Credit cards are a high CAC business in the premium space -- hundreds to a thousand dollars for an Amex Platinum class card. All Apple does different here is lower CAC by leveraging their immense brand power and their retail network and a few neat frilly UI features. Those aren't worth the opportunity cost of a 2% flat cash back card with no annual fee like the Citi Double Cash, or 2.67% with Bank of America if you have 100K in total balances including investments.
Those are the numbers to beat, and also why it's so hard to truly innovate in this space.
In other words, Apple's enlisting millions of people to push at a grassroots level for NFC adoption, and making money off them at the same time.
Anywhere that uses Stripe can accept Apple Pay, and the same approach from meatspace works in getting people to turn it on - get people to complain because they're missing out on their cash-back.
- mobile app improvements with effortless freeze/cancellation/card reorder
- great integrations in iOS/macOS
- even the metal credit card that is very similar to how the physical apple card has been described
For now the rewards program I'm works well for me and exceeds what Apple has announced; but Apple's is the next best option. One good thing with Apple Card is that by being in the MasterCard network, it can be good for those places that don't take Amex.
Apple has the clout and the PR team to make that happen. They are still going after Facebook but I suspect they’ll go after credit cards soon enough.
Compared to my MajorBank card, I expect that Apple Card will have somewhat worse rewards. But the process - signup, spending tracking and notifications, accessing rewards, freezing, cancellation - will be leagues better, and privacy will be better too. That will be their edge.
The MajorBank mobile app is weird and janky feeling, with lots of ads and other nonsense in it. It pushes me to open investment accounts and take out a mortgage. It tells me I can get 10% back at KidsPizzaRestaurant. It promotes "offers we've selected just for you based on your relationship with MajorBank," through virtue of monitoring my spending history.
I expect none of that from Apple. In my mind the risks are 1. Goldman Sachs and 2. Apple's financialization / being incentivized to push people into debt.