News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by misterdoubt on Monday August 12, 2019 @09:49AM (#20675350)
I don't quite understand the aim, or why it overlaps with OpenBSD. This is to provide a different, simplified CLI to git?
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by markphip on Monday August 12, 2019 @11:08AM (#20676080)
In addition to the simplified CLI and the license, there is also the mention of using Unveil/Pledge throughout the code. That seems consistent with OpenBSD and probably is a big part of this. AFAIK, that is also something that would make the code fairly tied to OpenBSD at the moment at least.

I've worked with stsp for a number of years on SVN. He is a thoughtful developer. I am not sure what got him started on this but I hope this comes together for him.

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by UI_at_80x24 on Monday August 12, 2019 @09:58AM (#20675433)
I'm not a developer,

(1) GIT is GPL licensed. OpenBSD does not use GPL code.[1]

(2) The developers saw something about git that they thought they could improve. (usually based on security/code-correctness, see: OpenSSL, OpenSSH, unwind, openrsync, etc..)

[1] https://www.openbsd.org/policy.html

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by microcolonel on Monday August 12, 2019 @10:23AM (#20675654)
> OpenBSD does not use GPL code

OpenBSD has used a lot of GPLv2 code, until recently their platform compiler was a heavily-patched version of the last GPLv2 version of GCC.

There are git implementations under permissive licenses as well. And it seems like GOT is yet another such implementation.

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by brynet on Monday August 12, 2019 @11:30AM (#20676321)
> a lot of GPLv2 code

"A lot" is quite the exaggeration for "at most 5".

GPLv2 licenced software:

• cvs

• texinfo (for software lacking proper mdoc(7) manuals)

• mkhybrid

• readline

• gcc/gdb/bintuils, supporting libraries libstdc++/libiberty*

The amount of GPL licensed software the resides in OpenBSD base is trivial compared to the entirety of software comprising a complete Unix operating system. Including its own implementation of a wide variety of network protocols, and being the home of OpenSSH, and tmux and many more.

https://www.openbsd.org/innovations.html

* On architectures that have transitioned to a LLVM toolchain, we already have a reference platform (arm64) which doesn't build or install gcc/binutils or supporting libraries, this will happen on other platforms as well, where they're currently installed alongside clang. OpenBSD has already transitioned to clang, lld, libc++/libc++abi on i386/amd64/armv7/octeon.

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by microcolonel on Monday August 12, 2019 @01:00PM (#20677361)
> cvs

You know, I had forgotten that they failed to bring OpenCVS to bear. Isn't it kinda silly to be concerned about replacing a GPLv2-licensed SCM with another one?

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by Fnoord on Monday August 12, 2019 @01:32PM (#20677731)
What are you on about?

CVS is GPL. OpenCVS is BSDL.

Git is GPL. Got is BSDL.

I got nothing against GPL, but I am pro diversification (competition = good, monoculture = bad). Furthermore, these projects add more than just different license. Mainly, better security.

PS: Got, trendy name. Got got?

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by dang on Monday August 12, 2019 @09:05PM (#20681830)
Hey, could you please not break the site guidelines by taking personal shots at other users, being snarky, or posting in the flamewar style? It makes this place worse, regardless of how solid your underlying points are. If you'd review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and make your substantive points thoughtfully, we'd appreciate it.
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by Fnoord on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:28AM (#20703287)
Hi Dan, thanks for the heads up. I agree I could have worded the flagged posts more positive. I've attempted to improve this after you posted your warning. Let me know if you still have concerns. Thanks!
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by knorker on Monday August 12, 2019 @04:24PM (#20679570)
Got is an absolutely terrible name. It's like "Go". It doesn't google well, and it's a proper word that will be used in the same sentences as this project.

Funny-because-confusing open source project names stopped being funny in the 90s.

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by microcolonel on Monday August 12, 2019 @02:08PM (#20678174)
Sure, but the idea seems to be that using git, as is, would mean relying on more GPLv2 software; my point is that it doesn't.

By all means, if OpenCVS or Got were actually brought to a useful state, that'd be great, but there's no great crisis of new GPLv2 reliance in using Git.

I, for one, would welcome a git clone (hah!) built to the core OpenBSD quality standard, but it seems unlikely that anyone cares enough to do that.

In the mean time, justifying not using Git for OpenBSD on the basis of license falls flat, when you realize you're using GNU CVS anyway.

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by ben_bai on Monday August 12, 2019 @05:09PM (#20680033)
> I, for one, would welcome a git clone (hah!) built to the core OpenBSD quality standard, but it seems unlikely that anyone cares enough to do that.

That would be got(1). Since yesterday version 0.3, 0.4 and then 0.5 was "released". It's still in early development but good enough for a casual user like me to import the OpenBSD src and start using it. Created some commits, branches, performed rebases. Looks great, but still some rough edges. Also tog(1) is great.

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by Fnoord on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:44PM (#20688275)
Hi, I clearly misunderstood your post. I implied you didn't know the licenses while I did not understand the "to bear" part of your post, at all. Furthermore, I am sorry if I came across as offensive. You make a good point in this post, clarifying your viewpoint. A viewpoint I can relate to.
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by microcolonel on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @05:36PM (#20700205)
It's alright, I am used to being misunderstood, so I choose not to be offended and misunderstand the misunderstander's misunderstandings. :- )
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by koenigdavidmj on Monday August 12, 2019 @11:04AM (#20676041)
You’re correct, but they also have a strong desire to replace these if possible. There was an old effort to replace gcc with the old pcc before they eventually settled on clang.
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday August 12, 2019 @01:46PM (#20677913)
> usually based on security/code-correctness,

But note that they also tend to consider usability to be part of security and correctness; if the tool is technically correct but nobody can use it without shooting their own foot, then the tool is bad. Hence things like signify - yes gpg or openssl(1) can do what it does, generally, but you'd struggle to use them and be sure that you'd done it right.

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by saxonww on Monday August 12, 2019 @09:59AM (#20675443)
See the other comment with a link to lobste.rs, but I'm afraid this entire project exists to reimplement git as a BSD-licensed tool.

My eyes were rolling pretty hard until I remembered that git was basically born out of a license disagreement with BitKeeper. Kudos to the OpenBSD folks (and/or this developer) for sticking to their principles.

Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by enneff on Monday August 12, 2019 @10:38AM (#20675783)
I don’t think that’s the goal. I think it’s more about a clear user experience for their developers, who used CVS for a very long time. While CVS is more rigid and limited than git, it has some benefits too. I see this tool, got, as marrying the benefits of both tools.
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by MuffinFlavored on Monday August 12, 2019 @12:20PM (#20676871)
What are some of those benefits?
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by enneff on Monday August 12, 2019 @03:18PM (#20678874)
Unambiguous workflow, checkouts of only part of the tree, checkouts of specific files that are being worked on, and probably more that I can’t remember now since it’s been 20 years since I used CVS.
Re:Game of Trees: A Version Control System for OpenBSD by compsciphd on Monday August 12, 2019 @10:22AM (#20675645)
the bitkeeper license disagreement impacted how the tool was used. Git's license really only impacts how its developed.