Re:The Utopian Promise of Adorno’s ‘Open Thinking,’ Fifty Ye...
by nradov on Friday August 09, 2019 @10:52AM
(#20654899)
But that's a circular argument. What makes his peers qualified? What is the root of qualification in a field where the foundational axioms are ultimately subjective and there is no reliable source of objective truth? Or to put it another way, what makes this branch of philosophy any more respectable than astrology?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Utopian Promise of Adorno’s ‘Open Thinking,’ Fifty Ye...
by Nav_Panel on Friday August 09, 2019 @11:15AM
(#20655105)
To invoke the notion of "objective truth" as a grounding requires that one has already accepted several "foundational axioms [that] are ultimately subjective".
We in software are lucky, representing what Hannah Arendt calls "homo faber", those who work with their hands and use instrumental reasoning to create use-objects. Of course object-ivity is our concern. But using such standards to critique and create philosophy ends up favoring what one might call "propaganda."
Re:The Utopian Promise of Adorno’s ‘Open Thinking,’ Fifty Ye...
by mlevental on Friday August 09, 2019 @04:42PM
(#20658096)
here here. i'm not as read up on arendt as i should be but that's a perfect refutation of the kind of ideas i see espoused on hn every day. the problem is that getting people to buy into this very insightful critique of formalism.
Re:The Utopian Promise of Adorno’s ‘Open Thinking,’ Fifty Ye...
by mlevental on Friday August 09, 2019 @11:02AM
(#20654985)
>What is the root of qualification in a field where the foundational axioms are ultimately subjective and there is no reliable source of objective truth
without going into post-modernity and socially constructed truths i'll simply ask you: are you an academic researcher in stem? what are the objective metrics for stem? beyond anything else it's citation count.
Re:The Utopian Promise of Adorno’s ‘Open Thinking,’ Fifty Ye...
by nradov on Friday August 09, 2019 @11:10AM
(#20655069)
There you go again, dodging the question.
Re:The Utopian Promise of Adorno’s ‘Open Thinking,’ Fifty Ye...
by mlevental on Friday August 09, 2019 @04:38PM
(#20658072)
i'm not dodging any question; i'm trying to explain to you that there is absolutely no such thing as "objective truth" anywhere outside of formal mathematics. so the humanities are absolutely no different from 99% of academia.
Re:The Utopian Promise of Adorno’s ‘Open Thinking,’ Fifty Ye...
by nradov on Friday August 09, 2019 @06:00PM
(#20658553)
I strongly support studying humanities, especially as a way to learn how to think clearly and communicate effectively. Unfortunately much of what passes for "humanities" is simply empty sophistry. Dig below the surface and there's nothing there. Yet everyone is afraid to say that "the emperor wears no clothes" for fear of being labeled unsophisticated by a gang of pseudo-intellectuals.
I know bullshit when I see it.
Re:The Utopian Promise of Adorno’s ‘Open Thinking,’ Fifty Ye...
by AnimalMuppet on Friday August 09, 2019 @04:56PM
(#20658200)
I could claim that "repeatable experiment" comes pretty close to "objective truth" for at least physics and chemistry.