News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI: Delivery drivers involved in Amazon theft ring by EForEndeavour on Saturday August 03, 2019 @07:36PM (#20603412)
> suppose someone had broken into my house over the last 5 years and stolen something from one of those receptacles that was eventually thrown out. should I be upset? now note that I'm not asking if I'm legally entitled to being upset but whether it would be rational to be upset.

A person's response to being burglarized is never purely rational. You've got the distress of the initial discovery, followed by the subsequent process of figuring out what (if anything) they stole, modified, or left behind, and the process of reporting the crime to authorities. Then you'll deal with self-blame about not investing more in home security and uncertainty about whether these thieves will come back for what they left behind (did they break in knowing you were gone, or did they mistakenly think you were home...?). Even if you had excellent video surveillance coverage that proved that they only took stuff you'd forgotten about, the burglar(s) violated your personal space, which obviously feels pretty awful, and may have broken something on their way in. The negativity of getting burglarized is irrational in nature and difficult to quantify in economic terms, but is nevertheless real.

In conclusion, I'd say every victim of B&E has great reasons to be upset, regardless of what (if anything) was stolen.

Re:FBI: Delivery drivers involved in Amazon theft ring by mlevental on Saturday August 03, 2019 @07:40PM (#20603425)
all of that is certainly true but not the point of my thought experiment because I'm sure Amazon the corporation doesn't experience emotional distress from having its personal space violated (so I'm sure that there won't be punitive damages for emotional distress in their sentences).
Re:FBI: Delivery drivers involved in Amazon theft ring by EForEndeavour on Sunday August 04, 2019 @12:12AM (#20604383)
But... your thought experiment was specifically about a hypothetical burglary perpetrated against a person, and specifically did not mention Amazon or corporations.
Re:FBI: Delivery drivers involved in Amazon theft ring by mlevental on Sunday August 04, 2019 @01:13AM (#20604544)
Yes to illustrate a point about Amazon's margins, not to compare the person's emotional duress to Amazon's