News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by miahi on Friday July 26, 2019 @06:39AM (#20533782)
The title is incorrect. The Schengen Information System does not keep data for "all EU citizens", it only keeps such data for wanted persons, missing/stolen identity documents or objects (like cars, boats and so on).

There is no centralized database for EU citizens photos or fingerprints (not even at national level in many countries).

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by sctb on Friday July 26, 2019 @01:58PM (#20536819)
Thanks, we've updated the title from the submitted “Photos and fingerprints of all EU citizens copied from the UK to the US”.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by pknight on Friday July 26, 2019 @06:47AM (#20533809)
>There is no centralized database for EU citizens photos or fingerprints (not even at national level in many countries).

"The database will aggregate the details of more than 350 million people, including their identifying information, such as names, passport number, dates of birth, as well as biometrics like fingerprints and facial scans."

https://www.computing.co.uk/ctg/news/3074472/eu-parliament-v...

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by ptaipale on Friday July 26, 2019 @08:43AM (#20534314)
>"will aggregate"

This was an announced intention in April this year. The implementation of this decision probably needs further approvals and ratifications, and even after that, it takes time. The source material does not even exist, and I expect that in some EU countries collecting this data of all citizens will not be possible due to country legislation. Thus this is certainly far from complete, if even started at all.

It's safe to say that there is no database of 350 million EU citizens' fingerprints that anyone could copy.

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by dangerface on Friday July 26, 2019 @09:23AM (#20534573)
So we should wait until every one's details are leaked before deciding this is a bad idea because it will inevitably leak?

This is like the police refusing to respond to death threats until the person is dead.

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by IanCal on Friday July 26, 2019 @09:51AM (#20534775)
What they seem to be saying is not that the data hasn't leaked, but that it likely does not even exist. If that's true, a headline of "X has been copied" would be wrong if X didn't exist.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by dangerface on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:12AM (#20535386)
The data does exist, and they are and have been collating it into one super database according to the article pknight posted. So I go back to my argument:

> So we should wait until every one's details are leaked before deciding this is a bad idea because it will inevitably leak?

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by ptaipale on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:58AM (#20535744)
You claim the data does exist - but where did it come from? There has been no program to forcibly collect fingerprints of all EU citizens. There is some biometric data collected for Schengen passports, but not even close to all people even have a passport. And if you claim my biometric passport fingerprints are in that DB, you are claiming that the police in my country has performed a massive illegal data handover. If you have evidence of that, give it - heads will roll.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by miahi on Friday July 26, 2019 @01:24PM (#20536450)
For most countries, biometric passport data is only stored inside the passport's chip and not in a (national or otherwise) database. It's to be used by border control (of other countries) to compare the person presenting the passport with the (signed) data.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by AdrianB1 on Friday July 26, 2019 @05:25PM (#20538462)
For Romania, it is in a national database. Source: family member that is a high ranking policeman, he checked my records and there is more than I thought, having a perfectly clean criminal record.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by loopbit on Friday July 26, 2019 @12:29PM (#20535997)
Maybe that data doesn't exist in your country.

In mine, the police has the picture and fingerprints of everyone older than 12 years old and any younger person that needed an ID card for whatever reason, travelling being just one.

Maybe that information has been shared with that database, maybe it hasn't. I have no way of knowing. Other EU countries have the same level of information about their citizens (and some record even more data).

Can we simply agree that what the UK has done is bad, should be investigated and, if true, the people resposible should face charges for it? Or should we spend days arguing about what information might/might not have been copied and how many people have been afected?

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by Symbiote on Friday July 26, 2019 @08:02PM (#20539366)
I'm downvoting all the comments about "my country" without saying which country that is.

No useful discussion can result from comments like this.

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by loopbit on Sunday July 28, 2019 @03:00PM (#20549225)
A bit late to the discussion, but does it really change that much if, instead of "my country", I say "Spain"?

In this case Spain hasn't done anything wrong (the data gathering for the id cards was done before entering the EU and complies with EU's regulations[0]). Other EU countries gather less or more data according to their specific legislations.

The country in question here is the UK and, to a lesser extent, the US. Specifics about other EU countries are, IMHO, irrelevant.

[0] Another question, for a different discussion, is if they should record all that data.

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by jobigoud on Friday July 26, 2019 @10:12AM (#20534929)
They are just saying the title should not contain the word "all". The linked tweet doesn't contain it either.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by ptaipale on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:26AM (#20535486)
No. That is not what I wrote, nor is it what I implied.

I simply mean that the claim about fingerprints of 350 M EU citizens copied cannot be true.

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by dangerface on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:32AM (#20535524)
The EU has been collecting fingerprints since 2004, they do have that data.

https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-eu-fingerprints/fingerprin...

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by sequence7 on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:54AM (#20535706)
That link does not describe the EU collecting fingerprints it just reports that their is an EU requirement for passports to contain biometic data. The EU do not collect or store that data national governments do.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by ptaipale on Friday July 26, 2019 @12:00PM (#20535767)
No. That link does not say so. Biometric passport data is collected by national goverments, not EU.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by jammygit on Friday July 26, 2019 @01:48PM (#20536685)
I received written death threats (letters cut and pasted from various papers) once and the police ignored it. I got attacked a week later
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by yaris on Friday July 26, 2019 @06:51AM (#20533823)
The link suggests that this was announced in April this year. Do you think all the necessary DBs have already been connected? I would expect it to happen next year earliest.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by pknight on Friday July 26, 2019 @07:11AM (#20533885)
I suspect it's nowhere near live yet, but it's relevant to this topic. There will be a massive new database and it's a terribly unlikely that this data will not be leaked or shared at some point.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by powi88nxjdi on Friday July 26, 2019 @09:07AM (#20534463)
So what if it was announced in April?

Do we really believe we ca trust these groups with this data?

This is like the Vogons justifying blowing up a planet because the paperwork was filed years ago.

It’s not about the details. It’s about trust in institutions and I’m pretty sure we can see we should have none with these official bodies and the corporate buddies they give our work away to

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by tinus_hn on Friday July 26, 2019 @10:12AM (#20534934)
The Dutch version of this database supposedly only keeps data of people associated with serious crimes. It has 1.3 million people (all of the Netherlands has about 17 million). These supposed restrictions are just a ruse.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by bonjurkes on Friday July 26, 2019 @09:21AM (#20534556)
It also includes information of 3rd world country citizens'. Like passport info, photos, fingerprints, their visit to Schengen countries.

When you apply for visa for Schengen countries, your info will be recorded on SIS. And stored there for 5 years.

Note: EU uses the term "3rd world country" term themselves and Im citizen of one of those countries.

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by cromulent on Friday July 26, 2019 @10:03AM (#20534860)
The EU uses the term "third country" which means a country that is not part of the union.

https://www.eurofound.europa.eu/observatories/eurwork/indust...

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by nmstoker on Friday July 26, 2019 @10:21AM (#20534983)
Well done posting that link. This topic seems to have brought out a lot of (unnecessary) confusion in the comments!
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by stordoff on Friday July 26, 2019 @10:01AM (#20534850)
Do you mean "Third country"? I have not come across the EU using "Third world country" officially.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by cat199 on Friday July 26, 2019 @10:15AM (#20534958)
not to mention that eu+us+uk does not equal the so-called '1st world' in it's entirety (see also: canada, japan), and also that there is some notion of a '2nd world' as well.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by ricudis on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:16AM (#20535407)
The confusion stems from the fact that most people perceive it as a "measure of economic development", while in fact it's political cold war terminology:

First world = US + close allies Second world = USSR + close allies Third world = Everybody else

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by mktmkr on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:48AM (#20535651)
Switzerland was third world under this definition?
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by nickserv on Friday July 26, 2019 @12:01PM (#20535781)
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by miahi on Friday July 26, 2019 @09:46AM (#20534742)
There is no visa information in the SIS, you are probably referring to a different system (maybe VIS). Yes, when you apply for visa you will probably be _searched_ in the SIS, but this will happen many times in the EU anyway (or even before approaching the EU - likely when boarding a flight to an EU country).
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by rasz on Friday July 26, 2019 @08:53AM (#20534381)
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by throwaway744678 on Friday July 26, 2019 @08:36AM (#20534268)
Regarding fingerprints, let's not forget that non-police system (eg. biometric passports) only register a subset of flat prints. On French passports, only two fingers are saved, and the prints are 'flat' - not rolled . Those are usable as a verification (is the holder of the document the actual owner?), but would prove very hard to use to identify someone out of a crowd (whose prints are on this gun/knife/glass?).
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by tapland on Friday July 26, 2019 @08:55AM (#20534401)
Passports are only handled by the police in some EU-countries, but I guess they use the same fingerprint rules.
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by zoobab on Friday July 26, 2019 @09:05AM (#20534456)
Is it enough to remove the "all"?

I understand not all EU citizens were in the database.

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by miahi on Friday July 26, 2019 @10:34AM (#20535084)
I would say it's more generic than that. Not all the data is for EU citizens, and not all the data has photos and fingerprints. What dangerface quoted from the euobserver[1] seems to be the best approach, maybe make it shorter... As I said in another comment, I would emphasize more on the "classified" than "personal information", but that's only me (I would say Facebook has way more info on "normal" people than what's in the SIS database).

There's also the issue of "copied to US", which was not demonstrated. It's really hard to keep all the US companies out of the SIS when you are using an Oracle database.

I would put it like this: "UK made illegal copies of classified personal information from the Schengen Information System"

[1] https://euobserver.com/justice/145530

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by wuliwong on Friday July 26, 2019 @09:36AM (#20534656)
That would seem fine. Possibly add a reference to the Schengen Information System to be specific?
Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by powi88nxjdi on Friday July 26, 2019 @09:05AM (#20534454)
Ok so it’s not all EU citizens

What’s more interesting to me is in the Tweet: UK made illegals copies of hundreds of millions of people’s data (since you were mostly hung up on that, I qualified it better).

Are you seeing the interesting takeaway?

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by miahi on Friday July 26, 2019 @10:04AM (#20534868)
Another (small) correction: There aren't hundred of millions persons registered in the SIS. The "hundred of millions" comes from the number of EU citizens. Of course, one person's data leaked is too many, but anyway, that's how it is. Also, most of the person alerts do not have binaries (photos or fingerprints); usually only the persons that have an European Arrest Warrant do have these.

I see this as more of a security issue than a privacy issue. The data in the SIS is mostly about law enforcement, meaning that a leak would expose that a person is wanted (some of the person searches are undercover, and the data also covers a person's aliases - so if a "bad" person has access to the data it can react) and also, the SIS data is a "living" organism - using a copy (snapshot) of the data in a law enforcement activity is actually unlawful - if the snapshot is old it means that you cannot find a person that was added yesterday and also that you will find a person that was "cleared" yesterday.

Re:The UK authorities made illegal copies of the Schengen In... by wuliwong on Friday July 26, 2019 @09:43AM (#20534713)
HN self-polices the titles here pretty well. Correcting inaccurate titles is a regular occurrence on HN. I think it leads to a much better user experience. Wanting an accurate headline on HN does not have to conflate to a person not understanding or disagreeing with the linked content. It can just be a representation of an overall goal of the HN community to keep headlines accurate.