Re:Pioneer manipulates scores to pick winners
by loresome on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:23AM
(#20535458)
If you look at the last image in the post, you will see that "expert" votes have little correlation with points.
Re:Pioneer manipulates scores to pick winners
by C4stor on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:31AM
(#20535516)
I don't see anything like that. In that last image, in the same column "not in top 10" there's the project ranked #3 on the image above, and the project ranked #17.
In this image, two projects mention being upvoted by an "expert", and the two are in the top 10 indeed.
Overall, I find that the evidence fails to convey the point, I may be wrong and the case is strong but right now, I don't think it's convincing that anything shady is happening.
I'm not surprised that the ultimate choice of giving out money is closely guarded, because the very little amount of voting happening makes it very sensible to fraud. (When a photo of an egg can get 20 million likes on twitter, basing a contest on handfuls of votes would seem a bit...naive.)
Re:Pioneer manipulates scores to pick winners
by loresome on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:36AM
(#20535559)
The second project that was upvoted by an "expert" (GreenGovernance) is at #20.
That is not necessarily a bad thing. If the experts were highly correlated with what the rankings already were, there would be no point in using them. You want as many independent inputs as possible; the more correlated they are, the more redundant they are.
Re:Pioneer manipulates scores to pick winners
by loresome on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:30AM
(#20535512)
What I tried to say is: you can't explain the points manipulation with "experts", because "experts" changed little in that regard, as can be seen on that screenshot.
Re:Pioneer manipulates scores to pick winners
by ubercore on Friday July 26, 2019 @03:04PM
(#20537463)
But, it's not in the page describing the tournament: https://pioneer.app/tournament
> How will you select the winners?
The final step in the tournament has our experts providing a final review on the top applications, based on leaderboard rankings. After their votes have been applied to the leaderboard, we select the top-scoring players as Pioneers. We're experimenting with the number of winners per-week, so cohorts will vary in size.
So, yes, the leaderboard is manually updated following the "experts" recommandations. It's in the FAQ.