Re:Escape the scripter mentality if reliability matters (2011)
by kd5bjo on Saturday July 27, 2019 @12:24PM
(#20542702)
The task as described included an easy for a human but tricky for a computer verification that the correct word will always be a color. Given this, and the need for the system to be tolerant against human error occurring at the paper, I believe a typical untrained human will have a better reliability on this task than almost any automated system.
But in the general case you’re absolutely right: any analysis like this should include the costs and probability of faults occurring in each option.
Re:Escape the scripter mentality if reliability matters (2011)
by andrewflnr on Saturday July 27, 2019 @03:36PM
(#20543711)
Sure, but maybe the assistant gets distracted by other work, or gets sick and don't get a chance to make sure someone else does it, or quits because their boss is a jerk, or any number of other things going wrong. At least a few of these will happen over the course of two years.
Your analysis ignores the cost of failure to get the right word, or maybe just assumes the office assistant is infallible. That cost is almost certainly non-zero, and might be much higher than the whole development cost.