I guess the main risk is that doing this might wake up the provider who would then finish their rollout to get those customers back, and undercut you on price. So it would need to be quick and easy to grab your box and move it to some other neighbourhood in that scenario.
These guys are doing that around the Boston area. They aren't in my area yet but I have friends who have signed up and had good experiences.
It's very expensive.
...or how much of an issue it would be to plug into what's already there, but hopefully it's not terrible assuming the existing provider would agree to let you in.
They won't let you in.
I guess the main risk is that doing this might wake up the provider who would then finish their rollout to get those customers back, and undercut you on price.
And they also do that. National ISPs can afford to lose money in one city in the short term but you can't.
A few players like this tried to use streetlights for this sort of thing with WiFi. Hanging a WiFi point on a pole is outrageous unless the city owns the pole and plays ball.
EDIT: In comparison, the same dsl provider on streets that have had their lines upgraded offers 100Mbps plans for about $30 less per month than the cable provider. So some homes actually do enjoy a little healthy competition, but it hasn't been enough to cause any changes in the cable plan pricing yet :(