I'm not the kind of person who spends all his time watching TV shows, but if I was, I probably wouldn't mind paying that much for it.
But that would be out of convenience, not out of a moral obligation.
I've paid for some steam games, but I still download games from bittorrent (even games that are available on steam).
I've paid for some games because I wanted to support the developers, and I'm not just talking about indie games here. I paid for Valve games (HL2 series) because I felt they deserve it. I felt like they were nice guys.
That said, I wouldn't mind paying $10-20 per month so that I don't have to both with downloading and tracking what I have and haven't seen. Also, the majority of the people that I know that use BT for movies/shows would pay that.