News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Noam Chomsky: Life Expectancy in the US Is Declining for ... by tgragnato on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:22AM (#20552793)
> Half the population has negative net worth, meaning debts outweigh assets. There has been stagnation pretty much for the workforce over the whole neoliberal period. That’s the group that we’re talking about. Naturally, this leads to anger, resentment, desperation. Similar things are happening in Europe under the austerity programs. That’s the background for what’s misleadingly called “populism.”

The way Chomsky thinks (and expresses himself) is always fascinating. The linguistic background is as evident as his political activism, perhaps a tad uncomfortable for conformists.

Re:Noam Chomsky: Life Expectancy in the US Is Declining for ... by everdrive on Monday July 29, 2019 @02:01PM (#20557419)
> perhaps a tad uncomfortable for conformists

I hope you're not implying that conformists being uncomfortable with an argument somehow lends a weight to the validity of the argument.

Re:Noam Chomsky: Life Expectancy in the US Is Declining for ... by tgragnato on Monday July 29, 2019 @03:19PM (#20558333)
No.

Part of the work of a linguist is to try understand why people use one term rather than another, often this happens because a word is associated with a particular idea rather than another: a different speech may imply a different acceptation or a different nuance.

These linguistic differences are obviously related to the set of beliefs, social habits, routines of the individual or set of people in analysis.

I simply believe that it can be extremely unnerving to be criticised by a linguist like Chomsky, who in this step uses his skills to highlight the imbalances and logical internal inconsistencies (the wrongful usage of the word "populism") of the neoliberal political thought to favour his worldview (political activism).

It's a critical point of view that's difficult to find in other figures, and one of the reasons why I follow his ideas, because whether you agree or not he offers another perspective.

Re:Noam Chomsky: Life Expectancy in the US Is Declining for ... by yostrovs on Monday July 29, 2019 @08:00AM (#20553577)
It would be nice for him to stick to topics he's an expert in. Though considering he's a "word" guy, he does know how to manipulate language to achieve his goals.
Re:Noam Chomsky: Life Expectancy in the US Is Declining for ... by avmich on Monday July 29, 2019 @10:30AM (#20554969)
I'd assume that for long time he's an expert in much more than linguistics. Even his colleagues from computer world still assume he's only a linguist, but a man can learn.
Re:Noam Chomsky: Life Expectancy in the US Is Declining for ... by tracer4201 on Monday July 29, 2019 @11:53AM (#20555884)
When you say he should stick to topics he is an expert in, do you have issue with something specific he’s saying or is it that this information conflicts with your personal beliefs or politics?
Re:Noam Chomsky: Life Expectancy in the US Is Declining for ... by tangue on Monday July 29, 2019 @12:55PM (#20556699)
> "It would be nice for him to stick to topics he's an expert in" Well if everybody sticks to his/her own expertise that would mean the end of HN ... And I'm not even talking about twitter.
Re:Noam Chomsky: Life Expectancy in the US Is Declining for ... by chacha2 on Monday July 29, 2019 @02:19PM (#20557629)
He´s the leading expert at this.