loresome
Edit: re-read your comment more carefully. To answer: because the exchange was not productive. I only saw general comments equating to "you don't understand our opaque system" without even acknowledging the arguments I was making.
To add to my previous comment. What separates "expert voting" from "leaderboard manipulation" the most in my opinion is the access to the leaderboard state. If experts vote in isolation, based solely on the project info and reports it's a "mixture of signals". If they have unlimited power, and change the scores to shape the leaderboard to a desirable state, it's manipulation.
I would suggest these three things: (1) separate the concept of "experts" and "organizers/developers". When I hear "experts" I assume "independent experts". (2) change deceiving language on the landing page. Quoting: "All you need to do is convince other participants that your project is worth doing." and "Every week other participants will give you feedback and points. The more progress you make, the higher your score will be." No mention of experts, yet alone organizers at all. (3) Make the points transparent. That includes breaking down voting vs experts vs whatever and disclosing the details of the scoring and matchmaking systems. Doesn't have to be exact spec/formula obviously, but general details.
Pioneer tournament for projects – a player's perspective
Ask HN: I want to share my experience with Pioneer, what should I write?
Hey fellow Hackers! I've been playing Pioneer (https://pioneer.app/join/bethechange), a weekly online tournament for projects (of any kind, from local charity to blockchain), for a few months now, and it's been an amazing motivation boost and a focusing tool for me and the project. I honestly think that anyone working on a side-project or a small startup with ambitious goals should try...
In fact, the API already exists, it's just not documented.
No, currently there are no limits, and I don't plan to add any. First, it's really boring and tiresome to grind the rewards, and second, there's nothing to get out of it apart from the feeling of guilt.
Perhaps some messaging stating the points above can also prevent cheating. Thanks for your feedback!