News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by whalabi on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:48PM (#20707680)
This is so absurdly disingenuous from Google.

The (very good) idea is that Google Search should be competing fairly with the other search engines.

It's not fair to make these other search engines, already the victims of anti-competitive behaviour, pay millions of dollars (or whatever) into Google's bank account to be listed, while Google pays nothing.

It's like if Ford owned the roads and GM had to pay Ford for each car they sold.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by summerlight on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:37PM (#20708244)
What is your proposal? I don't see not much other options:

1) Excludes Google from Android/Chrome's default search engine options. This clearly doesn't make sense for Google and I don't think there's an easy way to enforce this. 2) Lists all every search engine that exists on the planet. This still doesn't answer the question who should be placed on the top of the list. 3) Break google up into Android/Chrome and the rest. This is not even an option for EU since their jurisdiction doesn't reach to Google.

Maybe Google can say something like, "all of the profits from this auction will go back to the society!", which practically doesn't make any differences to them since the profit from this auction will likely be a minute fraction compared to the Google's yearly revenues.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by whalabi on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:41PM (#20708283)
Do what they did on Windows, pick the 4 or 5 most popular. (In that case it was browsers)

I know, I know, what about the less popular search engines?

Well. It's better than Google takes all, and customers get easier access to 5 search engines instead of 1. (Yes they can already choose others. Almost no one bothers)

Maybe they could rotate the last 2 choices between a field of say, 20.

Thing is, if no one's heard of the option, I doubt they'll choose it, so there's not much point offering beyond say, 5 choices.

I'm guessing though.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by dpq on Friday August 16, 2019 @01:56AM (#20712508)
In this case, Ecosia would still rant about it. They would only change their complaint text from "what about non-profit oriented search engines like us?" to "what about search engines nobody has ever heard about like us?". Interestingly enough, they use Bing API for actually producing SERPs, so basically this is a PR stunt for not getting free access to a marketing method that is irrelevant to user experience. While their claimed goal of promoting afforestation is rational/noble, I consider their argumentation in this case to be disingenuous.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by ryan_j_naughton on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:01PM (#20708502)
Actually making the profits donated to a non-Google entity works quite well. Then Google should have to bid as well. Then it is fair and competitive and would actually drive the market towards a competitive equilibrium
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by foobarchu on Friday August 16, 2019 @09:17AM (#20714826)
I don't think it really addresses the complaints in the article, though. The main complaint wasn't that the proceeds go to Google, it's that the premise of an auction naturally favors profit-focused search engines. I think it's a valid problem, and the only ways to counter it have to use a ranking that doesn't involve money.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by HeWhoLurksLate on Thursday August 15, 2019 @11:12PM (#20711850)
What about the EFF?
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by jkaplowitz on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:00PM (#20708483)
4) Pay an unaffiliated third party to run the auction, and pay to bid like every one of their competitors. Or if technology doesn't allow this, make payments to cause the same outcome. This is roughly your second paragraph, just a slight variant.

Choice of third party is tricky, but a dedicated or existing trade association that includes them and any interested major competitors on equal terms would probably do it.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by summerlight on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:23PM (#20708732)
This makes sense in principle, but I'm seeing a bunch of legal/technical/transparency issues on selecting the third party over the globe.

The root problem is a trust issue and I still don't see how Google can convince bidders that the auction is run by some entities which won't do any (implicitly) good for Google in return of selecting them, especially Google still owns a full control on picking the "third party". This can be solved if a state picks the third party, but now we have even bigger problems; you will have to enforce the same policy on most of the platform holders with similar issues (virtually every single major tech firms)

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by HeWhoLurksLate on Thursday August 15, 2019 @11:11PM (#20711847)
And that doesn't account for the fact that big corporations have a huge say in what the government does.

Hoo boy.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by whalabi on Thursday August 15, 2019 @09:49PM (#20711477)
I don't like it being an auction because then customers aren't necessarily getting the better choices, they're getting the choices backed by the most wealth

It would also harm not for profit search engines.

Why not choose based on popularity?

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by tareqak on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:54PM (#20708422)
1) Excluding Google from the Android/Chrome’s options is possible: just remove it from that list.

2) DuckDuckGo has a list of search providers using their !bang query. It’s not exhaustive, but adding one to the list is a form submission to DuckDuckGo.

3) A break up is not necessary: the EU can charge Google increasing fines and significantly hamper Google’s European operations.

I think 1) and 2) together could work: the browser could have no list of search engines but could download a list of search engines from a known good URL when it run for the first time. The owners of the known good URL could be a consortium of search engine providers. There are definitely flaws with this approach, and it gives the user an extra choice, but giving the user this extra choice is the point.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by summerlight on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:29PM (#20708785)
1) "Technically" possible. Google won't do that though unless there's an external, super strong push. 2) DDG can do that since its main target is tech-savy users (at least for now). 3) EU can do that until it doesn't escalate into EU vs US trade dispute. 5B is probably okay since Google really didn't even pay their tax in EU appropriately, but 50B will be big enough for US to intervene.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by tareqak on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:40PM (#20709419)
I replied to the assertion that those things were not possible, not that they were probable.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by briffle on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:11PM (#20707970)
Isn't that exactly what Google has to do to be the default search provider for IOS?
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by numbsafari on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:24PM (#20708122)
The difference is that Apple doesn't have its own search engine getting a free slot.

If Google handed administration of the auction over to an independent third party, who would accept all of the paid-in fees from the winners, thus bearing the same cost as everyone else, then it would be a lot harder to make a case against this arrangement.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by close04 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:18PM (#20708049)
Why not ask Google to do exactly what MS was asked to do with the browsers for Windows: offer a spot on the choice screen for free, with Google search engine occupying a random position on the screen. I don't think any of the browser developers were asked to bid for a spot on the choice screen.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BrowserChoice.eu

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by outside1234 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:56PM (#20708446)
I don't understand the downvotes. We are clearly at the same point with Google Search that we were with Windows at that time.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by jbob2000 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:53PM (#20709548)
The difference is that there were only a few browsers back then, it was easy to list them on a screen.

There are tons of search engines out there, how do you decide which ones to show above the fold on a user’s tiny screen?

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by close04 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @05:21PM (#20709781)
The browser choice screen included over time ~17 browsers. On the main page you had the main browsers, while the smaller ones ended up under a "More" button.

And the "tiny screen" doesn't seem to be an issue when picking one of the dozens of languages during the phone's setup. Or any of the countless activities on a phone that overflow one screen.

This particular list shouldn't be treated differently unless it's purely a money grab.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by whalabi on Thursday August 15, 2019 @09:50PM (#20711488)
It's also a barrier of entry to non profit search engines
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by close04 on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:52AM (#20713009)
It's a barrier for any search engine and Google knows it. Google is the only participant who doesn't have to pay and they're leveraging their 90% of the market share (about the same IE had 15 years ago) to squeeze the others.

My question still stands and (downvotes and the "small screen" non-issue aside) nobody is able to explain why Google should get a different treatment from Microsoft given the similar position.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by whalabi on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:36PM (#20708243)
It occurs to me that this is like supermarkets charging companies to put products on their shelves, then also launching their own brands and competing with them on their own shelves.

I think it's easy to see how customers are harmed by this, their choice becomes the supermarket brand or whoever shelled out the most for shelf space.

So Google search is an android home brand?

(Also why isn't the supermarket thing deemed anti-competitive?)

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by lallysingh on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:11PM (#20707976)
Indeed. I was pretty off-put by the auction. Rather un-googley.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by jsnell on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:16PM (#20708038)
:-D

Indeed, it's great that they've never tried building their entire business model on auctioning off the ad spots in search results. It's much more fair to everyone to just allow anyone to apply for a spot for each keyword for free, and then choose randomly from that set.