News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by rayiner on Sunday August 11, 2019 @05:36PM (#20670690)
> we don’t employ immigrants to save money.

> The competition for talent is quite brutal and we just can’t pay the same as FAANG.

You don't have to pay immigrants less in order to be saving money by employing immigrants. The whole point is that by expanding the labor pool, you're reducing salaries and negotiating power for everyone.

That's not what the H1-B system was designed for. It was designed to facilitate hiring folks with specialized skills you can't get locally. E.g. you want to hire an Indian person who did his PhD on something relevant to a project you're working on.

Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by komali2 on Sunday August 11, 2019 @05:44PM (#20670722)
> you're reducing salaries and negotiating power for everyone.

Rather, you're leveling it by expanding the labor pool to include the rest of the world, aka via globalization. Not inherently bad imo, but I could understand why someone patriotic would find this problematic.

Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by addicted on Sunday August 11, 2019 @06:08PM (#20670858)
Well, H1B visas do not expand the labor pool. H1B visas allow members of an already expanded labor pool to join and contribute to the US economy.

The alternative to fewer H1B visas is not just hiring Americans. In fact, hiring Americans is far less likely than simply hiring Indians and letting them work in India. Or, as is happening increasingly, having Chinese and Indian employees who were educated in the US, move to Canada.

Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by Mikeb85 on Sunday August 11, 2019 @06:30PM (#20670967)
> Well, H1B visas do not expand the labor pool. H1B visas allow members of an already expanded labor pool to join and contribute to the US economy.

Semantics. In economic terms, it's expanding the labour pool.

Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by throwaway5752 on Sunday August 11, 2019 @06:29PM (#20670954)
Can those of us born in the US and educated there be moved to Canada by FAANGs? If that's already happening by all means reply and let me know how to get in on it before all the stuff really hits the fan in the US.
Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by lazaroclapp on Sunday August 11, 2019 @08:06PM (#20671376)
Sure. Definitely already a thing! I know plenty of people from the US who joined a company in the US with international offices and then transferred (temporarily or permanently) to an office somewhere else. Singapore comes to mind, but I am sure the case for Canada is even easier (given NAFTA and similar).

You could also just directly apply to a position that happens to be in Canada, e.g. https://careers.google.com/locations/toronto/?hl=en

By the way, you actually might not need any FAANG (or other Canadian employer) help: https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/se...

Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by rayiner on Sunday August 11, 2019 @05:47PM (#20670746)
I'm not making a value judgment on it, I'm just pointing out the economic effect.
Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by atemerev on Sunday August 11, 2019 @07:30PM (#20671211)
And I can't. Expanding labor pool means that companies can afford to open lines of businesses that were previously deemed unsustainable, and eventually hire locals for e.g. administrative support.

Most businesses are at equilibrium. There is no choice of "hire locally and pay them well or hire globally and pocket the difference". The choice is "hire globally and expand" (and eventually hire more locals), or "hire locally and stay small, or even get out of business".

Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by whatshisface on Sunday August 11, 2019 @05:47PM (#20670749)
Also someone who was part of the expanding labor pool, including immigrants who have already got in.
Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by belltaco on Sunday August 11, 2019 @05:48PM (#20670754)
At this point, doing that will just fuel more offshoring to Canada to India. It happened to manufacturing where it was harder to move or build factories. Note that the article mentions Toronto as already benefiting. As companies get comfortable with fully remote workers they won't even bother with renting offices offshore.
Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by mrchicity on Sunday August 11, 2019 @06:13PM (#20670876)
And doing that may put downward pressure on wages for ordinary Canadians. Their citizens vote, too.

I don't think offshoring to India is a real worry. They lack the rule of law and stable business environment of countries like the US and Canada. Nobody with sensitive IP would outsource their core business there. If offshoring worked well, even with H-1Bs being allowed, companies would already prefer keeping Indian employees there with lower salary and COL, but they don't.

I also have a hard time believing fully remote work will ever be more than a niche thing. Shared context and serendipitous discussion of ideas are so important.

Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by belltaco on Sunday August 11, 2019 @11:02PM (#20672060)
How does moving high paying jobs from Canada to Canada while being done by the same people reduce wages in Canada?

If anything it will greatly help the local economy, and increases tax revenue for local, province and federal govts.

>If offshoring worked well, even with H-1Bs being allowed, companies would already prefer keeping Indian employees there with lower salary and COL, but they don't

What makes you think they don't?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_India

Headcount is 6500.

It can just be expanded to include more jobs if it keeps getting harder and more expensive to hire in the US.

Brain drain from India to US currently hinders it, but if the rules keep getting tougher, retaining talent in India or attracting them to Canada becomes easier.

Remember when lots of people thought high quality cars couldn't be made in Japan or South Korea?

Regarding Canada becoming a hub for offshore workers, back in 2007:

https://www.infoworld.com/article/2663608/microsoft-vancouve...

A couple of years ago:

https://www.seattletimes.com/business/microsoft/trumps-immig...

2018: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/07/12/microsoft-might-be-forced-to...

>I also have a hard time believing fully remote work will ever be more than a niche thing. Shared context and serendipitous discussion of ideas are so important.

Isn't GitLab 100% remote?

I think Github has like 60% of people remote as well.

Also, the Linux kernel has been developed with people being fully remote for the most part.

Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by pm90 on Sunday August 11, 2019 @06:03PM (#20670833)
This trope gets brought up a lot but the definition of specialized skills is broader than PHD level expertise. That is your interpretation of it and not that of the law or of the Federal Government.
Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by damnyou on Sunday August 11, 2019 @07:21PM (#20671178)
Citation? My understanding is that the situation you're describing is covered by the O-1, not the H-1B.
Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by kaitai on Monday August 12, 2019 @12:17AM (#20672383)
The O-1 is hard to get for mere PhDs. We are a dime a dozen in many fields.
Re:Denial of H1-B visas to India’s largest IT services expor... by doh on Sunday August 11, 2019 @06:08PM (#20670857)
I do understand your point. I would however venture out and say, that a person that can scale services to tens of thousands of servers, has quite specialized skillset.