1) Release a really slick smartphone that is a huge hit
2) Release arguably the most seamless and well integrated app marketplace in history
3) Get boatloads of developers to develop for the new platform
4) Release the iPad to a willing, educated audience, with a huge catalog of existing apps
That's a lot of moves to be behind. Changing the OS is a start, but far from sufficient.
But of course they shot themselves in the foot a couple months back when they crippled indie game developers.
* The big buttons and slide-to-expand of the new Taskbar
* Multi-touch gestures in Explorer, IE and more
* Aero Snap and Shake to make window management less fiddly
* A redesigned on-screen keyboard
It's not a total redesign, so obviously it will never be as smooth as iOS or Android, but I'd say they did a decent job without breaking compatibility.
Arguably hardware features, but ones that won't work without deep software support.
Windows 7 tablets without those two features will still be a poor imitation.
It took several tries in the Windows Mobile world for MS to give up homogenizing the PDA and the desktop. By throwing manpower at it they think the tablet is "close enough" to a desktop that it can be solved. I don't know if it can or not, but I believe that's the mentality.
You have a potential success with a low margin and certain doom with a high margin. Which one would you choose?
If you're going to have 10% of the market, which would you rather have -- the bottom 10% or the top 10%?
(I'll concede your point about the choice between potential success/certain doom for Microsoft in the tablet field, but Microsoft obviously doesn't see it that way: they see it as a choice between success and success, and obviously they want the more lucrative version.)
And that is absolutely baffling. It will be studied for decades after Microsoft is gone and be the ground upon countless doctoral theses are built.
Microsoft won't be the first huge company to succumb as a result of adhering to the very outlook that made them big in the first place. (Anyone else remember IBM in the run-up to 1994?)
So it's not unthinkable that they might have another tablet group either adapting Metro or starting fresh and this is just the choked sputters of work that was started back before it was obviated by modern tablets.
Sure, there are a few devs and nerds who'd like Windows on a tablet, but the casual user definitely does not. That's why iPad won so early: nobody would have bought one if it ran stock OS X. The buttons would be too small and the whole thing would feel clunky.
The price of this thing doesn't matter, really. It'll fail as a mass-market device, while it'll probably sell a few to businesses and nerds.