we have had better ways of judging danger since the dark ages.
That's true. And if you trust scientists and the FDA to do their jobs, you're all set. But what if you don't? Let's say that I'm at the supermarket in a small, poor country with a corrupt FDA, and I want to buy some juice. Well, I'm going to favor those brands with natural ingredients (and hope that the ingredient list is correct). Maybe that's a stupid move, but it has served me well so far.
Apologies, I sometimes forget some people find that word particularly offensive.
^ and they even messed this up on occasion: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomato#History
As for tomatoes, there was a serious lack of information regarding many topics in Europe at that time. Did the people living in lands to which the tomato is indigenous suffer from that misperception?
Anyway, the point is to analyze these substances based on what we know now, not what someone thought 250 years ago.
Here, have a delicious puffer fish. I prepared it myself!
Rating chemicals by whether or not they occur naturally is a really piss-poor way of judging danger. There is a practically unlimited number of naturally occurring chemicals what will knock you dead, and there are similarly tones of synthesized chemicals that are completely harmless, or even beneficial. Bringing "synthesized vs. naturally" is always disingenuous, we have had better ways of judging danger since the dark ages.