News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by cookiecaper on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:31PM (#2061107)
Copyright law is really disappointing here. How do such long terms contribute to the progress of sciences or the arts? The writers and main contributors to most of the pieces named are dead. The publishers have made their cash time and time again and now most of these pieces are by no means "hot sellers", though they may be of cultural or historical interest. And, there's 40 years left before the copyright expires.

All this does is allow two extra generations to leech off of the creativity of their fathers without actually contributing anything themselves. Same goes for the two subsequent generations that fill the publishing houses that originally print these works.

Do we really believe that Lord of the Rings or Lord of the Flies would not have been written or published if the copyright term was only 28 years (in fact, they _were_ published when the copyright term was 28 years)? It should be evident that cultural experiences will be generated even if the money doesn't flow down for 100-200 years (not that there won't be money anyway -- they'll just have to do something useful with the property, just like anyone else).

The whole thing is just patently ridiculous. What do we gain by refusing to allow free commentary or contribution on Lord of the Rings? Tolkien is dead and gone and made a comfortable existence on his work I'm sure. If he was concerned with ensuring his posterity and publisher would have money from his work, he could have taken various measures to do so, like divesting large amounts of money to them in his will.

It is ridiculous that all of society and culture has to suffer because of corporate lobbyists that don't want Disney et al to lose money. It's not like the publishers are being robbed here, they've made more than enough money on these properties and now it's time to share. Intellectual property was never meant to trap ideas -- it was meant to make their sharing plausible and reasonable (before the internet, there was significant overhead involved with publication and wide dissemination of such material). Now we just have leeches looking to ensure their own fat paycheck at the expense of free culture.

I would be very happy to see a copyright law of 28 years since publication or less with no extensions, applied retroactively to all works under copyright in the United States. I don't see why life of the author should be considered -- if someone writes a good story, that's great, but 28 years of unlimited monopoly on that is quite enough. And note that public domain doesn't mean the copyright holder can't make money anymore -- it just means he has to provide something that the market deems valuable, instead of standing as a gatekeeper and profiting off of everyone else's imagination.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by ShabbyDoo on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:39PM (#2061135)
"The writers and main contributors to most of the pieces named are dead."

Your argument presumes that a copyrighted work is not a transferable asset. Let's say your grandfather, at age 75, pens what some publishing house deems the next Great American Novel. He wishes to live in a nice retirement community and is willing to sell the copyright to this work as a means of paying for this lifestyle. The value of his copyright is function of its longevity, so he would garner a larger payment today if copyright laws allow his work to provide a better NPV to the purchaser. Certainly, exclusive rights for 2N years are worth no less than rights for N years, so extensions of copyright can not provider a lower NPV.

I am not arguing for or against any particular provision of copyright law -- I am simply objecting to the "author is dead anyway" argument against longer copyright periods.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by cookiecaper on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:45PM (#2061160)
Well, I don't think it should be exclusively about the life of the author, as I explain later in the comment. I think a relatively short general term from date of publication is good regardless of life of author.

I am merely indicating that in cases where the author died many years ago, all the extension of copyright does is allow non-creative people that were once attached to people that were attached to the original author (great-great grandchildren, the men who now control the publishers (very unlikely to be the same men that controlled the publisher back when these works were published in the 50s)) to profit exclusively off of the author's work, which is the very antithesis of a motivation to produce your own creative work. The creative originator long since got all imaginable value out of the work and now the copyright is merely a memorial to society's worship of money over all else.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by ShabbyDoo on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:48PM (#2061170)
It seems that your argument is generalizable to the inherit-ability of wealth.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by cookiecaper on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:15PM (#2061264)
Wealth is fine in literal terms. If you want to pass money on to your progenitors, that is just fine, as it is with all real property. The key here is that intellectual property and real property have some very fundamental differences. Ideas are assigned owners only to make it plausible to spread those ideas massively -- a stipulation that was necessary when it was expensive to spread ideas (printing). With the internet, dissemination of ideas is much cheaper, though there are often still production costs.

Ideas cannot be owned; they are like fire and can only be equally shared. We assign monopolies to make publishing feasible, not to ensure the wealth of two or three generations that live off of the creativity of their grandfathers without contributing anything themselves. If the grandfather wants this to happen, he can convert his copyright to real money while it lasts (and afterward too, though it's harder without the monopoly, of course) and then transfer that money to his children. He shouldn't be able to hold ideas hostage from the people that he shared them with, however.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by uvdiv on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:53PM (#2061377)
>Ideas cannot be owned; they are like fire and can only be equally shared. We assign monopolies to make publishing feasible, not to ensure the wealth of two or three generations that live off of the creativity of their grandfathers without contributing anything themselves.

Here's an alternative ethics. Nontrivial ideas are not natural resources but are created by an author; just as a physical object is the property of its creator, ideas are an intangible property owned by their author. The author can deny others access to his ideas, simply by not-disclosing them (keeping them secret); she has intrinsic control over them. IP ownership is not a monopoly "assigned" by some intangible collective; it is the natural property of its creator. Publishing rights are not an artificial benefit created by government to subsidize authors (out of benevolence); they are contracts between an author and publisher, transferring specific and limited rights (not ownership). Publishers can be forced to pay the author royalties, not out of utilitarian reasons, but because they voluntarily agreed to such terms (the author having natural leverage, e.g. she can refuse to disclose his ideas).

>Ideas are assigned owners

Did you have that thought, or did the social collective assign it to you?

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by joe_the_user on Sunday January 02, 2011 @07:55PM (#2061673)
Nontrivial ideas are not natural resources but are created by an author; just as a physical object is the property of its creator, ideas are an intangible property owned by their author.

Can you name the algorithm used to distinguish "trivial ideas" from "nontrivial ideas"? I'm waiting... What about an algorithm for determining when "nontrivial idea A" is equivalent to "nontrivial idea B"? We're still foundering on the haltering problem here, I think... OK, now, what about an algorithm to determine when idea A is "useful"? Ah, you need... society for this one I think... Indeed, you "natural" idea contains an excess of unnatural contortions...

Even more. Let's suppose you really could determine all these not-algorithmically-determinable things and the criteria was simple. Any string X with length greater than N is "nontrivial".

What happens when every string of length N+1 is copyrighted/patented/etc? The 2^N+1 string then are contained in every possible further nontrivial idea and the owners of them can extract rent perpetually. Things are not quite at this level yet but we're getting closer (the state of video should give one pause).

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by wlievens on Monday January 03, 2011 @05:25AM (#2062748)
The comment about nontriviality and equivalence goes for physical objects too, you know.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by joe_the_user on Monday January 03, 2011 @04:27PM (#2064740)
Indeed,

The patent system only makes in a world in which you have a finite number of industries performing a finite number of useful tasks. Then the social context lets you distinguish useful and useless inventions. Even then, the GGP's point of nontrivial works naturally belonging to their inventors is balderdash. What you can say, all you can say, is, with physical inventions in a fairly static world, that society can somewhat coherently grant people monopolies on inventions for public policy purposes.

But in a world where every activity, including the modification of the physical world, is approach "information processing", the whole patent system is become logically unsupportable. In this information processing world, a patent is government granting people deeds to an ill-defined terrain. And it's fairly clear our world is getting closer to that, is it not?

And with a ill-defined terrain, common sense about what's useful, common usage, etc just go out the window. All patents approach the status of troll-patents.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by Helianthus16 on Sunday January 02, 2011 @06:08PM (#2061415)
>Here's an alternative ethics. Nontrivial ideas are not natural resources but are created by an author; just as a physical object is the property of its creator, ideas are an intangible property owned by their author.

This is not an alternative ethics (if indeed this is an ethics instead of a system of legal ownership), it is the _dominant_ ethics.

>they are contracts between an author and publisher, transferring specific and limited rights (not ownership). Publishers can be forced to pay the author royalties, not out of utilitarian reasons, but because they voluntarily agreed to such terms (the author having natural leverage, e.g. she can refuse to disclose his ideas).

Except in a market where ideas are not scarce and the publishing _is_ success, the creatives are exploited and their so-called property rights a joke.

We all understand the _theory_ behind your 'natural property,' the ownership of something you create. We just don't agree with it anymore, because in many cases it has failed and in the future it will not be relevant.

>Did you have that thought, or did the social collective assign it to you?

Missed it. He's pointing out the semi-fictional nature of idea ownership, not claiming originality for his ideas.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by davidw on Sunday January 02, 2011 @06:33PM (#2061474)
Here is some actual economics:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good

For many things, creating artificial property is a good solution, but it is of course a compromise more than real property ever will be, due to its nature.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by euccastro on Monday January 03, 2011 @04:58AM (#2062714)
> The author can deny others access to his ideas, simply by not-disclosing them (keeping them secret);

At least that doesn't deny you the right to rediscover them.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by shpxnvz on Monday January 03, 2011 @04:38AM (#2062687)
Ideas aren't created, they are discovered. They aren't property, either, in any legal sense in the U.S.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by stretchwithme on Sunday January 02, 2011 @06:01PM (#2061396)
Yes, but will someone bother to create assets for themselves that disappear on their deaths when they do have people to care for?

Property isn't really property if you can't sell it or give it to someone else. Liquidity is very important to many people.

While undermining this will have little impact on the generation of a lof of crap, it will absolutely destroy the "long tail" for many valuable things that are receive little recognition when they are created.

I do recognize that we should only be handing out monopolies when it absolutely benefits society. These ridiculously long copyrights only exist because our legislators have put their own interests above the national interest.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by joe_the_user on Sunday January 02, 2011 @07:38PM (#2061640)
A copyright is a government granted-monopoly.

Essentially, it's a little bit of the state's right to restrict other people which has been given to you for reasons that supposedly wise-people consider important.

One might argue that it is almost the opposite of private wealth.

The government doesn't grant the descendants of social security recipients the right to their forebears' pension either. By your earlier reaoning, the state is "depriving" the pensioners of ability to sell a perpetual income stream to a third party. (yes, this is sarcasm...)

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by collint on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:08PM (#2061239)
One needs not inherit wealth through death to carry it on.

That's what living is for.

The privileges afforded from wealth certainly give you a leg up. Take it, or get out of the way.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by WalterBright on Monday January 03, 2011 @01:04AM (#2062291)
I make my living off of copyright.

But I think the term should be 28 years, and it could be extended by the copyright holder for a few additional years at a fee of $5,000/year.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by shadowpwner on Monday January 03, 2011 @01:23AM (#2062333)
But a fee makes it only affordable to large companies, which is the exact reason against extended copyright protection.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by xyzzyz on Monday January 03, 2011 @03:41AM (#2062606)
"a few additional years" does not mean "indefinitely".
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by rmc on Monday January 03, 2011 @12:19PM (#2063826)
You could legally commit all your works to the public domain in 28 years?
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by griftah on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:48PM (#2061169)
Why having Lord of the Rings in public domain is so important?
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by slantyyz on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:52PM (#2061189)
Maybe for the same reason that having Romeo & Juliet and King Lear in the public domain is so important.

Would West Side Story or Ran have been made if they weren't?

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by griftah on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:13PM (#2061261)
Copyright didn't seem to stop authors of D&D or many derivative fantasy novels that have more in common with Lord of the Rings than West Side Story with Shakespeare.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by i_c_b on Sunday January 02, 2011 @10:10PM (#2061935)
Why do you think D&D calls hobbits halflings, and ents treants? TSR has a vexed history with Tolkien's estate.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by Fargren on Monday January 03, 2011 @03:02PM (#2064463)
Has had. TSR doesn't exist anymore.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by patio11 on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:10PM (#2061254)
This is a good question. LOTR is being actively commercially exploited and the commercial exploitations are darn good. Meanwhile, it's cultural impact hasn't been noticeably blunted by copyright -- that novel launched at least one industry, to say nothing of being repurposed by virtually every book in adjacent genres.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by chc on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:58PM (#2061388)
I don't see what that has to do with anything. Public domain works can still be commercially exploited. The only difference is that LOTR wouldn't have sat in preproduction hell for years because of squabbles over the rights. Peter Jackson could have gone ahead and made his very fine movies — instead, copyright almost got him forced out of The Hobbit.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by MessagePad2100 on Sunday January 02, 2011 @07:29PM (#2061612)
Another possibility: Instead of squabbling with the publisher/Tolkien Trust, Michael Bay could have simultaneously made a movie as well to compete with Jackson's vision of the movie.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by chc on Sunday January 02, 2011 @08:31PM (#2061728)
I don't understand your point. If you mean he could have made a LOTR movie, I still don't see how that's relevant, given that:

1. That wouldn't happen, for a large number of reasons.

2. That happens even in the current system (see "The Exorcist: The Beginning" for an example in the movie world).

3. Michael Bay already had movies in competition with the LOTR franchise — copyright does nothing to prevent that. It just requires that some people distantly related to people who paid some money to Tolkien get paid if you want to use the LOTR names and characters.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by davidcuddeback on Sunday January 02, 2011 @08:26PM (#2061717)
Nothing wrong with competition. Let the makers of the better movie prosper.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by crystalis on Monday January 03, 2011 @07:06AM (#2062888)
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by Helianthus16 on Sunday January 02, 2011 @06:16PM (#2061436)
>LOTR is being actively commercially exploited and the commercial exploitations are darn good.

Darn good, but not perfect. We are now denied the right to re-interpret LOTR, perhaps because we want to include the Scouring of the Shire--not because the movie was necessarily worse without it, but because we _want_ to.

And heck, take a better example: the Harry Potter movies are in great need of re-interpretation, but don't expect to see independent film-makers getting a bite at that apple anytime soon.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by griftah on Sunday January 02, 2011 @06:43PM (#2061502)
Do we really need more fanfics?
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by Jach on Sunday January 02, 2011 @09:18PM (#2061843)
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by Vivtek on Sunday January 02, 2011 @09:32PM (#2061864)
Well, now we don't.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by Helianthus16 on Sunday January 02, 2011 @07:05PM (#2061565)
when you accept that the LOTR movies are just fanfics we've spent millions on, you'll understand why we need more fanfics.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by griftah on Sunday January 02, 2011 @07:49PM (#2061665)
Do we really need to blur difference between art and fanfics even more then?
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by gwern on Sunday January 02, 2011 @09:46PM (#2061884)
Yes. Fanfiction is an artificial term imposed on us by our current IP regime. It is not a natural kind and simply refers to normal literary practices that run afoul of current laws. Why isn't Shakespeare's _Othello_ fanfiction of Cinthio's short story? Because there was no copyright to run afoul of, and so it was 'only' a retelling or adaptation.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by gridspy on Sunday January 02, 2011 @06:11PM (#2061422)
Worth noting here that new works such as the LOTR movies would get a fresh copyright term.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by rmc on Monday January 03, 2011 @12:21PM (#2063832)
Yes the LoTR films would be under new copyright. However the original books would be free. You would not be forking the film, but the book.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by whyenot on Sunday January 02, 2011 @07:43PM (#2061654)
Not always darn good. Here is a counterexample: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Return_of_the_King_(1980_fi...
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by wtallis on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:52PM (#2061188)
I think the point is more that continued copyright protections don't serve any purpose, and thus are unconstitutional.
[deleted]
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by FluidDjango on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:05PM (#2061229)
Let them defend the current policies as promoting, "the progress of science and useful arts..." - as opposed to promoting corporate wealth.

Then let's also define "for limited times..." in terms of decades not centuries.

Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by wtallis on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:04PM (#2061224)
Right. But a copyright law that doesn't have the purpose and effect of promoting that progress is unconstitutional. Congress can't just hand out intellectual property rights on a whim, nor can they be used to stand in the way of progress.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar... by sesqu on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @05:36AM (#2070601)
Tolkien is dead and gone and made a comfortable existence on his work I'm sure.

I wanted to check up on that, and found this:

So far from losing money [as expected], sales so exceeded the break-even point as to make Tolkien regret that he had not taken early retirement. However, this was still based only upon hardback sales.

The really amazing moment was when The Lord of the Rings went into a pirated paperback version in 1965. Firstly, this put the book into the impulse-buying category; and secondly, the publicity generated by the copyright dispute alerted millions of American readers to the existence of something outside their previous experience, but which appeared to speak to their condition. By 1968 The Lord of the Rings had almost become the Bible of the "Alternative Society".

This development produced mixed feelings in the author. On the one hand, he was extremely flattered, and to his amazement, became rather rich. On the other, he could only deplore those whose idea of a great trip was to ingest The Lord of the Rings and LSD simultaneously.

source: http://www.tolkiensociety.org/tolkien/biography.html