be educated, otherwise they will be completely helpless and at the mercy of corporations relentlessly trying to "monetize" them.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by tomcooks on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:32AM (#20748063)
Avoid those sites, and when asked for feedback mention the problems (a great place for feedback is the customer serivce chat, followed with a FU, enter and a ctrl+w)
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by fnord123 on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:08AM (#20747800)
>How can we - users, programmers, hackers - fight this?

Pardon the interruption -> close window.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by fredthomsen on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:43AM (#20746275)
Well it is being fought on some level. More and more blogs have moved off of medium and hosting their own. I sense that rss is making a bit of a comeback as well
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by agluszak on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @10:03AM (#20747144)
Yeah, but I meant the more general problem of "modalization" and monetization of the Web, biggest service providers like Facebook or Google shutting down their open APIs and pushing us not towards common, open web standards, but towards some sort of closed bubbles or silos. Rss may have its own niche, especially among the hacker community, but most non-tech people will rely on Facebook or Twitter for staying up to date with sites/topics/people they wish to follow. And both FB and Twitter are neither open nor free (as in freedom)
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by WBrad on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:32AM (#20746790)
I believe the only way to combat this as users is to use agnostic tools. When a website, program or other service wants to force you to use a specific thing to access them just view in a web browser with ad/script blocking or choose to not view it at all if that isn't an option.

As programmers we can refuse to implement such nagware. There's not much worker solidarity in our field so quitting is usually the only option if the company has made up their mind on the matter.

Overall I don't believe it can be stopped at this point. This process is called privatizing the commons and it will continue to happen to every common good as long as capitalism is the system which we work under.

Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by klarstrup on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:37AM (#20746839)
Your point on worker solidarity got me thinking. In some countries(such as mine) we have decent unionization rates for IT workers, would it be a good idea to have such ethical issues encoded into the union lines?
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by WBrad on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:46AM (#20746951)
Absolutely. If you feel you are creating a product that has a negative impact on the people you are serving you should do something about it. Unions can greatly benefit society should they choose to.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by agluszak on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @10:11AM (#20747217)
But it appears that the issue of ethics in IT is almost non-existent. From a perspective of a CS student - everyone around wants to work at Google/MS/FB because that's the bleeding edge of technology, but no one gives a shit about corporation business practices and their consequences on privacy and digital wellbeing of other people.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by WBrad on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:04AM (#20747754)
Do you think we could do anything to change the industry for the better?
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by klarstrup on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @11:58AM (#20748433)
I wouldn't be surprised to learn that there is actually a code of ethics within my union, I'll try to seek it out and see what we may want to do. Could be cool.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by WBrad on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:12AM (#20757333)
If you do find it could you let me know about it? I'd love to see it.
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by mikaelmello on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:24AM (#20746705)
I guess you meant late 2000s? We are in the late 2010s right now!
Re:Why ElementaryOS Left Medium by agluszak on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:53AM (#20747047)
Yes, and I meant 2010s, because that's when all these aggressive modals urging you to log in/subscribe/etc. started to appear. This may be a bias, but to me the Web used to be a much more peaceful place when a simple adblock sufficed to browse it without pain