News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday August 02, 2019 @09:53AM (#20592895)
I did read the recent research in support of intermittent fasting, but a lot of the quotes in this article seem like pseudoscience.

> It also reduces the time spent each day processing food and lengthens the period devoted to cleansing and restoring the body’s cells, both of which have positive health effects.

So "cleansing and restoring" the body's cells only happens when one isn't eating?? Gonna need a citation for that one.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by lhl on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:33AM (#20593259)
I haven’t read the article so I don’t know the context but it’s probably specifically referencing autophagy, which is very nutrient sensitive: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6321489/

If you’re looking for the science, “autophagy,” “AMPK”, “MTOR” are probably good search terms to start with.

Here’s a recent review/introduction on how fasting stimulates autophagy that you can scihub: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S156816371... (if you just want PubMed access you can give this one a read: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5783752/ ) and a couple more starting points (follow the citation chain) if you’re looking into molecular mechanisms: https://www.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/ajpendo.00008.20... or https://www.nature.com/articles/ncb2152

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by gwd on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:00AM (#20592946)
> So "cleansing and restoring" the body's cells only happens when one isn't eating?? Gonna need a citation for that one.

But the article specifies exactly what they mean:

> When we eat, our body releases insulin. That disrupts the process of autophagy (from the Greek, meaning “self-devouring”), by which cells deconstruct old, damaged components in order to release energy and build new molecules. Autophagy helps to counteract the aging of cells and builds immunity. Fasts stimulate autophagy and allow the full molecular process to take place, as a team led by Frank Madeo at the University of Graz in Austria found in 2017.

Now maybe insulin doesn't have anything to do with autophagy, but if if the claim that insulin stops autophagy is correct, then "lengthens the period devoted to cleansing and restoring the body’s cells" has a specific well-defined meaning.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by shadowoflight on Friday August 02, 2019 @12:56PM (#20594479)
Interesting, it seems this could explain why a ketogenic diet has a cleansing effect, as it also reduces insulin production which may trigger autophagy.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by lm28469 on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:19AM (#20593112)
Yeah they're taking some of the woo-woo shit a bit too far sometimes, but it's pretty clear that the human body didn't evolve with 3 meals a day + snacks &c.

It's less about fasting being magic and more about our current lifestyle putting too much/unnecessary strains on our organs.

The real deal with IT is that after a while you became more aware about hunger. Then you can chose to eat when you are hungry vs when "it's time to eat". A lot of it is due to Ghrelin[0] and Insulin afaik. Basically the more regularly you eat the more your body will signal you to eat when the regular time approach -> you feel hungry but in most case your body doesn't _need_ to eat at that time.

There are some "easy" and basic tricks that really helps. One of the best is eating very light dinners, which helps not feeling hungry in the morning (you can easily reduce your daily calorie intake by 30%+ like that). On the other hand eating a big dinner -> feeling super hungry the day after thanks to insulin [1].

[0] https://www.diabetes.co.uk/in-depth/fasting-may-change-bodys...

[1] https://steemit.com/stemng/@pangoli/why-you-wake-up-hungry-a...

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by adrianN on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:27AM (#20593197)
I'm very wary of all evolutionary nutrition arguments, because a) we know very little about prehistoric lifestyle, b) there have been many generations since agriculture started and agricultural societies regularly outcompeted hunter-gatherers.

Furthermore it's really not clear that something is better just because it was that way during the time we supposedly evolved. For example, we didn't evolve with antiseptics either and yet disinfecting wounds seems like a pretty good idea.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by lm28469 on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:55AM (#20593443)
70% of Americans are obese or overweight. Every other major countries are following the trend. It's crystal clear that we're fucking up. IT is one of many ways to stay healthy that's all, no more no less.

> there have been many generations since agriculture started and agricultural societies regularly outcompeted hunter-gatherers.

Never refuted that, it's more efficient in every aspects. The only problem is that we're way past "eating for survival", we eat for fun, when we're bored, when "it's time to eat" no matter if we truly are hungry or not.

> we know very little about prehistoric lifestyle

I'm sure we can all agree they were not eating 3 times a day at regular interval, every single day of their life while sitting 80% of their awake time. Not even talking about the amount of calories or how processed their food was.

> Furthermore it's really not clear that something is better just because it was that way during the time we supposedly evolved. For example, we didn't evolve with antiseptics either and yet disinfecting wounds seems like a pretty good idea.

I fail to see the link. We evolved a way to keep bacterias out (skin) and antiseptics were designed to help with that in certain cases. Regular mealtime is something we came up very recently, especially for the average joe (ie. industrial revolution). Try putting SP98 in a diesel engine, that's what we're doing with our stomachs. It might somehow run for a bit but in the long term it's no bueno.

The human body is simply not designed for what we throw at it, and is incapable of handling the changes in such a small timeframe. Looking out of the window is enough proof that our lifestyle is not adequate.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by adrianN on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:06AM (#20593521)
Animals are getting fatter too, including lab animals whose diet is pretty tightly controlled. Perhaps there are more causes for the obesity epidemic than eating three meals a day and working in an office.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3081766/pdf/rsp...

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by ben7799 on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:17AM (#20593619)
And back when almost no Americans were overweight intermittent fasting wasn't a thing.

IF may be great but it is definitely also riding a diet fad wave right now.

At least IF doesn't involve the sale of anything... that elevates it above almost all the recent diet fads where you end up buying lots of highly processed supplements.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by lhl on Friday August 02, 2019 @01:16PM (#20594699)
Actually intermittent fasting was the norm - Americans averaged three meals a day with no snacks (you’ll spoil your appetite!), and typically spent 12-14 hours between supper/dinner and breakfast. Insulin response remained pulsatile with enough postprandial time for it to return to baseline.

The reference I have handy shows that Americans average 5 meals/snacks per day now: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29574043 although I’ve seen even higher numbers (closer to 6) mentioned.

Ah, found a source analyzing eating frequency (and timing) changes since 1977: https://idmprogram.com/the-critical-importance-of-meal-timin...

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by ben7799 on Friday August 02, 2019 @02:51PM (#20595548)
I'm not sure how that's fasting.

I don't consider myself as someone who fasts and it is typically 13-14 hours from my supper to my breakfast.

Eat dinner around 6-7PM Eat breakfast around 7:30-8AM

My schedule I would assume is shifted forward from say my grandparents schedule. They would have eaten dinner & breakfast earlier due to differences in work hours 50+ years ago.

If that's fasting it seems like a strange/new definition. But maybe a lot of people are indeed still eating something substantial closer to midnight as they watch TV or something?

I actually spread out my lunch into several smaller meals during the day.

But I also exercise a lot, and I'm not buying lunch like so many engineers I work with. My lunch is 1/4-1/2 the size of a sit down restaurant meal.

The old norm was so much more physical activity than today too.

One of those articles is totally right about kids though. When I was a kid I took a lunch to school and that was the only time I ate. My son is going into first grade and all the day cares he went to and his current school have dedicated snack times, 2-3 extra times eating that are not lunch. The day care that had 3 snack times porked the kids up pretty good.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by lhl on Friday August 02, 2019 @06:28PM (#20597164)
Per the article, 14h is actually what’s being spoken about: “There are different ways to go about it, but I advise patients to omit either dinner or breakfast, so that they don’t ingest any food for at least 14 hours at a stretch.” This should probably more specifically described as Time Restricted Eating/Feeding, but IF is sort of used as a catch all for this and other eating patterns, so what can you do.

Sadly, due to snacking and the misconception that they should eat as soon as they get up, I suspect that most Americans probably have an eating window that spans 14-16h instead of 8-10h (which has been RCT’d to show a significant difference in hunger and ad libitum food consumption).

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Ididntdothis on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:04AM (#20592981)
I think people feel the need to add a scientific explanation to things where in my view the pure observation that it seems to work would be enough already. It reminds me a little of Semmelweiss who observed that washing hands reduces infection rates but was ridiculed because he couldn’t explain it.

When I meditate or fast from time to time I can observe that it makes me feel better and I don’t really feel the importance for someone to explain it.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by el_cujo on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:14AM (#20593075)
>I think people feel the need to add a scientific explanation to things where in my view the pure observation that it seems to work would be enough already.

I really could not disagree more, given how much conflicting health information I see talked about seemingly daily.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Ididntdothis on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:19AM (#20593110)
Agreed. But if you try something and it shows benefits then you don’t necessarily need an explanation. For example exercise and mediation done regularly make me feel better but I don’t really care if it’s endorphins, hormones or any other mechanism that causes this.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Retra on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:09AM (#20593543)
For now. But what if it stops working? What if someone else wants the benefit but can't do the same things? What if there are other undesirable consequences that you'd like to avoid? Knowing how something works is generally much more valuable than knowing that it works in the long term.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Ididntdothis on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:40AM (#20593839)
Sure. It’s good to have people trying to understand things but while they are findings explanations we can take advantage of the benefits already and don’t have to wait. I am thinking the same about placebo effects. As long as it works let’s use it and in parallel make an effort to understand the mechanism.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by jeffdavis on Friday August 02, 2019 @12:34PM (#20594316)
One way to look at it is that health tips are subjective: they may be useful depending on the person and their lifestyle.

Another way to look at it is that, if we try hard enough, science will offer explanations that take into account all of these differences. But it might be really hard, like multi-billion dollar studies to reach basic conclusions.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by inimino on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:27AM (#20593201)
Pure observation comes from your own experience, not from reading others'.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by rasengan0 on Friday August 02, 2019 @12:18PM (#20594199)
>I think people feel the need to add a scientific explanation to things where in my view the pure observation that it seems to work would be enough already.

Thank you, I could not agree with this more.

Observation is the basis of science and yet many still need to be passively hand fed how to live and need constant validation from a constantly changing dynamic field where "experts" get fame, power, and attention for their true gospel [1]

Even after I graduated with a science degree and went onto healthcare, my mother would still lovingly remind me, "Son, you may have book smarts, but you need more common sense" :-)

[1] http://nautil.us/issue/74/networks/the-flawed-reasoning-behi...

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by theptip on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:22AM (#20593145)
If you want to make subjective observations like "fasting makes me feel more alert" that is completely fine by me. I fully agree that it's possible to observe positive changes like this without knowing why the change is happening.

However if you make a specific scientific claim about cell "cleansing" then you need to be able to back it up with evidence; without evidence, such claims are just nonsense. There is no "subjective observation" of what cells are doing.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by tptacek on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:06AM (#20593001)
... and when he tried to explain it, he was wrong, in ways any attentive observer could work out.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Ididntdothis on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:13AM (#20593066)
We should separate observation from explanation. There are plenty of valuable observations made by people and these observations should stand on their own without the observer also having to explain it.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by michrassena on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:07AM (#20593529)
This is something I've noticed as well. As both a client and as an IT troubleshooter, I try to be keenly aware of this distinction. When I'm at the doctor's office, I relay what I've observed, and try to refrain from any speculation of the cause. Likewise, when asked to fix a problem, I try to ignore the explanation the client is offering and focus solely on the observation.

I think it's very easy to get hung up on refuting or confirming the observer's explanation and ignore the observation. For as much as observations are worth, if someone says they saw a strange animal, I might believe them, if they said they saw Bigfoot, I wouldn't, but that's a very good moment to ask questions.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Symmetry on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:58AM (#20593458)
Maxwell's laws continue to work just fine despite Maxwell's explanations for them being complete hookum. If an observation is insufficiently precise the lack of explanation can be a problem. But high quality observation is useful regardless of the explanation for it.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by inimino on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:15AM (#20593083)
...and lives were lost because people couldn't accept a correct procedure with an incorrect explanation.

(Would you only take a cancer drug if the oncologist can explain exactly how it works?)

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by abakker on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:21AM (#20593142)
Off topic, but this is seemingly everything in management. So often, "Doing what feels right" can really pay off from a team/individual happiness POV. But, there is no "methodology" that could justify what I need to have a conversation with someone.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by inimino on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:25AM (#20593175)
Someone once told me the benefit of management theories is that they motivate people to take action, try things, and think.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Ididntdothis on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:26AM (#20593181)
Or they have to come up with some bullshit metric that justifies things.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by vonmoltke on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:00AM (#20593469)
How do you differentiate a correct procedure with an incorrect explanation from an incorrect procedure?
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Ididntdothis on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:42AM (#20593863)
Let’s simplify the question. How do you differentiate an correct procedure from an incorrect procedure? The correct procedure can be observed to work.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by vonmoltke on Friday August 02, 2019 @12:49PM (#20594408)
The correct procedure has been observed to work, but not everything that is observed to work is correct. This is particularly true when "correct" still comes with a probability of failure in specific cases.

Explanations need to be tested to verify they are correct. Incorrect explanations delivered authoritatively lead to bad extrapolations, which in turn lead to incorrect procedures. So, if something has been observed to work but an explanation has not been verified, the proper response at the practitioner level is "This tends to work, but we aren't sure why".

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by inimino on Saturday August 03, 2019 @07:01PM (#20603262)
> The correct procedure has been observed to work, but not everything that is observed to work is correct.

Procedures are neither correct nor incorrect but rather effective or ineffective. Whether the explanation is correct or incorrect is irrelevant if the procedure is effective. Of course we would prefer to have both the effective procedure and the correct explanation but if we insist on only applying procedures with correct explanations we are not doing the best we can.

So, I would extend the proper response to, "This tends to work, we don't know why, but you should try it."

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by inimino on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:09AM (#20593546)
It works.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by timonovici on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:38AM (#20593294)
I have some personal anecdotes that support this to some degree - I have dermatitis, and acne on my forearms - the longer I fast, the less acne I have, and my dermatitis recedes. The effects are very visible, and quite quick, 2 days of fasting will completely clean my scalp.

My father had psoriasis - after a week of fasting, his scabs would completely disappear, even in winter, when he had the worse flare-ups. Even eating healthy, even avoiding all sorts of foods that he knew he was sensitive to (lemons, garlic, spices, etc) didn't have nearly the same effect.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by lazerpants on Friday August 02, 2019 @09:56AM (#20592914)
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by nkozyra on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:01AM (#20592955)
That references this for that mechanism:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC363084/

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Udik on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:02AM (#20592971)
Autophagy is not "cleansing and restoring". We need to stop using these wellness-ad terms like "cleansing", "restoring", "toxins" and "detoxification", "building immunity". Please.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by sk5t on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:19AM (#20593111)
The benefit of seeing the word "toxins" is that the alert reader can be reasonably certain that the rest of the article or ad is baloney.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by yojex on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:23AM (#20593153)
Can you explain what autophagy is and specifically why "cleansing and restoring" are incorrect layman terms to use? I'm curious.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by everdrive on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:40AM (#20593840)
I think if there's any problem with the term "cleansing," it's that too many people have used it in a totally meaningless way, and almost caused the term to drift. This is unfortunate, since it clearly does fit a (more sane) colloquial definition of "cleansing and repairing."
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Udik on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:30AM (#20593228)
Autophagy translates to self-eating. Cleansing and restoring are incorrect terms because they don't describe the process, but our hopes about its outcome.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by samdoidge on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:16AM (#20593097)
How would you describe autophagy in layman's terms?
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by Udik on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:27AM (#20593192)
A controlled self destruction at the cellular level? I'm sure there's many ways to express the concept simply and clearly enough for people to get an idea.

What irks me is the usage of vague but positive terms to indicate what is a neutral, mechanical process. It might have positive impacts in certain circumstances, but if the body were so concerned about "cleansing" and "restoring", it would do it, fasting or not fasting.

Projecting on nature our own intentionality, sense of purpose and good/ bad categories is a pre-scientific attitude.

/rant :)

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by bsanr2 on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:25AM (#20593171)
"Self eat"
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by danepowell on Friday August 02, 2019 @12:21PM (#20594213)
I think they are referring to autophagy, which is upgregulated during fasting.

Sure autophagy is an important process in cellular "cleansing", if you want to use the pop definition here. But more autophagy != good outcomes, generally speaking. For instance, too much autophagy is associated with reduced cellular division and growth.

It sounds like someone just did a s/cleansing toxins/autophagy/ here to make this sound more science-y.

Note, I am NOT saying that there's no value in fasting. There certainly could be. I'm just saying that the article seems to be playing a bit fast and loose with the science.

Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by nine_k on Friday August 02, 2019 @09:59AM (#20592933)
IIRC intestine cells do cleanup and repair mostly when not busy processing food. Intestine is large, and is definitely a lot of work for immune system as an attack surface.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by matwood on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:34AM (#20593796)
Agreed. There is some science around limiting insulin spikes that come with eating is where the benefit comes from. Check out Peter Attia's podcast sometime. He's an MD who reads a tons of research and does a lot of self experimentation (he wears a continuous glucose monitor and meticulously tracks metrics). He's also the first say something isn't conclusive, but based on what he has personally seen in his practice there may be some merit to an idea.
Re:The Fasting Cure Is No Fad by sunstone on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:07AM (#20593010)
It's a Murdoch publication after all. Try not to set your sights too high.