News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on A "cure" for baldness could be around the corner. Parent comment

Re:A "cure" for baldness could be around the corner by equalunique on Friday July 26, 2019 @05:14AM (#20533437)
Simply being tall requires a higher caloric intake, and thus puts tall people at a disadvantage. The genes for tall stature do not express themselves when that higher food intake is not present during developmental stages. Tall people are more a phenomena of advanced agriculture than natural selection. They are not necessarily more formitable, but are rather a larger target, or a clumsier hunter. Evolutionarily, being tall means a lifetime of above-average access to food, and while that's desireable in a mate, it's just as much about the environment one lives in as it is the genes one's born with.
[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:A "cure" for baldness could be around the corner by Someone on Friday July 26, 2019 @07:32AM (#20533954)
”The genes for tall stature do not express themselves when that higher food intake is not present during developmental stages.”

So, it seems tall ⇒ was well-fed in his youth ⇒ must be from a rich family ⇒ will provide for my children well ⇒ attractive.

I don’t claim it did, but I do not see a reason evolution couldn’t pick up such an indirect correlation.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:A "cure" for baldness could be around the corner by jamesrcole on Friday July 26, 2019 @06:17AM (#20533682)
> Simply being tall requires a higher caloric intake, and thus puts tall people at a disadvantage

This is assuming that food intake is the only factor contributing to fitness. There are other possibilities. E.g. taller (larger) males may have advantages in competing with other males for mates, and thus be better at spreading their genes. Females who preferred such males would thus be better at spreading their genes down the generations.

> Evolutionarily, being tall means a lifetime of above-average access to food, and while that's desireable in a mate, it's just as much about the environment one lives in as it is the genes one's born with.

Evolution doesn't only concern the genes, as if environmental factors were distinct from evolution. Fitness is always a function of both genes and the environment.

[ Parent | on HN ]