News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Research Chef: You’re Not Allergic to MSG and More Culina... by code_duck on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @06:04PM (#2068963)
I think this comes up because natural substances tend to have a longer history of usage. I'd take a natural additive that has been generally proven safe by 500 years of human history over a synthetic chemical that was (supposedly) shown to be reasonably safe through 5 years of lab testing.
Re:Research Chef: You’re Not Allergic to MSG and More Culina... by burgerbrain on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @06:59PM (#2069145)
Until very recently lead and mercury were commonly considered to be swell things to ingest as medicine. With the exception of "these berries taste good and these berries will kill you"^, history of human consumption is a pretty bad thing to go by.

^ and they even messed this up on occasion: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomato#History

Re:Research Chef: You’re Not Allergic to MSG and More Culina... by code_duck on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @08:13PM (#2069361)
At least we have a long history of data on which to base conclusions. Unlike some of the stuff Monsanto is eager to spray on your food, lead wasn't invented in a lab last year. And see how long it took for the harmful effects to become apparent? Longer than a FDA testing cycle, definitely!

As for tomatoes, there was a serious lack of information regarding many topics in Europe at that time. Did the people living in lands to which the tomato is indigenous suffer from that misperception?

Anyway, the point is to analyze these substances based on what we know now, not what someone thought 250 years ago.

Re:Research Chef: You’re Not Allergic to MSG and More Culina... by Retric on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @12:00AM (#2069983)
Lead, mercury, and Tobaco where known to be unsafe before I was born. That's a fairly long time from my perspective. Also, in the short term they are reasonably safe. It's only because we can look at long term exposure that we understand how harmful these things are.
Re:Research Chef: You’re Not Allergic to MSG and More Culina... by hartror on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @10:49PM (#2069785)
To ingest, use as cosmetics . . you name it they tried it. A long history of use is neither a sign of safety or efficacy, but try telling the non scientific public that.
Re:Research Chef: You’re Not Allergic to MSG and More Culina... by khafra on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @10:16AM (#2071183)
I personally wish the FDA "Generally Regarded as Safe" list were more well-known. I think "GRAS" would make a good replacement for "natural."
Re:Research Chef: You’re Not Allergic to MSG and More Culina... by derleth on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @12:31PM (#2071637)
The problem is that some non-natural chemicals are GRAS, and the people who make the most noise about 'all-natural' will never accept them as being benign.