News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by estsauver on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:13AM (#20651971)
I was about to object, but I think as long as Taxi/Uber/Ride share are allowed in the center it'd be a huge improvement for Amsterdam. Taking a car anywhere inside prisengracht is already an exercise in pain, but opening up the city a little bit more would make the few "dicey" intersections in Amsterdam easier on a bike.
Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by jdnenej on Friday August 09, 2019 @05:00AM (#20652488)
Why should taxis be allowed. They are even worse than personal cars because they spend a lot of time driving with no one being transported.
Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by robert_foss on Friday August 09, 2019 @05:10AM (#20652559)
Taxi exemptions make no sense to me either, it would just make life easier for well-off people.

Biking or public transit it the answer.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by PedroCandeias on Friday August 09, 2019 @06:04AM (#20652855)
Transporting bulky or heavy items can be impractical by bike or public transport, as in when shopping or moving.

People with ilnesses and/or mobility issues also come to mind.

Cars' carrying capacity and weatherproofing are useful. As long as the number is limited and their usage is shared (taxis, carsharing), their existence can be a net positive in my opinion.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by exergy on Friday August 09, 2019 @08:15AM (#20653581)
If you've been to Amsterdam, you'll realize that people don't give a fuck about weatherproofing. They're out riding bikes in normal clothes in the biggest of deluges. It's frankly jaw-dropping for me to see.

Nevertheless, the examples you've stated are easily dealt with by allowing as-needed exceptions for the disabled. I don't see what moving houses has to do with wanting to go to the town center in a car though.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by xaitv on Friday August 09, 2019 @09:13AM (#20653951)
The difference in amount of bikes you see on a rainy/cold day vs a warm spring day is huge though.

I think what he means is that when you want to move a couch/bed/big television for example you don't really have good options, because even disassembled these are usually pretty bulky boxes to move through public transport or by bike.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by jchanimal on Friday August 09, 2019 @12:59PM (#20656186)
A flatbed bike trailer can carry more than a pickup truck. We moved house by bike. 20 friends makes easy work.
Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by PedroCandeias on Friday August 09, 2019 @11:30AM (#20655258)
Well, some years ago I helped a friend move from a place in central Amsterdam to Berlin. It would have been really expensive to hire a moving company, compared to renting a van and a car.

In Berlin, where I live (in the center in fact), we're big on reusing and recycling. I don't own a car, but quite often I need to transport bulky second hand items from wherever I bought them, or bulky trash to the recycling center. So I drive one from a car-sharing app.

I've also needed to take someone to a hospital, and it was just quicker to grab a car2go than waiting for an ambulance.

My point is, there are many use cases where the ability to drive or call a taxi is better than the existing alternatives. I agree that cities everywhere need far fewer cars in them, and I think Berlin with its focus on biking and public transportation but availability or car-sharing vehicles for on-demand private driving is heading in the right direction without having to outright ban cars.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by exergy on Friday August 09, 2019 @05:59PM (#20658543)
But your life is the perfect example to make my point!

We SHOULD use cars. But we should treat them as garnish, not the main course. Use them for exactly the things they're great for: moving houses, needing to visit the hospital, long road trips to a destination where you'll need flexibility to drive around once you reach etc.

I'm not advocating a ban on cars. I'm not even advocating not owning them. The simple step of banning them on the main shopping street is a far cry from any of those things, but makes the actual experience of being on that street a lot better for the shoppers.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by magduf on Friday August 09, 2019 @10:20AM (#20654557)
>Transporting bulky or heavy items can be impractical by bike or public transport, as in when shopping or moving.

You don't use a taxi for moving residences, you use a moving truck.

For shopping, if you can't carry it yourself, then have it delivered.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by barrkel on Friday August 09, 2019 @05:39AM (#20652739)
Bikes and public transport work well for people who can afford to live centrally, close to dense transport networks and within range of easy biking.

But if you're out socializing, you may be drunk (so unsafe to bike) and late (where transport networks start getting sparse). That's when taxis make more sense.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by dagw on Friday August 09, 2019 @06:54AM (#20653101)
But if you're out socializing, you may be drunk (so unsafe to bike) and late (where transport networks start getting sparse). That's when taxis make more sense.

Sure, but why does the taxi have to pick you up right outside the club. Most of the time it's not unreasonable to expect people to walk a short stretch to a place where a taxi can pick you up.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by barrkel on Friday August 09, 2019 @07:03AM (#20653146)
Oh I fully agree with pedestrianizing streets, what I don't agree with is banning taxis from city centres.
Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by dagw on Friday August 09, 2019 @08:18AM (#20653606)
I guess it all depends on how big your definition of "city centers" is. Is it 1 km or 10 km across? Thinking realistically about my own city, I could probably draw 3-5 "islands", each ~1km across, within in the larger city center that I would make car free, but still have roads running between/around them.
Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by johannes1234321 on Friday August 09, 2019 @07:21AM (#20653243)
Taxis are important for elderly or disabled people who can't use public transport or walk medium distances.
Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by jdnenej on Saturday August 10, 2019 @07:30PM (#20665192)
Why can't they? I see people on wheelchairs and elderly get on the bus all the time. Yes walking long distances could be an issue but a good public transport system does not require you to walk long distance. Elderly people usually can't afford to get a taxi everywhere.
Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by johannes1234321 on Saturday August 10, 2019 @09:06PM (#20665559)
There some that can, and some that can't. Some that can innrush our, somemthst can't in rush hour.

And about costs: At least here in Germany health insurance for isntance cover some costs for Taxis (when going to a doctor ... while they got stricter) Also in Germany Taxis have regulated prices in order to give some affordability. (Which is one of the critiques on Uber over here, as Uber can pick the routes they like and can raise prices on high demand, while making it cheap innorder to compete with regulated market during other times in hardly predictable ways, which isn't good for people who depend on working transport infrastructure)

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by namdnay on Friday August 09, 2019 @07:15AM (#20653215)
I don’t think they’re worse, because the total carbon footprint is much smaller compared to everyone owning their own car
Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by pilsetnieks on Friday August 09, 2019 @10:33AM (#20654695)
Also much less space would be taken up by street parking. Eliminate parking space in those limited zones, and you can have wider walking spaces, more greenery, that's already a benefit.

A solution doesn't have to be 100% perfect immediately to be of benefit to people.

Re:Berlin’s Popular Shopping Streets Will Go Car-Free by estsauver on Friday August 09, 2019 @08:12AM (#20653563)
Higher standards enforced on commercial drivers license/taxi, adhoc transit for elderly/mobility reduced (you're on crutches), things like delivery of a modest amount of heavy shopping from stores without delivery, and because the central area of Amsterdam is actually relatively large.