The problem with bad bets is that they take money from your good bets. If Paul's only bets were Heroku and Mint, he would probably have a much larger return.
I tend to invest $10-$25k. There was one for $50k (which is a loser) and one for $40k (which returned a bit.)
The better investments tended to have smaller allocations for me. Hotter deals tended to go on to Series B.
I've spent maybe $800k on investments. The unrealized value of the portfolio is approximately $1.6m, most of which is in one company. Since the original investment was only $25k and my first actual investment, if I had just stopped there I would be doing way better.
I cannot conclude that I am actually any good at this.
Not bad odds, although I think you and Paul have opportunities that most of us would never see (and rightfully so).
Big mistakes, so far:
Curiously, I've been working on taking stock of my angel portfolio as well lately, though it seems gauche to talk dollar numbers.