News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Mu – A modular UEFI environment for building mode... by wmf on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @01:30PM (#20697817)
This is potentially an alternative to Coreboot for open source firmware. AFAIK it's used in Microsoft Surface PCs and it looks more consumer-friendly with menus and such. The downside is that it's based on TianoCore which is reported to be very poor quality.
Re:Project Mu – A modular UEFI environment for building mode... by pgeorgi on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:00PM (#20698180)
Project Mu, like EDK2/Tianocore lacks everything coreboot has - and vice-versa: coreboot doesn't care too much about OS-side or user interfaces but delegates that to something we call "payload". EDK2/Tianocore on the other hand (and Mu, by extension) is extremely weak in the actual hardware initialization department because they only care about OS-side and user interface matters. If you dig a lot, you'll find one memory init driver there (for the now-dead Quark SoC).

Project Mu is an attempt to make something reasonable out of EDK2, and I commend them for it (EDK2 _really_ needs an effort like this).

But to get a useful (UEFI style) firmware image without signing NDAs (and not the ordinary NDA, the more secret ones) you'll need to combine Project Mu with... coreboot.

Re:Project Mu – A modular UEFI environment for building mode... by floatboth on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @01:49PM (#20698032)
here we go again, every thread, same confused comments…

Coreboot is just an early stage bootloader that does basic bringup and jumps into a payload… like… TianoCore EDK2 :) Comparing Coreboot with something that can be its payload does not make much sense.

EDK2 does have some PEI code but it's not very interesting. The valuable part is the DXE phase and beyond.