News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by pragmatic on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:22AM (#2052370)
I think we've gone a little crazy with the censorship word. This guy can print his book somewhere else and distribute it.

Amazon (a private company) has decided they don't want these books on it's platform (for whatever reason).

Now if the gov't said Amazon had to take these down, that's a problem. But that's not what happened.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by citricsquid on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:23AM (#2052378)
It seems the internet has gone crazy on entitlement recently.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:33AM (#2052409)
It's not entitlement.

Now, hear me out. If I'm going to spend money somewhere, I'd like to know that the company I'm spending it with is acting in a way that I find ethical. In fact, I'd like to hold them to a higher standard, since it's so much easier for companies to have moral failings than it is people.

> Censorship is suppression of speech or other communication which may be considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, or inconvenient to the general body of people as determined by a government, media outlet, or other controlling body. - Wikipedia

Amazon is acting as a censor. Now, it's not illegal. But I do find it to be distasteful. So I'd rather not support them. This article is one of a few lately that lets me know that Amazon and I are apparently looking at the world in a different way, and so I shouldn't patronize them anymore.

Finally, it's incredibly important to hold these companies to a higher standard as they grow larger, because they become more and more influential. Most of my local bookstores have closed, and while there are other places to buy books online, I don't have the same relationship with them as I once did with Amazon. Now I'm in the process of checking out alternatives, but still: Amazon has become synonymous with "buying a book on the Internet."

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by CodeMage on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:40AM (#2052433)
Let me put it this way: let's say I own a chain of shops selling stuff for gardening and you want me to carry a product that consists of your turd in a plastic bag. No matter how much you insist it has its place in my fertilizer section, I'm not obliged to pick it up and sell it.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by Bud on Friday December 31, 2010 @03:58PM (#2056435)
Let's say you own a company that has driven most of the book industry out of business, and you suddenly decide to let Roger Ailes and Rupert Murdoch decide what books are ok for you to sell, and what books aren't.

You honestly think for a millisecond that there isn't a major free speech issue brewing here? Think again. Borders is about to collapse and even more bookstore deaths are imminent. Amazon already controls a huge chunk of book sales; soon, it could be 50% or more of the industry.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by drinian on Thursday December 30, 2010 @12:47PM (#2052911)
That's not the best comparison if we're talking about digital books, which take up nothing but a tiny amount of hard-disk space to "stock."

I seem to remember that Amazon was named after the river with the most volume in the world, a pun on their universal selection of books. Why change that now?

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:43AM (#2052442)
No, I'm saying that if your company does something that I don't like, I'm not going to shop there.

Amazon is totally allowed to not carry someone's book because they think the content is in poor taste. And I am totally allowed to patronize someone else.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by CodeMage on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:51AM (#2052473)
That's okay, I understand that part of your point and completely agree with it. I'm just arguing against the claim that what they do is censorship.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:53AM (#2052483)
I think what this really boils down to is that we have slightly different views about what the word means, and at what point private individuals become powerful enough for these kinds of things to matter.

My (theoretical) mom's corner bookstore can't effectively be a censor. Yeah, it sucks if she doesn't carry a book, and it's still a bad thing that she's doing, but Amazon, doing the same act but at scale, is a totally different story. There's context that makes this important.

Littering is a bummer. Oil spills are a disaster.

Also, this isn't time #1 where Amazon has come out and done something like this. It's starting to become a growing pattern that I'm becoming increasingly uncomfortable with.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by coderdude on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:48AM (#2052462)
You change your tune depending on who you reply to. In one statement they're censoring books and controlling the dissemination of information. Here you're saying Amazon is totally allowed to not carry someone's book, and that all that means is you won't shop there.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:51AM (#2052476)
There's a difference between legality and morality.

Amazon is permitted by the rule of law to do this.

I consider it immoral. Discriminating books based on content is the same thing as discriminating packets based on content.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by coderdude on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:02AM (#2052509)
If it is simply immoral to you then why all these goings on about censorship and controlling the dissemination of information? By the way, your end piece about books and packets is incorrect. They are not alike at all and the motivations to "discriminate" against packets is very different from any motivation to discriminate against books. If anything, no one is charging you more to read the book with the title about rape than they are to let you read Charles Dickens.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:09AM (#2052529)
Maybe I need to drink more coffee, or I shouldn't write things in the morning.

It's immoral to me because they're censoring information based on the content that it contains. And it's not a one-time incident, it's starting to become a pattern. At their size, I think that it's important that they are neutral to the content of the information.

The company's motivations for packet discrimination may be different, but my reason for being against it is the same: I don't think content should be discriminated against.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by middlegeek on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:17AM (#2052564)
"is acting in a way that I find ethical."

"But I do find it to be distasteful."

"hold these companies to a higher standard"

Quotes from your comment. Are you aware the title of the book is "How To Rape A Straight Guy"? I mean the book could be about bunnies and rainbows and cuddly kittens, but if I owned a business I am not sure I would want to sell a product that seemed to advocate an illegal, unethical and (universally deemed) immoral act, even if it did not and the title was just for shock value.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:20AM (#2052575)
Yes, I am. I don't consider it wrong to discuss any particular topic.

And, while I haven't read into this particular book, the author says that the title is simply a troll. More investigation would be needed from either side to determine if the book is any good or not, but I don't really care if it is or not.

As the author points out, Amazon already caries a litany of materials that describe and depict other immoral acts in graphic detail, including rape.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by coderdude on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:36AM (#2052418)
Talk about being melodramatic.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:39AM (#2052425)
The control of dissemination of information is one of the most important things there is, full stop. I am not being melodramatic.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by bambax on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:53AM (#2052482)
> Amazon and I are apparently looking at the world in a different way

I don't think Amazon is looking at the world in any specific way. Amazon listens to whoever shouts louder.

Unfortunately, people who want to ban books (for whatever reason) are much more vocal and much better organized than people who would rather not ban any book.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by middlegeek on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:18AM (#2052568)
Amazon is not banning the book, they are a private business that chooses not to carry a product whose title seems to (even though the contents do not) advocate rape.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:56AM (#2052489)
That's true. It's difficult not to anthropomorphize in these kinds of discussions.

Regardless, that's why I'm trying to be vocal.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by nopal on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:26AM (#2052385)
It's still censorship, and some would prefer not to support businesses that arbitrarily censor speech.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by nopal on Thursday December 30, 2010 @12:03PM (#2052718)
I wanted to post an addendum. While I still hold that Amazon's actions are censorship, I do agree that they're within their rights to censor certain content and I believe they have to do so at certain times in order to maintain their image and appeal.

From the description of the books given by the author, I don't think Amazon should have removed these books, but I understand why they did. Amazon needs to fight the perception that it's a purveyor of sickening material. Amazon could choose to take a stand for the First Amendment without regard to the loss of business, it could do so in hopes that it's position would attract new customers, or it can do what it's doing now. Each option has a valid argument. Ultimately Amazon has to do what it thinks is right, and as a business, that generally means doing what will have the least negative impact on profits. Fair enough. If Amazon's actions aren't acceptable to some, then those people can shop elsewhere or band together to give Amazon incentive to shift their policy.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by middlegeek on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:27AM (#2052388)
"Censorship is suppression of speech or other communication which may be considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, or inconvenient to the general body of people as determined by a government, media outlet, or other controlling body."

It's not censorship.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by jerf on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:50AM (#2052469)
You're not playing the "cite a definition" game correctly. You neglected to include the reference to the presumably-a-dictionary you used. How am I supposed to go back to the same work, cite another subdefinition that has about a 50-50 chance of actually applying, and then argue that I'm correct while simultaneously invoking some half-assed "Amazon is really a newspaper, or maybe something involving cars" metaphor? The Internet has a well defined protocol for this dance!

Anyhow, trying to shut things down by definition only works in mathematics. Redefining away what Amazon as "not censorship" won't mollify anybody, as they can still choose to be legitimately annoyed at the perfectly legal and arguably perfectly ethical actions Amazon have taken. Acting legally and even ethically doesn't mean you have the right to not be criticized.

And, seeing as how if this is "not censorship" we don't actually have an English word for what it is... yeah, it's censorship. It's not government censorship, but it's censorship. It's also a sufficiently different kind of censorship that simply knee-jerk applying our attitudes towards government censorship may not be relevant, but English simply doesn't have the granularity to deal with this. That's OK. Everything works that way anyhow.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by middlegeek on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:03AM (#2052514)
The first result on a Google search, but feel free to pick your favorite as the test still stands: http://www.google.com/search?q=censorship&ie=utf-8&o...

Amazon is a media outlet but they are not suppressing his speech. They are not stopping him from publishing the work or even stopping him from writing it. They are choosing not to distribute it. Thus the suppression test fails and it is not censorship.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by CodeMage on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:59AM (#2052501)
Okay, we don't have an English word for it, we have to use two words instead: quality control. Just because someone decided to publish a book, it doesn't mean Amazon must sell it.

You can address that issue the same way author did it, by stating that Amazon sells stuff like "Hostel 2". Frankly, I haven't read the guys book and I haven't read Amazon's quality control policy (or whatever it's called) either, so I can't say whether the book fails the test. My point here is that most people commenting here can't say that either, for the same reasons. So why are some people so quick to side with the author and cry "censorship", when it might just be that his book is crap?

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by nopal on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:31AM (#2052403)
I read that before I posted. Amazon's the controlling body in this case. The controlling body need not have authority over the censored, e.g. media outlet.

People have been complaining about Walmart censoring media for years. I don't see how this is any different.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by middlegeek on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:40AM (#2052431)
They are a media outlet but it is not suppression. They are not stopping him from publishing that work and they are not stopping him from writing it. They are simply not taking part in the distribution.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by nopal on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:56AM (#2052491)
I don't think we're going to agree on this, but one of the definitions of suppression is, "the act of withholding or withdrawing some book or writing from publication or circulation; 'a suppression of the newspaper'."

Amazon is withdrawing these items from circulation.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by middlegeek on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:10AM (#2052533)
"Amazon is withdrawing these items from circulation."

They are not withdrawing it from circulation. THEY are choosing to not circulate it themselves. The author can circulate it where ever he likes as long as it is not Amazon. If Amazon was the only place that sold books I would be with you.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:34AM (#2052410)
> media outlet
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by middlegeek on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:41AM (#2052434)
(As previously posted) They are a media outlet but it is not suppression. They are not stopping him from publishing that work and they are not stopping him from writing it. They are simply not taking part in the distribution.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by bambax on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:56AM (#2052495)
It is censorship.

It's not enough to say that "it's a private company, it should be left to do as it pleases" (as the counter-argument goes). In many other domains there are rules enforcing general principles, especially for private companies. Employment is one of them.

A company cannot say "since, as a private company I should be free to make my own employment policies, I'll just engage in race discrimination".

Just the same, the First amendment should be enforced for private companies.

If your business is helping anyone publish content, then it should not be possible for you to filter out content or authors based on your own private rules/opinions.

Anything that's legal is acceptable -- and the legality is decided by a court of law.

I'm quite optimistic we'll get there eventually, but it'll take time and effort.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by skymt on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:43AM (#2052443)
I think the pedophile-guide incident has Amazon paranoid. Amazon has a huge task ahead of it in both shifting the publishing world to e-books and maintaining their lead in that market. They decided they can't afford negative publicity right now: unfortunate, but entirely understandable.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by middlegeek on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:26AM (#2052386)
This isn't censorship. They are not suppressing his speech, they are choosing not to disseminate it.

Another thing, if the title of your book talks about raping someone, some people are going to find it offensive and some businesses are not going to want to put it on their shelves.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by jbillingsley on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:25AM (#2052381)
Now you can see why the government wants to privatize everything. If it's a private institution they can infringe upon your rights however they like.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by steveklabnik on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:36AM (#2052420)
Upvoted. Corporations are regulated significantly less, and as they become more and more powerful, it becomes more important to pay attention to what they're doing.

> Italian Fascism and most other fascist movements promote a corporatist economy whereby, in theory, representatives of capital and labour interest groups work together within sectoral corporations to create both harmonious labour relations and maximization of production that would serve the national interest. - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facism

(EDIT: I do take small issue with 'governments wanting to privatize.' I don't think the government does at all. Other interests, yes. The point still stands.)

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by pmichaud on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:30AM (#2052400)
Based on the titles alone I was tempted to side with Amazon on this, but if you read further, you find that these are novels that probably have redeeming value. I don't know about the quality of writing, but the content isn't any more pornographic than a romance novel or slasher flick.
Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by VMG on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:39AM (#2052426)
I think this is the subject of the discussion:

http://www.buy.com/prod/how-to-rape-a-straight-guy/q/loc/106...

> Curt has been beaten, betrayed and brutalized by just about everyone he's known. And his mother - once a prostitute, now "born-again" and married - has banned him from the family. But six years in prison taught him a lot - including how to force straight cons to ejaculate as he rapes them, and how that can be a very satisfying method of revenge. Now he's out and trying to stay straight, but problems with his marriage and zero prospects of earning money enough to live on make that almost impossible. It's while he's hustling two gay men in a bar one afternoon that he mentions what he's done in prison. . .and the bet comes up.It seems the men, Wayne and Lenny, want a little revenge of their own against someone who's caused them trouble. If Curt can make this one "straight" guy "get off" while being assaulted, they'll give him a car, cash and a chance at a new life. Being in the mood to do some damage, Curt agrees and they start laying their plans. But step-by-step, Curt realizes things are getting out of control, and he has no one to pull him back from the abyss. And a stupid little bet is threatening to plunge him headlong into disaster.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by Bud on Thursday December 30, 2010 @09:57AM (#2052296)
It's not going to be a good world if Fox News is allowed to intimidate Amazon into censoring whatever it finds inappropriate.

Not at all.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by lotusleaf1987 on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:49AM (#2052463)
Amazon doesn't care what Fox News says, they're doing this because it makes good economic sense. More people will be angry at Amazon for them selling it than there will be those angered at its removal.

So Risk > Reward.

And anyways wouldn't Fox News be the one defending the guy? They seem to always take the tea party side which the author would almost certainly be on.

Re:Even More Amazon Censorship by angrycoder on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:52AM (#2052478)
> "How To Rape A Straight Guy" has a very provocative title, yes

I would say it did its job of provoking then.