News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by ergo98 on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @08:37PM (#2069420)
I see little that is unique or insightful in this essay.

"Google builds services like Google Maps, Gmail and Docs and gives them away for free"...

...because they entered a market where maps, email, and "docs" were free. Google didn't blaze a trail of free services, but they were bound to continue it.

Nonetheless, they've managed to get lots of businesses to subscribe to the pay services though.

"This is important for Google because while Google isn’t licensing Android"

Aside from the fact that while the core Android image -- which is GPLd btw -- is free, Google's premium applications are not. Note that many low end devices don't have Google's applications. Google is also trying to monetize their leading edge advantage with the Nexus One originally, and now the Nexus S.

"And Google conveniently owns one of the largest mobile advertising providers, Admob. "

Yeah, so does Apple. How do you like them Apples? Apple is very heavily invested and involved in the advertising and the media sales market. Any illusion that Apple is a pure player just trying to honestly sell an electronic device and that's the conclusion of the transaction should be demolished the moment you hook it up to iTunes. The original purchase is merely the first of many monetizations of the customer.

"Google is building Android not so they can make great mobile devices"

Oh well if you say so.

"For example, Android’s market may not be terrible in comparison to Apple’s App Store for paid applications just because Google hasn’t yet finished it; rather, discouraging paid applications on the Android platform is in Google’s interest. "

Conspiracy theory. Google is simply really bad at some things. See Google Checkout -- which was actually a major contributor to the Market's problems -- and Google's retail efforts with the Nexus One. The Android Market is not great, but neither is it particularly terrible, and it has been rapidly improving.

"This would squeeze out space for Apple in the mass market, forcing them into the high-end of the market, where people are willing to pay higher prices for a better device and experience."

This is my favorite bit. Apple is a mass consumer electronics company, with products at every price point, usually representing the value option. This sort of casual allusion that it is the premium option is utter bunk, and instantly reveals the bias of the speaker. If Android succeeds, via competition, in putting price pressure on smartphones, you can be certain that Apple will be pushing down to the lower options just as quickly. Anyone who thinks otherwise has absolutely no business sense.

Android is really a story about Linux. When people miss the Linux part of the equation -- and the decisions that are bound by it -- they instantly lose focus on some of the givens of the platform.

Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by blub on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @06:01AM (#2070641)
I don't think that you are right at all.

First you said that Google just continued with free services. This is incorrect: Navigation was not free and they severely crippled the paid navigation market.

Quality e-mail was not free. A quality office suite was not free. And it still isn't, because Google has failed so far to provide an alternative to MS Office, but they're trying alright!

I do applaud initiatives of transparency such as publishing takedown requests, but income sources are a very powerful influence in a company. Decisions that benefit ads income surely get a priority boost or better funding. I'm not saying that Google is evil or good - this is simplistic and stupid - but a corporation is a corporation.

I don't use Apple products, and I don't care much what Apple does, but at least they're not hypocrites and admit that they want your money. On the other hand Google is all "free" and "open" according to their corporate talk. Speaking of Apple, they ARE a premium brand. You're probably wealthy enough not to care that you pay 2000EUR on a laptop, but most people can't afford to do that.

Finally, Android is a story about the Linux kernel with a Java user space on top. Lots of products have Linux kernels, I don't see why it's such a big deal.

Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by RyanMcGreal on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @07:40AM (#2070784)
> A quality office suite was not free.

I'm holding my nose as I type this, but for the vast majority of non-power users, OpenOffice is more than adequate.

Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by blub on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:31AM (#2071037)
It is adequate. If I had to pay the full price for Office I probably wouldn't get it, but through BizSpark I was able to get it for free and OO just can't compete. Additonally, MS offers healthy discounts for home versions, students and so on, most of the time you don't have to pay the full price.

My parents use OO though.

Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by ygtckr on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @08:07AM (#2070830)
I agree, I only switch to excel from time to time to use its add-ons. I think there are better and easier to use presentation software for the non-power users online.
Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by ergo98 on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @08:23AM (#2070853)
First you said that Google just continued with free services. This is incorrect: Navigation was not free and they severely crippled the paid navigation market.

Google Navigation is on Android, a paid add-on that providers add to products that you pay for. There is nothing free about it.

Quality e-mail was not free. A quality office suite was not free. And it still isn't, because Google has failed so far to provide an alternative to MS Office, but they're trying alright!

No one paid for consumer email -- it was long a free, ad-supported market via options like Hotmail. Adding weasel words like "quality" to disclaim some exception doesn't make that any less true. OpenOffice is entirely free, and is a huge superset of the limited features Google offers.

But even then, the "free" Google office functionality is very limited. Businesses pay for business plans.

Speaking of Apple, they ARE a premium brand.

Most of the buyers of Apple are buying iPods and iMacs and iTVs and iPads, all fantastic values. The people buying Apple laptops are usually developers targeting the first set of buyers.

GM sells the Corvette CR1. They still aren't a premium maker.

Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by blub on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:26AM (#2071025)
Well, my reply was not well thought out and I apologize. I latched onto the "free" word when instead I should have focused on the real issue that bothers me: commoditizing the competition.

E-mail was free, but you got a crap service and ads to boot, it was worth it to get a paid account. Now, for most people GMail would be fine, Google commoditized the e-mail market. They are trying the same thing with the Office market, but they are not succeeding because it's much harder to beat MS Office at its own game, as OO has found.

The bottom line is that when Google enters a market you can bet that they'll make the product free (and beta of course) and then compete with the help of their web ads monopoly. I don't think that's what is best for the tech market and neither it is good for us small entrepreneurs. The last thing I want to do is put ads into my apps, but what choice will I have if Google drives the market to free-with-ads as it has done in certain cases?

P.S: I'm pretty sure that you can use Google Maps for navigation, I have seen at least two people do it with Nokia keyboard phones. You could create a route and it showed where you are on that route.

I think it would also be fair to call Apple a premium brand in certain niches and a value brand in others. Although as you've noticed the premium-ness from iPhone/Macbook tends to rub onto the other products in people minds and when it comes to quality.

Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by mattmcknight on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @12:30AM (#2070046)
"Apple is a mass consumer electronics company, with products at every price point, usually representing the value option"

For general purpose computing devices, I don't see it. Apple doesn't sell a monitor for less than $999. A MacBook costs a minimum of $999 (a better spec-ed Asus is $300 less). MacBook Pros are very expensive. The only tower they sell is the MacPro, starting at $2499. Even the Mini is high priced, although crammed into a nettop form factor. Plus, they hardly ever discount, so you end up paying retail for the whole product lifetime.

I actually agree with you when it comes to smartphones, as the iPhone 3G at $99 is a value option, but for computers, they do not typically offer value options.

Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by meric on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @12:42AM (#2070069)
As a mass consumer electronics company, Apple sells the iPod shuffle ($49), and the Apple TV ($99) (vs blueray players), both representing the value option.
Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by eftpotrm on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:08AM (#2070965)
There are plenty of small MP3 players with more capacity and little added extras like screens and the ability to play the song you want when you want (ahem) for the same sort of money as the iPod Shuffle though, and I'm curious to know who is buying an Apple TV instead of a Blu-Ray player - they seem substantially different markets to me.
Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by meric on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:37AM (#2071053)
I always saw the it as the "itunes-stack" vs the "physical-disk-stack". You either only bought itunes movies or only bought blueray dvds. The itunes stack is price competitive because movies from the itunes store is lower priced than a physical blue ray disk, and that the price of an apple tv was comparable to a low priced blue ray disk player.
Re:Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform by alextingle on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @07:33AM (#2070772)
Where can you buy an iPhone 3G for US$99?? The best prices I can see are around $350: http://www.google.com/products?q=iphone+3g

Or perhaps you are talking about the subsidised price with a contact, which would be pretty disingenuous.