News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Plans on Backdooring WhatsApp? by JTbane on Thursday August 01, 2019 @01:56PM (#20586457)
I never understood government overreach like this. Any developer can clone an open source crypto implementation and spin up a new chat app. It is ridiculously stupid to backdoor things.

Unless the government plans to go back to the 80s, in which cryptography is heavily restricted from export, this doesn't accomplish anything.

Re:Facebook Plans on Backdooring WhatsApp? by gnode on Thursday August 01, 2019 @02:21PM (#20586699)
> Any developer can clone an open source crypto implementation and spin up a new chat app.

And they can use it to converse only with themselves. Getting everyone else to stop using their favourite panopticon is the hard part.

Re:Facebook Plans on Backdooring WhatsApp? by kenshaw on Thursday August 01, 2019 @08:43PM (#20589793)
I disagree, and history does not show this to be true. We have been more fickle when it comes to instant messengers than almost any other technology on the face of the planet (pun intended). From IRC, ICQ, AIM, Facebook messages on the website (not Messenger), WhatsApp, Telegram. I count 6 major shifts in the last 19 years. This would indicate that the over/under lifespan of a messenger is roughly 3.5 years.

All it takes is a usable interface, general availability, and a reason to change. If WhatsApp starts doing content moderation, of any form on the client, I am of the strong opinion that users will find this to be "creepy" and will immediately start shifting. As it is, all of my technical contacts have already left WhatsApp for Telegram. Since that group/audience has been the bellwether for all of the previous instant messaging client shifts over the last 2 decades, I imagine it's only time before "everyone else" also shifts off WhatsApp. I don't necessarily think it will be Telegram, but they definitely have the most momentum today when compared to, eg, Line, Zalo, Viber, Kik, et al.

Re:Facebook Plans on Backdooring WhatsApp? by kelnos on Thursday August 01, 2019 @03:36PM (#20587455)
> Unless the government plans to go back to the 80s, in which cryptography is heavily restricted from export, this doesn't accomplish anything.

That wouldn't accomplish anything now, anyway. All the current best crypto we have is out in the world, and plenty of crypto research happens outside the US. If the US revived the export restrictions, it wouldn't have much effect on the rest of the world.

Re:Facebook Plans on Backdooring WhatsApp? by ryacko on Thursday August 01, 2019 @02:18PM (#20586662)
I’ve always interpreted the various Crypto Wars as distractions.

It is a bizarre paradox where designing a secure system is a hard problem, where zero-days are commonly cheaper than brute forcing a 64-bit key, while cryptography is chronically lambasted.