Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy
by EForEndeavour on Saturday August 03, 2019 @07:19PM
(#20603330)
How is 50% efficiency five times worse than 90%? Isn't that a factor of roughly two?
90% efficiency: spend 100 joules to get 90 useful joules, wasting 10.
50% efficiency: spend 100 joules to get 50 useful joules, wasting 50.
You could say that 50% efficiency is five times more wasteful than 90%, but that doesn't strike me as a useful metric. More useful is to observe that spending 100 units of energy at 90% efficiency gets you roughly twice as much usable energy compared to 50% efficiency (9/5 = 1.8 times, to be precise).
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy
by simonebrunozzi on Monday August 05, 2019 @01:48PM
(#20616361)
10 -> 50 : 5 times worse.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy
by EForEndeavour on Monday August 05, 2019 @05:24PM
(#20619150)
In my opinion, that's the less useful way of measuring efficiency. By that metric, 99% efficiency is twice as good as 98%, since the former wastes only 1% of input compared to 2%. Isn't it more useful to recognize that 98% efficiency is almost the same as 99%?
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy
by reitzensteinm on Saturday August 03, 2019 @07:53PM
(#20603494)
Whether or not it's a good idea, the numbers you're quoting aren't really an argument for it.
A low efficiency solution with high storage capacity absolutely has a role in the transition to renewables.
Solar and wind are going to necessarily be overbuilt in terms of peak capacity. If you have enough to power your country on a relatively calm overcast day, what happens on a windy clear day?
Can't find a proper reference, but one of the most efficient way to store energy is pumping water up and storing it there, in which case the efficiency is close to 90%, and the cost of storing large amounts of energy are low. Doing what you are proposing should have an efficiency below 50% - or more than 5 times worse -, without considering much higher energy storage costs.