Big mistakes, so far:
- startup has no lead investor
- startup is raising too little
- generally, not having an investment thesis
Curiously, I've been working on taking stock of my angel portfolio as well lately, though it seems gauche to talk dollar numbers.The problem with bad bets is that they take money from your good bets. If Paul's only bets were Heroku and Mint, he would probably have a much larger return.
I tend to invest $10-$25k. There was one for $50k (which is a loser) and one for $40k (which returned a bit.)
The better investments tended to have smaller allocations for me. Hotter deals tended to go on to Series B.
I've spent maybe $800k on investments. The unrealized value of the portfolio is approximately $1.6m, most of which is in one company. Since the original investment was only $25k and my first actual investment, if I had just stopped there I would be doing way better.
I cannot conclude that I am actually any good at this.
Not bad odds, although I think you and Paul have opportunities that most of us would never see (and rightfully so).
If you're otherwise getting 20% returns, investing 20% more money annually in losing investments will trash those returns. And 20% would be pretty good for the VC industry nowadays, or a hedge fund, or even Berkshire Hathaway.
With investments like Heroku, YC is probably doing better than 20% and can afford a winner-based strategy - but this will rarely be a viable mode of thinking in finance generally.
If you're getting 20% already, you might as well expand your base looking for more 1000x returns, and not cry too much about bad placements; this investing business has a significant opportunity cost risk which means you probably want to err on the side of putting some money in. If you're over 'great' returns, you can afford to do that, and should.
On the flip side, if you're under 'great' you probably want to figure out how to prune your choices away a bit first.