I wonder if once a post shows up formally on something like HN's front page, we see it as implicitly claiming authority in a medium-is-the-message way, even if it all it's doing is thinking out loud. Then the article seems disappointing when it turns out just to be someone's notes on shit they were thinking about.
And predicting / guessing at solutions without having done the "deep academic literature" reading is actually an excellent learning technique that connects you more deeply to the reading if you decide to go down that path. Or do the predicting in a blog post and get free answers from the experts correcting you.
I've "invented" a few things in my life only to later find the existing patents. I had so much fun doing it and learned so much, I'm glad I didn't know about the patents ahead of time.
"I might be wrong but would love some feedback. It’s an exceedingly complicated topic which has been researched for hundreds of years so it might be that this observation has been made before."
And that very important word "might", right in the headline too.
People that do come to solutions to problems (including deep problems), often come to them "without reading into the deep academic literature around [them]" first, so there's that...