Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar...
by griftah on Sunday January 02, 2011 @06:43PM
(#2061502)
Do we really need more fanfics?
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar...
by Vivtek on Sunday January 02, 2011 @09:32PM
(#2061864)
Well, now we don't.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar...
by Helianthus16 on Sunday January 02, 2011 @07:05PM
(#2061565)
when you accept that the LOTR movies are just fanfics we've spent millions on, you'll understand why we need more fanfics.
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar...
by griftah on Sunday January 02, 2011 @07:49PM
(#2061665)
Do we really need to blur difference between art and fanfics even more then?
Re:What Could Have Been Entering the Public Domain on Januar...
by gwern on Sunday January 02, 2011 @09:46PM
(#2061884)
Yes. Fanfiction is an artificial term imposed on us by our current IP regime. It is not a natural kind and simply refers to normal literary practices that run afoul of current laws. Why isn't Shakespeare's _Othello_ fanfiction of Cinthio's short story? Because there was no copyright to run afoul of, and so it was 'only' a retelling or adaptation.
Darn good, but not perfect. We are now denied the right to re-interpret LOTR, perhaps because we want to include the Scouring of the Shire--not because the movie was necessarily worse without it, but because we _want_ to.
And heck, take a better example: the Harry Potter movies are in great need of re-interpretation, but don't expect to see independent film-makers getting a bite at that apple anytime soon.