Re:When Mesmerism Came to America
by RangerScience on Friday July 26, 2019 @05:15PM
(#20538383)
"Just because it's all in your head doesn't mean it isn't real"
Re:When Mesmerism Came to America
by shanemhansen on Friday July 26, 2019 @06:46PM
(#20539018)
As someone who used meditation to reduce opioid usage post surgery, I agree.
If the effect is all in my head but it works, then who cares if it's all in my head?
What is the effect of holding onto iron bars in a water bath?
This article helps explain, with illustrations. It is very good!
The mechanism of mesmerism was disproven by the Ben Franklin committee -- there is no "vital force", akin to a magnetic force, that a mesmerist taps into. Nevertheless, the Franklin committee didn't dispute the effects of mesmerism. As a placebo effect, it is a particularly strong one. Placebo effects often comprise the greater part of accepted medical psychotherapies. While the esoteric/ magical qualities of mesmerism may make rationalists shudder, if it worked well (it did) we might still learn from it.