If you join with the expectation of stock or are sold on stock as part of your package then yes. Based on the article, people were offered stock contingent on another funding round. That round never happened. If they were sold on promises of getting that stock and a round happening then they're right to be pissed.
This has, as I read it, nothing to do with a company that just decides to not give out promises of stock in any form.
Does a statement of the form "you'll get X if condition Y" imply "we will seek condition Y so that you can get your X"? I don't think that it does.
For example: companies offer dividends if they make a profit. But that doesn't imply that the company will seek to make a profit in order to confer dividends. It's nice when they do, but there's no implied promise of working toward profitability just so that the dividend condition will apply.
In my experience companies do far more selling than just sending out an offer. Furthermore, the offer in my experience doesn't include the paperwork for equity unless you request to review it.
When employees don’t have an equity stake, it can make for awkward moments. I’m reminded of a company all-hands, where the CEO announced a record quarter, and apparently the company’s stock just went up 60% or something. The handful of senior execs who did have equity cheered and did some lame hi-5’s while the rest of the employees shrugged and silently looked at each other like “should we be applauding now?”
Awk—ward...!
I think it is an amazing plan. I was able to choose more equity because I had a working wife and no kids. Others chose more cash. One guy chose 100% equity, and is now retired.
being able to choose 100% equity would suggest a particular level of financial independence before even starting. how long did they work without a salary? did they regularly sell equity as a salary-replacement?
If it was straight stock, then yes it would be rather equivalent to getting cash and then buying stock right away.
I guess this is purely academic for Netflix, but one difference in other companies is that the grant is made ahead of time, and the stock price can rise or fall before it vests.
If (say) you expect the stock to rise with the market, and you expect the market to rise at 7% a year, you might also expect your income from vesting stock to also rise at 7% per year over the vesting period (typically four years) regardless of any raises or promotions.
I have heard of some companies adjusting subsequent grants based on changes in value of invested stock, though. I think policies there vary.
Also, if I were an early employee at a startup, yes, I would expect equity.
The average compensation of employees at other similar companies was probably lower once you account for all that.
You can't judge the outcome of buying lottery tickets by only looking at the winners.
I have made tens of thousands and made e made over 100,000 effectively tax free.
I think you missed out there
Yes, the last time I checked we moved on from the feudal era, at least in principle. There should be at least the illusion that employees have skin in the game by giving them a stake in the company.
As a former Toptal employee: IMHO the co-founder in question was widely regarded as a horrible manager, often pushing people to burnout and generally imposing a culture of secrecy and mistrust. The VPs they ousted were nothing better. I personally went through several burnouts while there, but also that was a springboard to a much better career afterwards. Yes, we've put in 9/9/6 for years in the founding years, but we were also compensated quite generously.