I'm talking about the home video offerings (DVDs, Apple's iTunes store) which often only provide the dubbed versions.
Same goes for games by the way, but there, thankfully, there's Steam which actually allows me to play the games in the original language.
If I paid 20$ for every episode or movie or show I've ever watched, I'd be in a huge financial crisis -- I would not gladly put myself in that position.
I'm not the kind of person who spends all his time watching TV shows, but if I was, I probably wouldn't mind paying that much for it.
But that would be out of convenience, not out of a moral obligation.
I've paid for some steam games, but I still download games from bittorrent (even games that are available on steam).
I've paid for some games because I wanted to support the developers, and I'm not just talking about indie games here. I paid for Valve games (HL2 series) because I felt they deserve it. I felt like they were nice guys.
That said, I wouldn't mind paying $10-20 per month so that I don't have to both with downloading and tracking what I have and haven't seen. Also, the majority of the people that I know that use BT for movies/shows would pay that.
Unfortunately that's not possible. Most of the content isn't available and if it is, it's usually only available in a crappy german translation.
These artificial barriers should probably be factored in before doing such calculations.