News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by jedberg on Thursday August 01, 2019 @09:18PM (#20589963)
Can someone explain to me what is gained by processing the trades in real time vs. batching the processing into say 1 second increments? What does GS gain by being able to get their trade there a few milliseconds before the competition and what do I as a consumer gain from this?
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by PeterStuer on Friday August 02, 2019 @05:08AM (#20591581)
Think about it this way: When you get new information that according to your trading algo might move the price of a stock and you want to act on it, once you have made the decision you want the time for your order to reach the exchange to be as low as possible as you assume others can have the same info and act to it accordingly.

Not just anyone can have a direct market access connection to an exchange's order book. This is usually reserved to the members of the exchange, and many rules and regulations apply. So even large volume traders use Sponsored Access, transacting directly with the exchange through the access platform of a sponsoring member that ensures not just technical service but most often also some risk and regulatory compliance controls. This service is not provided for free.

GS competes with a few others to provide such an access platform. Reducing the overhead latency of the platform itself in the trade loop makes them more attractive and allows them to attract HFT clients and/or maintain healthy margins.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by harryh on Friday August 02, 2019 @07:42AM (#20592242)
Batching won't solve any problems you might think it would solve. The real world is continuous. Because of this, everyone is incentivized to wait until the last possible millisecond (or nanosecond) before the auction to submit bids so the incentive to build fast acting systems remains.

There are other problems as well, like how to deal with bid/ask imbalances at auction time.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by maximente on Thursday August 01, 2019 @09:49PM (#20590122)
suppose "real time" means order of magnitude milliseconds for example's sake.

the price could change a bunch in that interval of 1000ms. you may think "well only slightly" - fractions of cents - but if GS can make fractions of pennies on those events, scaled up to all seconds that the market is open, you can see why that's potentially attractive.

for whatever it's worth, GS in 2009 claimed that HFT generated <1% of their profits. whether you believe that is another thing.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by jedberg on Friday August 02, 2019 @12:05AM (#20590589)
Ok that explains why they want to do it, but how does it benefit the market to allow that? How does it benefit the consumers and corporations? In other words, what is the argument against creating a law that requires a minimum of 1 second batches for example?
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by denormalfloat on Friday August 02, 2019 @01:58AM (#20590907)
Exchange traded funds depend on special traders who buy the underlying stocks (like AMZN and MSFT), and sell them in exchange for the ETFs (like SPY and VOO). If the individual stocks are more valuable the special traders can buy the ETF shares, exchange them for the individuals, and then sell those for cash. If the ETF is more valuable, they can buy the individual stocks, exchange them for the ETF, and sell the ETF for cash. This is what keeps Index funds matching the underlying index.

Whenever the prices are out of whack, one of the assets can be exchanged for the other. However, there is the concept of tracking error, where by the value of the ETF doesn't track its index. High frequency traders are constantly trying to take advantage of this mismatch (i.e. arbitrage), and as a result the fund's tracking error is moved very close to 0 (i.e. it achieves the goal stated in the prospectus).

Retail investors (like you and me) benefit from this because the price of the index fund is kept in line, and HFT people get to make a little money being keeping it that way. Who would want to make a law that hurts everyone involved by preventing them from entering a mutually beneficial relationship?

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by alkibiades on Friday August 02, 2019 @03:07AM (#20591142)
my question would be how/who does it harm? what is the argument FOR setting that law? other than you think it’s greedy or something?
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by jedberg on Friday August 02, 2019 @12:42PM (#20594372)
I don't care about the greediness, I just care about fairness. Why should GS get the best trades just because they can make a deal to get the shortest ethernet cables?
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by wallace_f on Thursday August 01, 2019 @09:20PM (#20589973)
You don't gain anything.

GS is in an arms race with other fintech firms to be first in line to act on new information.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by denormalfloat on Friday August 02, 2019 @02:12AM (#20590947)
That's not right, you (we) get accurately priced securities. We also get tighter bid-ask spreads.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by wallace_f on Friday August 02, 2019 @05:01AM (#20591554)
Accurately priced securities 100ms faster (which have had any profit opportunity already arbitraged). Grea.t.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by 9HZZRfNlpR on Friday August 02, 2019 @05:29AM (#20591661)
The market is closed so much of the time available for us means we don't need these milliseconds for accurate prices/price-establishing?