News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia announces Project Denver ARM CPU for the desktop by anonymous246 on Thursday January 06, 2011 @01:16AM (#2074294)
Do you have any insights into why then x86 chips consume so much power than the ARM equivalents?

Btw, I tend to agree with you,and think Intel's engineers are just being lazy wrt power. I expect this Nvidia chip to get crushed technically when Intel's engineers gear up and really work on power (like they did when Transmeta's Crusoe came out).

Re:Nvidia announces Project Denver ARM CPU for the desktop by wtallis on Thursday January 06, 2011 @01:42AM (#2074350)
There's probably quite a bit of truth to that, but in recent years Intel has had two dramatic under-performers (Atom can't come close to ARM and the on-chip graphics for their mid-range processors have yet to fill the gap left when Intel forced NVidia to stop making integrated graphics chipsets) and a complete failure (Larrabee) that seem like they shouldn't have happened given Intel's dominance.

Why is Intel having trouble broadening their horizons? Is it an institutional thing, that the teams not working on the main (and most profitable) CPU product lines just can't get the resources needed to catch up with the competition? Intel always has the latest and greatest fabs, but it seems like the designs they're producing for these new product lines are completely squandering that advantage and then some.

Re:Nvidia announces Project Denver ARM CPU for the desktop by wmf on Thursday January 06, 2011 @03:21PM (#2076977)
There really aren't equivalent x86 and ARM processors yet; IIRC even the slowest Atom is faster than the fastest Cortex A8 (I'm still waiting on A9 benchmarks).

I don't think Intel is being lazy, but Atom is certainly an immature design and the mainstream Intel cores target a much higher level of performance; brainiac cores are fundamentally inefficient because power efficiency decreases as performance increases (in other words, each marginal increase in performance costs more in power than the previous one).

Re:Nvidia announces Project Denver ARM CPU for the desktop by miloshasan on Thursday January 06, 2011 @02:25AM (#2074454)
I suspect that the inability to bring down power isn't just "laziness" on Intel's part. Decreasing power consumption is (more or less) equivalent to increasing performance per watt - an area where Nvidia and ARM designs may simply be better.
Re:Nvidia announces Project Denver ARM CPU for the desktop by effn on Thursday January 06, 2011 @03:06AM (#2074564)
Many arm chips support both a RISC ISA (the original ARM), and a more CISC-y ISA (thumb2). They consume less power and perform better with the latter. So well, in fact, that some chips don't even bother with the legacy RISC mode.
Re:Nvidia announces Project Denver ARM CPU for the desktop by darren_ on Thursday January 06, 2011 @04:25AM (#2074709)
Thumb and Thumb2 really aren't any more 'CISC'-y then ARM; about the most cisc aspect would be that thumb2 supports two different instruction lengths (2 and 4 byte) whereas ARM supports only 4 byte instructions.

That said i've heard/read that Thumb2 tends to be the optimum size/space trade-off, but that's not because it's somehow more 'cisc'.

Re:Nvidia announces Project Denver ARM CPU for the desktop by Aegean on Thursday January 06, 2011 @03:46AM (#2074639)
legacy RISC mode? last time I checked it was called the ARM mode, which is the absolute standard.

Thumb has benefits, but there are also limitations which is why I wouldn't call it a replacement.

Re:Nvidia announces Project Denver ARM CPU for the desktop by crnflke on Thursday January 06, 2011 @06:41AM (#2074937)
Not anymore - Thumb2 is the new standard and supports everything that ARM does (at least, the last I read it did).

One of the big differences is that you now need a marker instruction for predicated sequences, but obviously the encoding is quite different.

Re:Nvidia announces Project Denver ARM CPU for the desktop by Tamerlin on Friday January 07, 2011 @02:34AM (#2078951)
If this were another TransMeta, I'd agree, but the situation is quite different, because Intel is very early in their learning curve on graphics, and nVidia is quite far along in their learning curve on graphics and high-performance computing. They actually have a decent shot at competing with Intel in the low end of the desktop market by making up with the GPU what they end up lacking in the CPU.