Re:Fire One, Fire Ten: Implications of the Torpedo Scandal o...
by wffurr on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @08:36AM
(#20694851)
It's not a technical article about torpedo design. From that perspective, it is superficial but that's not what it's about. You can easily research the torpedo design if you want.
The article is actually about the organizational and strategic failures that led to and exacerbated the problem. From that perspective, it has plenty to offer.
Re:Fire One, Fire Ten: Implications of the Torpedo Scandal o...
by brazzy on Friday August 16, 2019 @07:50AM
(#20714172)
Even from that perspective, it has very little to offer because it completely fails to explain how those "organizational and strategic failures" actually had anything to do with the torpedoes.
Re:Fire One, Fire Ten: Implications of the Torpedo Scandal o...
by pjc50 on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @04:19AM
(#20693623)
The wikipedia article cites three problems: wrong depth setting (caused by the test warheads being lighter than the real ones); over-sensitive magnetic detonators and under-sensitive contact detonators.
It also cites inadequate testing because the torpedoes were too expensive.
Re:Fire One, Fire Ten: Implications of the Torpedo Scandal o...
by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @08:05AM
(#20694607)
The article posted cites them and doesn't even discuss them. Furthermore it doesn't even go into any deep discussion as to why the navy couldn't figure it out. It's just hand waving about money and organizational politics. There is no depth or breadth of subject matter in this article. I think that makes "maddeningly superficial" an accurate description.
Edit: If you're going to edit your comment to change the subject of your comment from "it" (referring to the posted article the GP is talking about) to "the Wikipedia article" thereby totally changing what you are discussing do us all a favor and mention it.
It is not. I found it maddeningly superficial.
It talks about "crippling flaws in all three control mechanisms." but fails to provide any information whatsoever about what those flaws were and what effects they had.
The story about how the flaws were isolated and fixed is confined to a single sentence.
It is completely unclear how "Lesson 1: Indecision can thicken the fog of war" has anything at all to do with the faulty torpedoes. Why and how did "operational consequences of this startling strategic decision masked the true nature of the torpedo problem"?