That said, some of the complaints I hear about Google being unable to help with shopping queries baffle me. When I search for dishwashers all the results (bar the EnergyStar one, arguably) look helpful. They won't give me an objective recommendation for the best dishwasher for my personal needs, but how the hell is a search engine supposed to manage that?
Likewise, I'm admittedly probably not being served the exact same results as Jeff (I get a couple of local UK ones for a start), but I can't really see how he found it so difficult to find iPhone cases for his wife using a search for iPhone 4 case
The top result is iphone4case.com, which is rather nicely designed even if the purchase links do go via another merchant. The next four results appear to be legit merchant sites - sandwiched in the middle is Google's suggestion you try a shopping search with its own custom price comparison engine.
Only one result on the home page is a splog and whilst four of the sites have "buy" links that redirect you to the purchase page of a separate merchant, the average internet consumer isn't going to mind, and certainly isn't going to find the results "useless" in their quest to buy a case online. It's not that big a flaw to the usability of Google given the average user really couldn't care less if the helpful site with the big pictures of phones is simply deep affiliate linking to Casemate.
The mission of Google is to help users find stuff, not generate the maximum possible number of ad impressions per query (which would be quite short-sighted).
But, is it really getting worse? It's never been possible to use Google effectively to research dishwashers. Never. I remember using a Firefox extension to block specific domains from Google search for a long time (it's now called "OptimizeGoogle" but had another name before that).
Dishwashers aside, I still find Google pretty effective.
Jeff's post starts with a chart that shows that 88.2% of SO's traffic comes from Google; if Google was that bad, wouldn't users start to use something else? Where is the increase in traffic from Bing (0.9% from the same chart!)? Where's the nascent but so powerful traffic from blekko...??!?