News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by JohnJamesRambo on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @09:56AM (#20634705)
For cows at least, I’m not sure where this infinite level of suffering you mention comes in. They grow on a ranch well taken care of and have all the food and medical care they could want (more than most Americans can say!). Then they are taken to a feedlot and given all the fattening grain they could ever want (if you’ve ever owned an animal you know that unlimited food is their nirvana) before being humanely slaughtered in an approved and as painless as possible way.

Something else to think of is if not for being grown for food they wouldn’t have existed at all. Is not existing better than that life they get? It’s an interesting question.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/26669595/

That study measured fecal cortisol (indicator for stress) upon arriving at a feedlot and after fattening and the animals seem to be within normal limits the whole time.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by ForrestN on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:10AM (#20634803)
This is a very hot take—the feed lots you describe are horrific! Not only are they in tiny, cramped pens, these pens are filled with mud and shit! The food they're eating is not nirvana, it's the barest possible nutrition to fatten them up according to their warped genetic urgency to get bigger at an unnaturally fast pace that trashes their natural health. This isn't an all you can eat buffet and a spa—getting pumped full of antibiotics because their environment is so toxic is hardly what I'd guess they "want."

This kind of argument relies on the idea that human beings and animals are fundamentally different, that somehow cow suffering is unrelated to human suffering. But most of what we feel and do every day is not actually dictated by consciousness. If you were put into a tiny, roasting summer pen so tiny you couldn't even walk in circles, filled with drugs, covered in your own excrement, ravaged by hunger even though all you do is eat dirty grey hard food, I don't think you'd respond with some kind of elegant, mathematical, civilized emotion. You'd be out of your mind with terror, sadness and grief. Cows can feel all those things, and they do in factory farms. It's common sense, and I agree with those who say we will look back on this era as a disgusting, ignominious chapter in human society.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by wysifnwyg on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:28AM (#20634980)
>https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/26669595/

>That study measured fecal cortisol (indicator for stress) upon arriving at a feedlot and after fattening and the animals seem to be within normal limits the whole time.

It seems like your opinion is not supported by the scientific evidence that reflects stress levels.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by throw_away on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:50AM (#20635227)
I'm not going to buy the whole paper, but this seems to be studying whether there is additional stress in humid, tropical climates, not whether feedlots affect stress levels. Note that there is no non-feedlot control. The fact that it says that stress indicators were in the "normal ranges for cattle" could mean simply that they are not more stressed than feedlot animals in non-humid, non-tropical climates.

The one paper that cites this one is also about how temperature and climate differences affect reproduction rates: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by wysifnwyg on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:04PM (#20635954)
>That study measured fecal cortisol (indicator for stress) upon arriving at a feedlot and after fattening and the animals seem to be within normal limits the whole time.

Perhaps you have a different definition of what normal means?

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by throw_away on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:22PM (#20636148)
I think you're willfully ignoring the main intent of this paper (effects of climate, not effects of feedlots) and instead replying with trite, condescending responses and nitpicks, so I highly doubt anything productive can come out of this thread.

I don't think that's normal. I think that's trolling. & I think I'm done here.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by wysifnwyg on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:22PM (#20636811)
If you've got any evidence which would support the idea that they were stressed, I would imagine you'd provide it. As you haven't, we both know what the answer is.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by ForrestN on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:54AM (#20635276)
This summary is certainly not scientific evidence of the experience of suffering in these animals! As a start, who decided what level of stress is "within normal limits?" If the idea is that this somehow "scientifically" proves that cows don't suffer when confined in abject squalor, well, good luck with that.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by wysifnwyg on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:21AM (#20635513)
It seems like you'd prefer to reject science when it doesn't support your opinions.
[dead]
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by wysifnwyg on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:03PM (#20635940)
>That study measured fecal cortisol (indicator for stress) upon arriving at a feedlot and after fattening and the animals seem to be within normal limits the whole time.

If you're not aware, that's not the title of the paper and is indeed the content.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by lawlessone on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:54AM (#20635275)
>It seems like your opinion is not supported by the scientific evidence that reflects stress levels.

people can be happy in pretty shite situations too.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by wysifnwyg on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:27AM (#20635580)
One animal's "shite situation" is another animal's "happy situation".
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Retra on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:42AM (#20635114)
>This kind of argument relies on the idea that human beings and animals are fundamentally different

The argument that humans have any sort of ethical duty at all assumes that humans and animals are fundamentally different. Animals don't have any ethical duty to prevent their food from suffering.

EDIT: Furthermore, human suffering is categorically different from animal suffering because human suffering can be inter-generational and have very long-term consequences. Animals don't transfer their suffering and their morality between generations, and that fact does make human suffering much worse than animal suffering, because human suffering can lead to arbitrarily catastrophic consequences. A tiger biting a human can lead directly to the complete extinction of the tiger. The emotional content of the suffering my be similar, but the consequences are not.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by ForrestN on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:57AM (#20635295)
That doesn't logically follow. My argument is about this case, not about hypothetical cases in which animals cause each other to suffer. If I were able to communicate with, say, a predator who likes torturing its live prey, I'd be happy to do my best to convince them not to do so.

EDIT: So as long as we strip children from their parents (like cows) and thereby ameliorate the generational connection to the parents suffering, it doesn't matter so much that we cause suffering to both the parent and the child?

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Retra on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:08AM (#20635384)
>My argument is about this case, not about hypothetical cases in which animals cause each other to suffer.

I don't know what you're talking about. You said it is wrong to assume humans are different from animals, which makes this case a case of animals (humans) causing suffering in other animals (cows).

>If I were able to communicate with, say, a predator who likes torturing its live prey, I'd be happy to do my best to convince them not to do so.

If I crapped gold, I would be rich. That doesn't mean you can assume I am rich. You can't make a convincing argument by basing your assumptions in fantasy.

>So as long as we strip children from their parents (like cows) and thereby ameliorate the generational connection to the parents suffering, it doesn't matter so much that we cause suffering to both the parent and the child?

What? No. This has nothing to do with parent-child relationships, it has to do with the fact that humans teach and write and communicate ideas across long periods of time. If you take away the ability of humans to communicate and teach each other, then their suffering will be comparable to animal suffering. If you teach cows to read and write, they will stop being treated like animals.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by ForrestN on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @02:10PM (#20637281)
> I don't know what you're talking about. You said it is wrong to assume humans are different from animals, which makes this case a case of animals (humans) causing suffering in other animals (cows).

I'm making a claim about what humans should and shouldn't do to cows, namely that we shouldn't torture them. The behavior of some kind of predator does towards its prey is not relevant.

> If I crapped gold, I would be rich. That doesn't mean you can assume I am rich. You can't make a convincing argument by basing your assumptions in fantasy.

You found a loophole in thousands of years of logical reasoning! Hypotheticals aren't real or useful in thinking and communicating, who knew!!

> What? No. This has nothing to do with parent-child relationships, it has to do with the fact that humans teach and write and communicate ideas across long periods of time. If you take away the ability of humans to communicate and teach each other, then their suffering will be comparable to animal suffering. If you teach cows to read and write, they will stop being treated like animals.

By your reasoning, then, it's actually the torture victims writing about it who are causing the reverberating suffering. If they didn't opt to communicate and teach, their suffering would be fine. Maybe after you've finished convincing everyone to torture animals you can start to shame the writing of memoirs by torture victims?

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday August 08, 2019 @01:53AM (#20642193)
>> The behavior of some kind of predator does towards its prey is not relevant.

It should be. Nonhuman animals can be absolutely ghastly to each other. See for example surplus killing:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surplus_killing

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Retra on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @05:15PM (#20639168)
I don't think you've honestly tried to understand what I'm saying, and I don't think your attitude reflects the maturity I expect of someone seriously attempting to discuss ethics.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday August 08, 2019 @12:58AM (#20641974)
Cramped pens are awful and should be illegal, but farm animals normally and quite nonchalantly shit right were they eat without a care about bacteria and parasites (which many parasites exploit readily) . Mud is really not a problem. Pigs actually wallow in it. Literally. That is were the word "wallow" comes from.

Perhaps human sensitivities are in need of adjustment, just as much as our in sensitivities.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by tashoecraft on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:07AM (#20634779)
Uh, I think your making it quite a bit more glamorous than it is. Feedlots are like if you were placed in a bathroom and given a buffet of a single food source that is designed to be both as cheap as possible whilst fattening you as fast as possible. Than having antibiotics given to you in order to survive the bacteria filled area.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by rjf72 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:21AM (#20634901)
Antibiotics are not given to animals for health reasons (at least not primarily). The antibiotics somehow help the animals grow faster for reasons that are not well understood. As a not so fun fact the vast majority of all antibiotics in the US end up being given to animals.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by dpark on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:51AM (#20635243)
They are given for health reasons. It’s no longer legal in the US to give cattle antibiotics to encourage faster growth. It is legal to give them antibiotics to prevent/treat the liver abscesses they frequently develop as a result of their diet in the feed lot.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by rjf72 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:12AM (#20635417)
The FDA rules left a number of loopholes. Overall usage has declined and in some cases quite substantially, but they're still being misused. For instance animals can still be given antibiotics as a 'preventative measure.' In 2017, there were still 2.3 million kg of antibiotics sold for usage in cattle alone. [1] To try to give that number some context there are about 95 million head of cattle in the US, so that works out 24g per cow per year even at the current reduced rate.

Actually creates quite a sick motivation system if the FDA does close the loopholes. Growers would have an incentive for their animals to develop conditions requiring antibiotics, so long as it did not significantly risk the animal's health.

[1] - http://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2018/12/fda-repor...

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Ididntdothis on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:00AM (#20635327)
They are being given an extremely unsuitable diet so they need antibiotics to deal with this. It’s pretty bad.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by codingvelocity on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:07AM (#20634782)
Cows out to pasture likely have a good life, but I wouldn't say feedlots are especially kind. They are fairly crowded with little to no green space.

I do agree with the rest of your statements though. Beef farming is far kinder then any poultry farming

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:11AM (#20634816)
Hm relatively similar? A chicken has the awareness of a bug. Conditions for a higher mammal vs a chicken might reasonably be very different for the same level of stress.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by codingvelocity on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:43AM (#20635127)
I strongly disagree. We treat chickens quite poor. Laying hens for example, we throw most male chicks into a shredder because they can't produce eggs. That's beyond cruel regardless of their mental capacity. Another example. Chicken debeaking is a practice used to prevent chickens self mutilating or destroying their eggs or each other.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by ksaj on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @02:20PM (#20637367)
> we throw most male chicks into a shredder because they can't produce eggs

They also fight viciously amongst each other. You can only have up to a specific ratio of males and females if you want to avoid outright carnage.

Most debeaking is just taking the point off the top of the beak. This is so when they peck, it simultaneously jolts their jaw. They learn to stop doing that, and every time they try, they get that jab reminder. The amount removed isn't even deep enough to hit any nerves.

Maybe some farmers overdo it, but I haven't witnessed that around any farms I've been to.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by inflatableDodo on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:26AM (#20634955)
>A chicken has the awareness of a bug.

You must know some smart bugs. Birds tend to be surprisingly bright for their brain capacity.

"Research has shown that chickens have some sense of numbers. Experiments with newly hatched domestic chicks showed they can discriminate between quantities. They also have an idea about ordinality, which refers to the ability to place quantities in a series. Five-day-old domestic chicks presented with two sets of objects of different quantities disappearing behind two screens were able to successfully track which one hid the larger number by apparently performing simple arithmetic in the form of addition and subtraction.

Chickens are also able to remember the trajectory of a hidden ball for up to 180 seconds if they see the ball moving and up to one minute if the displacement of the ball is invisible to them. Their performance is similar to that of most primates under similar conditions.

The birds possess self-control when it comes to holding out for a better food reward. They are able to self-assess their position in the pecking order. These two characteristics are indicative of self-awareness.

Chicken communication is also quite complex, and consists of a large repertoire of different visual displays and at least 24 distinct vocalizations. The birds possess the complex ability of referential communication, which involves signals such as calls, displays and whistles to convey information. They may use this to sound the alarm when there is danger, for instance. This ability requires some level of self-awareness and being able to take the perspective of another animal, and is also possessed by highly intelligent and social species, including primates.

Chickens perceive time intervals and can anticipate future events. Like many other animals, they demonstrate their cognitive complexity when placed in social situations requiring them to solve problems.

The birds are able to experience a range of complex negative and positive emotions, including fear, anticipation and anxiety. They make decisions based on what is best for them. They also possess a simple form of empathy called emotional contagion. Not only do individual chickens have distinct personalities, but mother hens also show a range of individual maternal personality traits which appear to affect the behavior of their chicks. The birds can deceive one another, and they watch and learn from each other."

https://www.springer.com/gp/about-springer/media/research-ne...

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Gh0stRAT on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:53AM (#20635256)
Not the OP, and I disagree with their assertion that chickens and bugs are of similar intelligence, but there ARE some very intelligent spiders. (which I know aren't technically "bugs")

>Besides having the capacity to make plans, act on the basis of object permanence, represent specific goals and solve novel problems, Portia often has to confront more than one other spider at the same time. [0]

>Our findings suggest that Portia represents 1 and 2 as discrete number categories, but categorizes 3 or more as a single category that we call ‘many’. [1]

We seem to naturally have a strong tendency to disregard the intelligence and emotional lives of animals. (which if you think about it, was probably strongly selected for at some point in the past)

[0] https://royalsociety.org.nz/news/jumping-spiders-can-count-1...

[1] https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rsfs.201...

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Ididntdothis on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:04AM (#20635347)
“We seem to naturally have a strong tendency to disregard the intelligence and emotional lives of animals. “

It makes ethics much simpler if you deny that an animal can suffer.

To a degree this also happens on conflicts between humans. It’s much easier to kill others if you deny that they may have reasons for doing what they are doing but instead just call them mindless fanatics that can’t be helped.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday August 08, 2019 @03:26AM (#20642523)
I think the OP's comment is just right. Some "bugs" (spiders are "bugs" but they are not insects) have surprisingly complex behavior, and chickens can be surprisingly stupid for animals with actual brains. For instance, they will stay in their coop and drown in a flood, even if they can easily jump over its fence to evade you in other times. It's really incomprehensible.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:36AM (#20635669)
Sure, I was speaking hyperbole. But the differences between chicken awareness and higher mammals is profound. Blurring that is just anthropomorphizing chickens.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by inflatableDodo on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:01PM (#20635918)
The critique of anthropomorphisis, doesn't really make a hell of a lot of sense, if you are comparing chickens and higher mammal's relative awareness. And what about it being blurry don't you like? I mean, it is a bit blurry if you start looking for a very smart chicken and a particularly stupid monkey.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by orwin on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:08AM (#20635378)
>A chicken has the awareness of a bug I this true? I thought that all birds were highly intelligents. Although they don't have any pack instinct, chicken still have a peck order, that mean that they recognize individuality. Thus they probably have a sense of self. If consiousness is an illusion created by senses, they probably have a conscience too then.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Ididntdothis on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:44AM (#20635145)
Have you ever dealt with chickens? They have much more awareness than bugs. It’s not even close.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:32AM (#20635634)
All my young life. They have very marginal responses to their environment. They see a threat, they respond. They turn their backs on the threat, seconds later they are back to pecking at the dirt.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Ididntdothis on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:07PM (#20636658)
I spent a lot of time with chickens when I was a kid. The ones I dealt with had quite distinct personalities, some were friendly, some fearful, some brave and they also seemed to respond to stress. Obviously they are different from humans but I thought they had quite a range of behaviors.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by lostlogin on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:52AM (#20635252)
I don’t know much about chickens but look after some bees. The awareness and organisation of a colony is striking. The bar is perhaps a little higher than the OP intended it to be.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by JoeAltmaier on Thursday August 08, 2019 @07:26AM (#20643480)
Isn't that anthropomorphizing right there? Maybe more correct to say "The evolved stimulus reactions in individuals resulting in complex group behaviors is striking"?

Bees are a great example of mindless creatures with no awareness. They die a horrible death when they sting someone (their internal organs ripped out of their bodies with the stinger) with no obvious awareness of what they're doing.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Ididntdothis on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:58AM (#20635308)
That’s a good point. I often think it would be helpful to view any colonies or bee hives as a living being because they certainly behave like one.

However I am pretty sure that a single chicken has more awareness than a single bee or ant.

Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by durpleDrank on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:37AM (#20635062)
OP's implications were in the context of a modern factory farm. You are describing the life of a cow on an old fashioned farm. Not existing is objectively better than being raised for veal. Perhaps you are unfamiliar with factory farming, I honestly don't recommend going down the animal lib rabbit hole it's incredibly depressing. It's a water slide of cognitive dissonance until you hit rock bottom and realize there needs to be reform.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Franciscouzo on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:38AM (#20635065)
Might be the cynic in me, but that just sounds like p-hacking, they probably tested several "stress indicators" and chose the one that was below 0.05.
Re:Vegetarians Who Turned into Butchers by Ididntdothis on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:42AM (#20635118)
“Something else to think of is if not for being grown for food they wouldn’t have existed at all. Is not existing better than that life they get? It’s an interesting question.”

By that logic we could grow humans in concentration camps and make them perform slave labor for their whole life. Their lives are miserable but at least they have existed.

You seem to have a very rose colored impression of how life is for most animals is on farms or feed lots. Their whole life is miserable and stressful.