News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Care and Feeding of the Android GPU by jrockway on Monday January 03, 2011 @06:35AM (#2062846)
I turn animations off. Useless eye candy that just wastes the battery.

Also, is it really fair to compare the N1, a phone that's over a year old, to brand-new WP7 phones?

Re:The Care and Feeding of the Android GPU by jemmons on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @12:43PM (#2067767)
How about we compare the N1 (released Jan 5th, 2010) with the first gen iPhone (released June 29th, 2007)? Even the 2007 iPhone had smooth scrolling/compositing/animation and was always responsive to touch gestures. I'm pretty sure you can't claim a phone made three years before the N1 had an unfair technology advantage, right?
Re:The Care and Feeding of the Android GPU by Lewisham on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @01:38AM (#2066110)
It's interesting how you railed on people earlier for mentioning that responsiveness and animations weren't great, and yet you have animations turned off.
Re:The Care and Feeding of the Android GPU by sjs382 on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @12:22PM (#2067685)
I have a Droid Incredible. (Similar specs to the Nexus One) I don't have animations off. I have 5 home screens and 3 active home screen widgets (Beautiful Widgets and 2 different Jorte Calendar widgets.)

I don't have any problems with responsiveness or battery life.

Re:The Care and Feeding of the Android GPU by grayrest on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @02:15PM (#2068069)
I have a DI as well (with an undervolt/overclock kernel) and while the stutters are quite short, they're definitely there. As an easy example, scrub left/right quickly using the optical joystick on the stock home screen. If you're looking for it or paying attention, it's not that difficult to notice 2-3 frame pauses elsewhere but those are intermittent so I assume they're GC pauses. It doesn't hinder my enjoyment of the platform, but when you're looking for something to criticize it's an easy target.

As for battery life, it depends entirely on where you live. I experimented on it for months before finally figuring out that well over 50% of the power draw on the system is the data network (mobile network option when you hold down power). If you have it on when you have really weak/no reception, the phone will burn through the full battery in about 4 hours and it's pretty simple to lose 20% battery in 15 minutes. If you always have a decent connection, your battery life will be fine, if you happen to live in a place where you have holes in your coverage (e.g. NYC urban canyons), battery life is terrible.

After realizing that, I set up a set of Locale rules to shut down the network when I'm on the wireless network at home/work and to shut it down when I lose signal. Combined with the undervolted kernel, I normally get 48 hours on a charge for my normal use (~350MB/mo).

Re:The Care and Feeding of the Android GPU by vshade on Monday January 03, 2011 @01:16PM (#2064037)
Yes, it is really fair. Both the N1 and the WP7 phones have the same screen resolution and the same first gen snapdragon SoC.
Re:The Care and Feeding of the Android GPU by TillE on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @06:23AM (#2066591)
For perspective, the first-gen iPhone and iPod touch are perfectly responsive, even though they're ancient in gadget years. When there are Android phones which feel as slow as crud despite featuring the same (or better) hardware as an iPhone 3GS, you have a big problem.

Google has done a lot of cool stuff for developers in the last few iterations of Android. The NDK has evolved into something quite decent, definitely good enough for writing games now. But responsiveness is the major user experience issue that they've completely failed to address.

Re:The Care and Feeding of the Android GPU by bonch on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @02:38PM (#2068150)
Well, no wonder you "don't notice touch responsiveness."