News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by msla on Friday August 09, 2019 @01:58PM (#20656794)
> Be honest now... the unbroken spine on your Godel Escher Bach suggests otherwise.

I find it amusing that this book is chosen as an example of one people don't really read, and not, say, Penrose's The Road To Reality.

Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by copperx on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:59PM (#20657325)
I remember begging my mom to buy me GEB at a Barnes and Noble when I was about 17, about twenty years ago. The book was expensive, especially for a Mexican family, but the book was hyped up in Slashdot, so I really really wanted to read it. I remember reading a few chapters and then couldn't muster the motivation to continue.

I still feel guilty about it. The book sits in my bookshelf, spine unbroken. My mom recently passed away. I'm sorry, mom.

Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by mixmastamyk on Saturday August 10, 2019 @01:25AM (#20660364)
Libraries: I ordered it thru the library maybe ten years ago after geeks talked it up on a similar site. Gave up after a few chapters, had no clue what it was about.
Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by emmanueloga_ on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:14PM (#20657439)
I'm thinking on prioritizing "I am a Strange Loop" over GEB. According to Hofstadter, it is a better book [1]. Also, shorter :-).

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Am_a_Strange_Loop

Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by jimpudar on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:22PM (#20657509)
GEB was written when he was a young man and his ideas hadn't fully percolated into the more concrete form they take in I Am a Strange Loop. I can't find a source at the moment (it might actually be in IaaSL itself) but I seem to remember him saying IaaSL is the book he wanted to write when he wrote GEB.

Both are excellent reads, but I'd definitely agree IaaSL is far more approachable and a better use of your time.

Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by rmidthun on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:35PM (#20657620)
Strongly disagree.

I Am a Strange Loop spends an entire chapter of Hofstadter informing us how he is better than everyone else because he hears Bach better than everyone else. And this attitude fills the book, I found it very obnoxious and am not sure why no else mentions it.

There are at least two places in the book where he talks about an interesting point, then realizes it is a rehash of something from a previous book. And aside from the self-congratulations (did you know being a vegetarian makes you more of a person?), anything interesting in this book was done better in a previous book.

I would recommend The Mind's I instead. It's a collection of stories and essays from most of his influences, see what Turing, Lucas, et al. actually said.

Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by iamnothere on Saturday August 10, 2019 @10:30PM (#20665844)
He also spends a chapter trashing Searle, in a way that seems a little unnecessarily vindictive.

I still enjoyed it. It's not for everyone, but I found that his meanderings served to break up the seriousness of the subject in a way that made for an easy read, much easier than GEB.

Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by zem on Friday August 09, 2019 @08:51PM (#20659464)
if you read one book of hofstadter's, make it "metamagical themas", a truly engaging collection of his columns for "scientific american". I also liked "le ton beau de marot", on the art of translation, but that's less of a general appeal book.

I have read geb, and it had some nice ideas, but i can't say I was motivated to reread it; it felt overly self indulgent somewhat in the manner of a friend telling you about how their rpg campaign played out without realising that half the interest lay in having been there.

Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by GlenTheMachine on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:49PM (#20657241)
Hey there. I've read the first half of GEB at least four times. It's only the last 50% I've never read.
Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by wwweston on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:22PM (#20657519)
The content is fractally self-similar, so you're covered.
Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by khazhou on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:11PM (#20656922)
Well it does have a 25 year headstart.

And a cooler cover!

Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by rosser on Friday August 09, 2019 @08:07PM (#20659264)
Or Infinite Jest.

Disclosure: My (unfinished) copy of GEB was given to a friend as a gift, and my (unfinished) copy of IJ taunts me as I type.

Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by 6thaccount2 on Friday August 09, 2019 @09:50PM (#20659664)
I have both books sitting next to each other on my bookshelf. In everyone's defense...both are extremely dense reading material.
Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by Rerarom on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:20PM (#20656996)
I read both GEB and TRTR, and I haven't read any of the books on Kay's list ;)
Re:Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books progr... by gmassman on Friday August 09, 2019 @04:46PM (#20658128)
I read about 30% of GEB. Now it makes quite a good mouse pad.